Which Missional Church?

I was asked this week to answer the question, What is the “Missional Church”? And it got me to thinking, again, about this slippery and elusive term.  So I’ll put my thoughts here, in this public forum, and see if you think I’m on to something or not.

My conclusion is this: There are two missional churches. More specifically, there are two movements of people within American Protestantism who claim the term “missional.”

The First Missional Church

This is a group, primarily of theologians and missiologists, initially gathered under the banner of the Gospel & Our Culture Network in the mid-1990s.  The names most closely associated with the inception missional church are Darrell Guder, George Hunsberger, Lois Barrett, Craig van Gelder, Pat Keifert, and Alan Roxburgh.  Their books include Missional Church and Treasure in Clay Jars.

These thought-leaders come from a mainline context, but they have evangelical leanings. They feel that the church has lost its missional impulse as the mainline church has been ultimately absorbed by American culture.  And they found a theological patron saint in Lesslie Newbigin, a twentieth century missionary to India who retired to his native England to find that Christianity was no longer a prophetic force.  Newbigin’s books, and those of missiologist David Bosch have guided thinking of this group.  Newbigin and Bosch, as well as the books and newsletters of the GOCN, were all highly influential on the genesis of the emerging church movement and of Emergent Village in particular.

Guder and Hunsberger are also Barthians, so that is evident in much of their writing and thinking.  At some point in the early 2000s, Keifert and Roxburgh broke ties with the group — each has started his own consulting organization.  Since then, the GOCN has been largely dormant; the last addition to their website dates to 2009.  John Franke, another Barthian, promises to provide new leadership to the GOCN moving forward.

The Second Missional Church

[Read more...]

John Bohannon Responds to My Review at Jesus Creed

John Bohannon has taken to Scot McKnight’s blog to respond to a critical review of his book that I posted there last month.  Here’s a taste:

First, why should McLaren be exempt from a work that analyzes the preaching within the Emerging Church? Yes he has retired from the full time pastorate, but does this mean that he has stopped preaching and teaching altogether? Does this mean that a historical analysis of his homiletical practices is no longer valid or that his influence has ceased? Like player cum Coach Ozzie Guillen, his change in roles did not lessen his impact on the game. If anything, it heightened it.

via Saturday Afternoon Book Review: Bohannon Responds to Tony Jones | Jesus Creed.

I think the weaknesses in his retort are obvious, and several have already been pointed out by commenters.  Therefore, I don’t plan to respond.  I will note, however, that paragraphs full of rhetorical questions are among my least favorite writing gimmicks.  Don’t you agree? ;-)

Photo in Need of a Caption

What do you suppose I was saying that had The Tickle aghast and BMac scrolling through his iPhone?

Photo by Courtney Perry

An xtranormal Test of Christian Orthodoxy

So, others are posting the pretty damn funny spoof of emergent on xtranormal, but I like this one even better.