This Chesterton Quote Has Been Altered and Taken Out of Context

This Chesterton Quote Has Been Altered and Taken Out of Context July 12, 2018

I’ve seen the following image shared in many of my Facebook groups lately:

Now, I am a huge fan of G.K. Chesterton — I was confirmed into Catholicism on his birthday, and I love his writings so much that I named one of my sons after him — but I don’t agree with everything he has ever written. He does have some things to say about working mothers that aren’t complimentary, for example.

After seeing the above image for the fifth or sixth time, however, I decided to look up the source so I could read the quote its proper context. It took a while, as the quote has proliferated quite freely but very few bothered to cite the actual work it was from. Finally, though, I tracked it down.

As it turns out — and I’m not altogether surprised at this, although I am ashamed at myself for initially assuming it was accurate — the creator of the meme took the quote entirely out of context and added a word that isn’t present, WITHOUT using brackets to signify the replacement. In other words, she is being deliberately misleading.

The quote comes from G.K. Chesterton’s essay “Social Reform versus Birth Control,” published in 1927.

Here is the quote in context, with the relevant portion bolded:

There is of course a great deal more to be said. I have dealt with only one feature of Birth Control–its exceedingly unpleasant origin. I said it was purely capitalist and reactionary; I venture to say I have proved it was entirely capitalist and reactionary. But there are many other aspects of this evil thing. It is unclean in the light of the instincts; it is unnatural in relation to the affections; it is part of a general attempt to run the populace on a routine of quack medicine and smelly science; it is mixed up with a muddled idea that women are free when they serve their employers but slaves when they help their husbands; it is ignorant of the very existence of real households where prudence comes by free-will and agreement. It has all those aspects, and many of them would be extraordinarily interesting to discuss. But in order not to occupy too much space, I will take as a text nothing more than the title.

As you can see, the “it” referred to in this quote is very clearly not “feminism” — it is BIRTH CONTROL. Feminism isn’t even mentioned in this paragraph, nor is it even mentioned in the essay.

As I alluded to previously, “True Catholic Femininity”* is notorious for making misleading memes like this. In the Facebook group — which I will not link to here, as I do not recommend wasting your time perusing it — most of the memes and quotes seem to be created only to draw a reaction as opposed to facilitating actual discussion (anyone who doesn’t parrot the party line is immediately banned).

I would not recommend sharing anything from that Facebook page.

*In an earlier version of this post, I named the admin of the group “Traditional Catholic Femininity” as the admin of the group “True Catholic Femininity.” I apologize for the mistake, and it has been corrected in the post.

"That article is false. Here's the truth: George Soros Funds the Major Pro-Abortion Groups Trashing ..."

Pro-Life Organizations Should Not Publish Untruthful ..."
"Neither of those groups are worthy of the name "pro-life.""

Pro-Life Organizations Should Not Publish Untruthful ..."
"A pro-life website is Anti-Semitic. Who would expect?"

Pro-Life Organizations Should Not Publish Untruthful ..."
"I read his whole statement. She cannot be written off so easily. She should be ..."

A Tale of Two Assault Victims

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


TRENDING AT PATHEOS Catholic
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Morgan Mareglia

    Speaking of checking your sources, Paige runs Traditional Catholic Femininity, not True Catholic Femininity. The former has the group, the latter shared the image above.

  • My mistake! Thank you for the correction. I will edit accordingly.

  • Morgan Mareglia

    Easy mistake! But my point is that while “True” CF did misquote Chesterton, they do not have a FB group. The FB group to which you are referring is tied to the other page, “Traditional” CF. The group is indeed terrible, but has nothing to do with the above shared image.

    It’s fair to call out True CF for the misquote, but not fair to suggest they have some toxic FB group, because they do not and it’s otherwise a great page.

  • Marie Kopp

    I love how they not only ignore that he was referring to birth control, but also that he roots birth control in capitalism (which is so beloved of this type of Catholic). They literally just conveniently replaced birth control and capitalism with *vile feminism.*

    Well done, Joanna. Scary white capitalist American Catholicism lives to die another day.

  • Again, my mistake! I thought both Traditional and True had FB groups as well as pages. It’s hard to keep track!