Note To David Barton And Kenneth Copeland: PTSD Is Real

Kenneth Copeland’s and David Barton’s teaching on post-traumatic stress disorder struck a raw nerve.

On Veteran’s Day, Copeland and Barton claimed that the Old Testament book of Numbers 32 is a promise that soldiers who fight for God are promised that they will return from battle and can get rid of PTSD if they cast out demonic influences. Reaction was swift and negative. Predictably, left leaning groups castigated the two. However, equally strong was the reaction from evangelical and conservative circles. These groups have good reason to react negatively, the advice given by Barton and Copeland was dangerously misinformed.

I rarely treat PTSD these days. However, when I owned a group practice in Southern Ohio, I had a contract with the Veteran’s Administration to treat Vietnam Vets with PTSD. Before he died, my uncle struggled with his experiences in WWII, often using alcohol to quiet the raging memories inside. The intrusive thoughts and sense of dread are quite real to the person who suffers. Advances in brain imaging have begun to reveal some answers to why some people experience symptoms after trauma and others do not. And Numbers 32 has no role in the differences.

A recent VA study found that the parts of the brain which encode incoming information remain active in PTSD patients whereas non-sufferers show more neural flexibility. Study co-author Lisa James said, “The deficit that we see in PTSD is the absence of that ability to modulate.”

Acting along with pre-existing vulnerability, trauma seems to actually erode the resilience and mood regulating functions of the brain. A 2011 NIMH funded study found fewer neurons responsible for passing chemical messages through the brain in victims of trauma than in brains of controls participants. The brain scans below depicts the difference:

Patients with PTSD (right) had significantly fewer serotonin 1B receptors (yellow & red areas) in their brain stress circuits than healthy controls (left). PET scan images show destinations of a radioactive tracer that binds to serotonin 1B receptors. Front of brain is at bottom. Source: Alexander Neumeister, M.D., Mount Sinai School of Medicine

A quick review of the other NIMH work and many other studies showing real changes as the result of trauma demonstrate the harmful nature of the advice given by Copeland and Barton.  One cannot just “get rid of it” as Copeland counseled.

Copeland and Barton should immediately offer an apology and point people to the VA and/or other credible medical and psychological professionals.

 

  • Stogumber

    You didn’t explain why we should see brain conditions as causal, and not as parallel, to emotional conditions.
    Nor did you explain what use these brain studies eventually have for professional therapy. Are professional therapists more successful in healing PTSD than in healing homosexuality? We wouldn’t know. So, why ever should Copeland and Barton point anyone to a “professional”?

    • Stogumber

      It’s edifying that Barton’s position can be framed as “PTSD isn’t real” (which is certainly not what Barton wanted to say).
      But from that we can learn how the professional mind works: A disorder is only a real disorder, if it can’t be cured neither by amateurs nor by the patient himself but only by us professionals.

  • http://randy.today/ Randy Thomas

    I was diagnosed with PTSD in 2005. My life experience is different from what soldiers go through for sure … but PTSD is extremely difficult and these men’s ignorance is insulting. They should not hesitate and apologize.

  • Drianusa

    All Veterans, please remember that whatever they have written about is a subject that does not exist. Any reply from these guys is based on their believe of something that, despite their research, still is not verifiable. It is a belief system, that despite their efforts, still today leaves them empty handed with facts. Thus Veterans, stick to your experience, because those are real, and do not let any of these so called learned characters tell you otherwise. The evidence will show that they studied a lot but have learned nothing.

    • Warren Throckmorton

      Drianusa – I assume you are referring to Barton and Copeland…


CLOSE | X

HIDE | X