Is the ‘Christian Fatwa’ over? Makers of ‘Blue Like Jazz’ and ‘October Baby’ talk it out

We reported previously on a “Christian fatwa” allegedly imposed on Steve Taylor’s Blue Like Jazz by the Kendrick brothers. Their company, Sherwood Pictures, makes Christian market movies like Fireproof and Courageous and distributes them with Provident Pictures. The most recent distributed through Provident was October Baby. The “fatwa” involved a refusal to promote Blue Like Jazz via trailers at October Baby screenings and a threat that people who worked with Blue Like Jazz would no longer be able to work with Sherwood and Provident.

In a blog post just published, Taylor describes a phone call Saturday night in which he hashed out the issue with Alex Kendrick, whom he describes as “warm, humble, and generous” and “a Christian brother who wanted to make things right.” Taylor writes:

He explained how he and his brother/filmmaking partner Stephen had no prior knowledge that their church’s Executive Pastor (who is also an Executive Producer on their movies) had issued the edict last year that I described in a previous blog, wherein he let it be known that anybody who worked on Blue Like Jazz would not be working on future Sherwood Baptist movies. Alex told me that, while he and his brother are members of the church and have worked closely with this pastor in the past, they disagreed with his decision, and he further confirmed that none of them, including the pastor, have seen Blue Like Jazz.

It seems the two also found a way to bridge the gap between Kendrick’s sweet faith-based films and Taylor’s more edgy style.

As I’ve stated before, I have great respect for what Alex and his brother have accomplished as filmmakers. Making movies is hard. They’ve had extraordinary success using very limited resources, and each time they do it they get better. We’ve had a number of their fans tell us how much they liked Blue Like Jazz, and Alex and I agreed that there are a variety of ways for Christians to approach storytelling. We’re humbled and grateful that he reached out to us in such a direct and personal way.

Sounds like a good ending to the story. Maybe it would make a good movie.

More on this story:

Read our original post about the “Christian fatwa.

Read our review of Blue Like Jazz

Read our interview with Steve Taylor

Read our interview with John Schneider for October Baby

Update: October Baby is not made by Sherwood Pictures, but is distributed by Provident Films, which has co-distributed the Kendrick Brothers’ films for years and is closely tied to them. A previous version of this story identified October Baby as a Sherwood production, which it is not. Thanks to reader Matt Smith for the catch.

Steve Taylor Hopes to Blow up the Theater Real Good

For many of us growing up in Christian culture in the 1980s, musician Steve Taylor was a voice of nuance, irony, and edginess in a world gone soft-focus.  He always seemed to be about truth, even hard truth. In Taylor’s eye, Jesus was never merely your boyfriend and the church was full of silly and sometimes downright bad people…but always with a precious core.

I caught up with Taylor last week. He was on a bus travelling from Nashville to Atlanta on the first leg of his “30 Days, 30 Screenings” of his upcoming movie, “Blue Like Jazz.” Based on the best-selling book by Donald Miller, the film will premiere at the South by Southwest Festival in Austin before hitting theaters April 13.

Taylor had just finished a big job.

When it seemed that “Blue Like Jazz” was destined to remain a dream and not a reality after a major investor backed out in 2010, some fans posted a request for help on Kickstarter.com.

“I didn’t think this was going to work, so I said give us $10 and I’ll call you personally,” Taylor laughed.

He never expected some 4500 donations totaling more than $345,000 in 30 days.

“Anytime I was in the car, I would make phone calls. I ended up last month finally finishing my 3500 calls. It was great. Now we’re all friends. I gotta say I really enjoyed it. I owe these people a lot.”

Those who, like me, came to know Taylor through songs like “I Wanna Be a Clone” and “I Blew up the Clinic Real Good” do not know that Taylor studied both music and filmmaking at the University of Colorado at Boulder but chose to pursue music first.

“I figured it was easier to be a rock star in my 20s and a filmmaker in my 50s than try the reverse,” Taylor joked. However, as MTV developed the concept of the music video, Taylor directed music videos for himself and others, then switched to filmmaking seven years ago. In the meantime, he started his own label to facilitate Christian artists making a transition to a broader market.

“There had developed this glass ceiling,” he said, “We had these Christian artists who had worked their way up in the Christian subculture and deserved to be heard by the world. [A band he represented, Sixpence None the Richer] spoke to a wider audience by in their music and deserved to be heard by a wider audience.”

He hopes to do the same thing in the realm of film.

“I feel like ‘Blue Like Jazz’ has the same potential to speak to a much wider audience as well,” he said, “A Christian movie genre has formed. Our first goal with this movie is that we didn’t fit into this genre.”

“What’s surprising to me is that the genre has become synonymous with family entertainment. I’m all in favor of family entertainment, but when and why would we think that all media from faith perspective would have to be a family movie, and how could you possibly get that from reading the Bible?”

This view was not always popular.

As with certain times in his music career, Taylor got pushback from potential investors, saying they would support the film if certain content was softened. The story follows a young man from a Southern, conservative Christian background who goes to a secular Northwestern college and wrestles with faith. “There was no way to tell this story truthfully without a certain amount of PG-13 content,” Taylor said. The edgy storylines stayed in, reflecting the tone of the book.

As in music, Taylor turns the camera on what he knows, Christianity, which takes a certain amount of bravery. However, he thinks it’s better for believers to mine Christian culture for stories than to leave it to the secular world.

“I think part of the perception problem with Christianity is that there are people on the outside who think we don’t see any of this stuff. They don’t think we see the hypocrisy within our midst. When that perspective comes from the inside, it helps people understand ‘Yeah, we see it. We get it, but there’s another way here.’”

When I told him that someone I knew took “I Want to be a Clone” as a straight statement about Christian desire instead of the satire Taylor intended, he laughed.

“I think they’re so used to the idea that we have no sense of humor or sense of irony, it’s probably an easy mistake to make.”

Blue Like Jazz Trailer

The book Blue Like Jazz made big waves in the Christian world. Now it’s been made into a movie directed by the one, the only Steve Taylor. I have to say, the trailer makes me want to see the film. The movie hits theaters April 13.

YouTube Preview Image