Building Walls, Banning the Human 

“Blame is a valuable antidote to helplessness.”

Martha Nussbaum

I spent last Monday morning in a multi-faith press conference where the subject was the recent immigration ban by the Trump administration. We heard from Muslims, Jews, and Christians. All read scriptures concerning how “the stranger” is to be treated. All agreed that “god” wishes the stranger to fare well.

We all know that any argument will convince the already convinced—that preaching to the choir thing. Convincing the frightened, however, is a very different thing. The frightened ones—the extreme right in all three of those religions—weren’t there.

Among US Christians, opposition to the ban runs 50/50 (Among the largest Christian group, Evangelicals, only twenty percent oppose the ban). Among US “nones” opposition runs at seventy-five percent.

It sounds like scriptures are doing more harm than good.

For me, a Humanist, the multi-faith press conference underlined the fact that the various concepts of god reflect a person’s politics. The people in the room—of whatever religious persuasion—were liberal; those not in the room were not.

This is not to denigrate those who welcome the stranger for religious reasons. The stories are moving and the help is real. Still, the US government, a government made up almost entirely of professing Christians, is not welcoming and not helping, and the US populace, most of whom claim to be Christian, is split evenly on the matter. Christianity is not tuning the tide toward welcoming the stranger.

Only law will do that.

Humanists are internationalists. Just as we believe that religions worship creations of the human mind, we know that national borders are the creation of human minds. We don’t worship boundaries any more than we worship human ideas.

The Humanist minister John Dietrich talked about national boundaries immediately after the First World War:

these things are wholly artificial. Every one of them is a pure illusion in the minds of diplomats. From the standpoint of the basic human interests which make up our life, they have no more reality than a unicorn or a dragon.

National borders are another illusion that human beings worship. Like religions, they are the stuff of anger, division, and murder.

An aspiration of Humanism is decolonization of the human mind. Each person’s colonization includes the religions and borders that we are born into. Religion. Nationality. Race. Class. Gender. All human constructs that colonize our minds and lead us toward fearing “the other.”

Is seeing and hearing differently possible? Only marginally, for the most part. Decolonizing the mind is an impossible ideal. But insofar as it is impossible, we understand just how dyed into the wool our subjectivities are. Everyone comes from somewhere, and that somewhere that covers our ears and eyes limits us if we allow it to. It colonizes our minds and makes us afraid of “the other.”

My Humanism isn’t about what I don’t believe. Or do believe, for that matter. Humanism to me is about actions and commitments. It’s about central concerns. Humanism is about taking ownership of choices and consequences rather than farming those out to gods and scriptures. My Humanism is about understanding that in this web of existence, my choices have wide-ranging consequences.

Human beings matter more than ideas. It’s that simple.

Decolonizing the mind necessarily leads to the conclusion that national borders and religious differences are as real as unicorns and dragons. As such, they must be resisted. This is the bedrock of my faith in the human spirit.

About the Universal Declaration of Human Rights

http://www.un.org/en/universal-declaration-human-rights/index.html HUU

"Talk about that moral arc of the universe that bends toward justice is metaphysical talk—theology—not ..."

#Charlottesville and Getting Real
"My tradition is Advaita Vedanta. Yoga is actually union with God. Advaita recognizes no duality ..."

To Whom It May Concern: the ..."
"The end question blew my mind. The answer somehow didn't making so much sense I ..."

#Charlottesville and Getting Real
"It’s interesting that you find in the Orient an early alternative to metaphysical dualism. I ..."

On the Suppression of Knowledge

Browse Our Archives

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment