Jesus Never Said: “God Helps Those Who Help Themselves”

god helps those

Perhaps you’ve heard the catchphrase: “God helps those who help themselves.”

It might have come up at a dinner table during the election.
In our day, this phrase comes up in political banter more than any other place.

One side claims that Jesus gives everyone a fair go at life, so all you have to do is work hard to succeed. At one level I agree: we should strive to be personally responsible where we can be.

The other side appeals to all of the passages about feeding the hungry, and says that this phrase certainly doesn’t mean that we leave people to their own difficult circumstances.

(For my friends who aren’t American, this probably doesn’t apply, but feel free to chuckle at us from a distance ;-))

Where both sides are often wrong, I think at least, is in the assumption that this is even a helpful or “Christian” saying at all.

It’s not.


Sadly, one stat I came across from the 90s (so old, admittedly) states that about 68% of US Christians believed that “The Bible teaches that God helps those who helps themselves” is true. The number was higher for Americans in general.

Not only is this slogan unhelpful but it is not in the Bible at all.

It’s nowhere to be found.

It has its origins about 400 years prior to Jesus in Aesop’s Fables, in the story of Hercules and the Wagoner.

The wagoner’s heavy load leads him to distress because he gets stuck in the mud.
If you’ve ever been stuck in the mud (don’t read ‘stick in the mud’ although maybe this is true at times too for some of us :-)), you know that things can get really bad really fast.

So the wagoner cries out to Hercules for help. The demigod Hercules (Heracles to the Greeks) replies:

“Get up and put your shoulder to the wheel. The gods help them that help themselves.”

Where does this infamous one liner come from: not Jesus, nor the Scriptures.

It comes from Greco-Roman myth.

Nothing about it is Jewish or Christian.
But after Benjamin Franklin used this slogan in his publication of Poor Richard’s Almanac, it has become part of the American ethos ever since.

Thus, many people believe it to be in the Bible or based on something from the Bible.

I’d argue, it is actually anti-Bible.

Here’s why.


This idea can easily lead to a poor assumption: my actions determine my access.

Let me say that again.

The false idea that “God helps them who help themselves” leads to the false narrative that our actions determine our access to God.

Nothing could be further from the truth!

Rather, our access to God (relationally, experiencially, etc.) can and should determine our actions (rooted in God-like love and empathy toward others).

Accessing God is so different for those of us to see Jesus revealed in the New Testament. The gates are as wide as we let them be! God wants nothing more than to be accessible to all.

This is why, in the Scriptures, the initiative for all that is good always starts and ends with God, not us.

God always takes initiative. Whether it is calling Abram to be the father of a people who would partner with God to undo the evil of Genesis 3-11, or forsaking the glories of the heavenly realm of reality to become human in Jesus of Nazareth: God is the intiator.

God doesn’t wait around hoping we will take the first move to ‘help ourselves.’
God is already acting in the world to our good end.

Everything that is good, starts and ends in God. Our cooperation flow from our access and experience of God, not to earn access to God.


Add to this that “God helps those who help themselves” is the language of privilege.

If God is into impartiality, then this slogan is junk already.

God is so impartial that Jesus says that we are to love even enemies! God sees our enemies as people to be loved! God sends rain on both the righteous and the unrighteous (see Matthew 5.44-45).

God isn’t partial to those who pick themselves up by the bootstraps to “help themselves” first. Neither should we adopt this posture!

God’s love extends father than our logic or cliches will ever know!


When we are tempted to grab for quick answers and slogans that will reinforce our particular positions on an issue, we need to ask: Does this look like the God who looks like Jesus?

In this case, the slogan doesn’t pan out.

In fact, there was once a man who was pretty well off in life who approached Jesus (see Mark 10.17-22).
He wanted to know what he needed to do to inherit the life of the Kingdom that Jesus came to proclaim.

The conversation first turned to the 10 Commandments.

Sure Jesus: I’ve never stolen anything. I never killed another person. I tell the truth about others. I’m good to my parents.

Of course, Jesus is glad to hear that this wealthy young man lived out the Torah commands so well.
But even in appealing to the commandments first, we see that this person had the wrong narrative:

For him, it seems, his actions (what he had accomplished) should lead to greater access (an inheritance in God’s kingdom).

Jesus tells him to sell all his stuff (because it is getting in the way of truly seeing how wide the access point really is!) and to follow him (the embodiment of “access”).

Basically, it’s like Jesus is saying: Come and see just how wide and beautiful the access to God really is… follow me to it… that’s how you will see the kingdom for what it truly is. It is all grace. You are in unless you opt out.

Sadly, this young man can’t do it. He gives us an example of someone who at some level believed that “God helps those who help themselves.” He was mistaken.

He had all the money he would ever need. He had all of the rules followed.

But he lacked one thing: expereincing the gift of recklessly following Jesus into the deep love of God that opens our eyes to others around us.

May you experience a God who’s access is wide.

May you experience others as God does, objects of love, before they do anything to “help themselves.”

And may you see that empathy for others and reliance on God is born out of a life surrendered to the love of God!


 

***Some of the historical insights come from Adam Hamilton in Half-Truths.

"You used to watch Bill O'Reilly? Ow, that had to be painful."

