It's the End of the Dissertation as We Know It, and I Feel Fine

Well, not exactly.  But Michael Bérubé writes in The Times Higher Education that the dissertation may have run its course.  As part of a study of tenure and promotion in the humanities, it became clear to him that there was an impending crisis.  While schools still require junior faculty to publish their dissertations with university presses, publishing houses are not financially able to edit, print, market and sell books that will only move a couple hundred units.

Bérubé writes,

Still, the crucial question remains: why are we continuing to demand that our junior faculty produce monographs that fewer and fewer libraries are going to purchase – and still fewer people are going to read? Can’t we think of some other, better way to conduct scholarly exchange?

[Read more...]

Dissertation Table of Contents

Here it is so far.  You can tell how far I’ve gotten when the chapter subheads start to drop off…

CONTENTS

ILLUSTRATIONS

TABLES

ABBREVIATIONS

PREFACE

COPYRIGHT PERMISSIONS

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

CHAPTER ONE: THE EMERGING CHURCH MOVEMENT AND THE PROJECT OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY

Introduction

The “Emerging Church Movement” – A Working Definition

Literature Review

The Emerging Church Movement as a New Social Movement

An Osmerian Approach to Practical Theology

The Promise of Transversal Rationality for the ECM

CHAPTER TWO: AN INSIDE LOOK AT EIGHT EMERGING CHURCHES

The Changes in American Protestantism Leading to the ECM

Developments in the 1990s—Three Phases of the ECM

Empirical Research Method

Cedar Ridge Community Church, Spencerville, Maryland

Solomon’s Porch, Minneapolis, Minnesota

House of Mercy, St. Paul, Minnesota

Journey, Dallas, Texas

Pathways Church, Denver, Colorado

Church of the Apostles, Seattle, Washington

Jacob’s Well, Kansas City, Missouri

Vintage Faith Church, Santa Cruz, California

CHAPTER THREE: CORE PRACTICES OF THE EMERGING CHURCH MOVEMENT

Alasdair MacIntyre, Jeffrey Stout, Pierre Bourdieu, and the Concept of “Practice”

CHAPTER FOUR: THE RELATIONAL ECCLESIOLOGY OF JÜRGEN MOLTMANN IN CONVERSATION WITH THE EMERGING CHURCH MOVEMENT

CHAPTER FIVE: PRAGMATIC SUGGESTIONS FOR THE ECCLESIOLOGY OF THE EMERGING CHURCH MOVEMENT

APPENDIX A: FOCUS GROUP AND INTERVIEW LINES OF QUESTIONING

Focus Group Line of Questioning

Line of Questioning: Founding Pastor Interview

Line of Questioning: Layperson Interview

APPENDIX B: CHURCH CENSUS SURVEY

APPENDIX C: Empirical Data

APPENDIX D: An Excursus on Modes of Cross-Disciplinary Thinking in Practical Theology

BIBLIOGRAPHY

From the Archive: A Top Ten List

Originally published April 3, 2005:

This Tuesday will mark the last time ever that I will sit in a class as a student (maybe that’s why they call the Ph.D. a “terminal degree”). I’ve read an enormous amount over the past two years, so I thought I’d look back and try to rank which books have been most influential on my thinking. Since I couldn’t narrow it to ten, here’s my shot at the top eleven:

11. Practicing Passion: Youth and the Quest for a Passionate Church by Kenda Creasy Dean

10. Simulacra and Simulation by Jean O. Baudrillard

9. Making Social Science Matter: How Social Inquiry Fails and How It Can Succeed Again by Bent Flyvbjerg

8. The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order by Samuel Huntington

via A Top Ten List | Tony Jones.

Liberal Bias in the Academy? (In Response to Jesus Creed)

At Jesus Creed, Scot has first asked, then responded to a question posted by Dan Wallace at Parchment and Pen.  The bottom line of the discussion is this: Is there a bias in the academy, particularly graduate studies, against students from evangelical schools? I have a couple thoughts.

First, my experience.  I went to a secular, Ivy League university for undergraduate studies, majoring in Classics and adept in history, archaeology, Greek, and Latin.  From there I went directly to an evangelical seminary.  And, after that, in the fall of 1993, I applied to the PhD programs at Yale, Duke, Emory, and the University of Chicago.  I was accepted at none.

[Read more...]

Back to Princeton

Last week, I spent two days at Princeton, speaking at the annual youth ministry conference. I’ve always got mixed feelings when I go back — a love of the people there, and an aversion to the bureaucracy and to New Jersey in general.

In happy news, I recently found out that I won a dissertation grant from the Louisville Institute, so I’ll be hunkering down and finally writing that massive term paper next fall/winter/spring.