2 Reasons NOT to ‘Keep Christ ..."
"Your splitting hairs. Whether it's an A.D. or C.E. after the 2017, what happened approximately ..."

2 Reasons NOT to ‘Keep Christ ..."
"I know exactly who I'm directing it to. And I'm not Protestant. I'm going to ..."

2 Reasons NOT to ‘Keep Christ ..."
"I'm going to go ahead and question your ability to draw logical conclusions when you ..."

2 Reasons NOT to ‘Keep Christ ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • See Noevo

    One thing Jesus said for sure, and said repeatedly, was “Repent.”

    And the Apostles, too.
    Like Paul in Acts 26:

    “I was not disobedient to the heavenly vision,
    but declared first to those at Damascus, then at Jerusalem and throughout all
    the country of Judea, and also to the Gentiles, that they SHOULD REPENT and
    turn to God and PERFORM DEEDS WORTHY OF THEIR REPENTANCE.”

  • Iain Lovejoy

    “God helps those who help themselves.” –
    the shoplifter’s motto.
    And on a less frivolous note:
    The most sensible explanation I have heard of the story of the rich young man comes from George MacDonald. Jesus is saying to the rich young man exactly what he always says: “Come and follow me”. Jesus is not criticising him, or testing him, he is rewarding him by offering him what he asked for: the chance to inherit lasting life by joining Jesus on the road as a disciple. The point of the story is that the young man turns Jesus down because he cannot bear to abandon his wealth, not that he had hitherto been doing anything wrong.

  • http://omg-occasionalmuffledgrunts.blogspot.co.uk/ Jez Bayes

    “He Never said”
    Martyn Joseph
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e4QyByYgJq8

    “He never said God helps those who help themselves
    He never said Blessed are the rich
    He never said Do unto others before they do it unto you
    He never said Its too bad buddy the winner has to take it all
    He never said success is the key
    You gotta be cruel to be kind
    And he never said it’s a jungle out there
    Where the weak must get left behind

    He Said..
    Answer a strangers cry for help
    Love your brother as you loved yourself
    You only have to seek and you will find
    Forgive your enemies drop that grudge

    Don’t judge others and you won’t be judged
    Only knock and the door will open wide, open wide … “

    • James Connor

      Amen!

  • Arlene Adamo

    It’s ironic that this saying, used by so many American Christians, has it’s origins in polytheistic paganism. And also that it comes from a story where Hercules is basically being a jerk.

  • Bei Dawei

    Well you can’t PROVE he never said that.

    • mencik

      You can’t prove any negative thing.

    • Bruce Robertson

      This is the beauty of religion Bei Dawei, nothing can be proved or disproved. Just make it all up!! Need an answer? Just make it up!!

  • James Connor

    Luke 10:25-28 Jesus in answering the lawyer who is trying to put Jesus to the test, puts the test back on the lawyer. The lawyer,prompted by Jesus, answers one of the foundational precepts of Jesus’s ministry. “Love the Lord your God with all your heart and all your soul and with all your strength and all your mind and your neighbor as yourself.” Jesus doesn’t actually say this but he does agree that if the lawyer does this, he will have eternal life.

    • JenellYB

      I think any parallel there would be the man asking for help with his stuck wagon. Your example is asking seeking God’s help.

  • martin baiada

    Jesus told us: “the road is wide that leads to destruction and many take it! The gate is narrow and the road difficult which lead to salvation, and few make it.

  • rrhersh

    Next thing you are going to tell me that the Bible doesn’t say that cleanliness is next to Godliness!

  • mikehorn

    Or the phrase could mean that hard work creates more opportunities and benefits that you wouldn’t have before. Especially education or making yourself a master of a trade. Humans have intellect and the ability to learn. Not using it is ungrateful and lazy.

    You could say improving yourself is implied if not outright stated. Does this mean charity and self worth are bound up in success? Not at all. But the benefits of work and self improvement are undeniable.

  • Clayton Gafne Jaymes

    God helps those who lean on Him. :)

    (Isaiah
    41:9, 10) You, whom I*(*Jehovah God*)* took from the ends of the earth,
    And you, whom I called from its most distant parts. I said to you, ‘You
    are my servant; I have chosen you; I have not rejected you. 10 Do not
    be afraid, for I am with you. Do not be anxious, for I am your God. I
    will fortify you, yes, I will help you, I will really hold on to you
    with my right hand of righteousness.’

    (Isaiah 41:13,
    14) For I, Jehovah your God, am grasping your right hand, The One
    saying to you, ‘Do not be afraid. I will help you.’ 14 Do not be afraid,
    you worm Jacob, You men of Israel, I will help you,” declares Jehovah,
    your Repurchaser, the Holy One of Israel. -[RNWT
    ***
    As
    these words did apply to the nation of Israel before Jesus, they became
    the reality of true followers of Jehovah God through Jesus today. As
    Jesus is King of Israel. Now God does indeed ‘call ppl’ from all ends of
    the earth to be His servant in the house/body of the Chosen/Anointed
    One(Christ) whose name is ‘Jesus’. Jesus’ name mmeaning: “Jehovah Is
    Salvation”