PTSD and the Church: When Religion is a Trigger

PTSD and the Church: When Religion is a Trigger August 17, 2018
girl praying
Image credit: Pixabay

I used to think I was the only person who experienced panic attacks inside church buildings. It doesn’t happen often, but I have been known to get to the parking lot, immediately pull a U-Turn and nope on out because all the sudden I can’t catch my breath.

When I started sharing my challenges a few years ago, I heard from people with the same problem. Something terrible had happened to them in the church, and now their brains were firing off warning sirens when they tried to connect to their spiritual home again.

Most people understand Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) on some level, though we usually associate it with combat veterans. People are sometimes surprised to hear anyone who has lived through a traumatic event could have PTSD.

A lot of people have been traumatized within our churches. We haven’t even scratched the surface on that yet.

Not everyone who experiences trauma develops PTSD, but plenty do. So, how do we support them?

We start with trying to understand how PTSD and religion might interact for our brother or sister.

When we’re in the middle of a traumatic event, our body automatically kicks in with our fight/flight/freeze response. Our heart is racing. Our breathing is shallow. Our adrenaline is pumping. We have no control over any of it. We might tell our heart, “Slow down!” and think it really hard, but we have no way of actually forcing our heart to slow down on command like that.

When someone who has PTSD talks about being “triggered,” they mean they’re experiencing that uncontrollable fight/flight/freeze response because part of their brain has interpreted some stimulus around them as meaning their life is in danger. This isn’t something that is consciously done.

I have a lot of trees around my house. In the fall, acorns hit my roof. I know the sounds I’m hearing is acorns. I know I’m perfectly safe inside my house. But when an acorn falls on the roof, I startle and my heart starts racing. My higher brain hasn’t even had a second to process the noise and realize it’s a stupid acorn before my instincts have kicked in. That’s how a PTSD trigger works. You can know, without a doubt, that you are safe, but part of your unconscious brain is sending out signals that tell your body you are in a life-or-death situation. You can’t just tell your adrenal glands to knock it off and expect them to obey you.

To be clear, “trigger” doesn’t mean offended, upset, angry, or irritated. That definition is a complete misuse of the word “trigger.” Misusing that word makes it harder for people with PTSD to talk about their symptoms.

The other thing that’s important to understand is these uncontrollable responses can be unpredictable. Sometimes a person with PTSD can identify likely triggers, but not always. In a church setting, the goal isn’t to remove all PTSD triggers (which would be impossible) but to be supportive when our brothers or sisters are struggling with the response those triggers can bring out.

What could that support look like?

Let’s look at a scenario:

As a teenager, a man was abused by an adult male authority figure who justified the abuse with religion. This adult had a favorite hymn he was known for singing loudly in their church.

This boy grew up and is now attending a different church, far away from his abuser.

One Sunday, he finds himself stuck in the middle of a pew while everyone opens their hymnals and begins singing that song his predator loved. The song surrounds him. His heart races. His palms get sweaty. He feels like he’s going to throw up or pass out.

He knows he’s having a panic attack. He’s found the best way of handling those is to find a quiet place to sit for a while until it passes. But he’ll have to get the people around him to move before he can exit the pew.

When he taps the woman to his left on the shoulder and says, “Excuse me,” she could respond in a few different ways.

A) She could roll her eyes and ignore him because she loves this song and he’s interrupting her favorite part of the hymn.

B ) She could refuse to move, glare at him for being disruptive, and snap out, “Just wait for us to finish the song.”

C) She could move out of his way and let him pass.

D) She could look at him, notice his agitation, and let him pass. Later, after Mass is over, she could ask if he’s OK.

She chooses the last option. She lets the man pass. He returns to his seat after a while, though he still seems a little unsettled.

While everyone is gathering their jackets and purses, she turns to him and asks if everything is OK.

He tells her, “I’m OK. That song just gets to me.”

This woman knows what PTSD is, and she notices the man’s reaction seems like a panic attack. Maybe he’s a veteran and that song reminded him of something he experienced in combat. Maybe he’s an abuse survivor and that song had something to do with the abuse. Maybe he was in a nearly fatal car accident and that song was playing on a CD when he crashed.

She doesn’t know why that song triggered his response, but that’s not important right now. She knows the most important thing right now is to make sure this man feels supported within the church.

“I’m so sorry,” she says, “There’s nothing wrong with ducking out for a bit when you need to.”

She says, “I’m so sorry,” not as an admission of guilt or wrong-doing on her part, but as a show of compassion and understanding. She then tells him his actions were acceptable so that he doesn’t feel ashamed of doing what is healthiest for him in that situation.

She has validated him and shown him that he can attend here without being judged, and it took less than five minutes.

Would this man be more likely to come back next Sunday when she behaves this way or if she had rolled her eyes or shot a harsh comment his way? Basic, easy-to-accomplish, kindness goes a long way.

When someone looks like they’re struggling, we shouldn’t assume they’re trying to be disruptive. From what I’ve heard from people who have PTSD symptoms within religious spaces, they’re desperately trying not to be disruptive. They don’t want you to notice them because, well, it’s embarrassing and hard to explain. And even when we do explain, more often than not, we’re met with ridicule, judgment, and cruel comments from people who don’t understand trauma or PTSD.

Some people will get defensive here. They’re thinking, “It’s not my job to be that person’s therapist. They should get some help on their own.”

That’s not what I’m saying at all. I’d actually encourage you not to try to take on the role of therapist. Well-meaning people can do serious harm while trying to take on that role when they aren’t equipped for it.

But I do want to address therapy. Some people respond well to therapy and see an improvement with their PTSD symptoms. Other people don’t respond as well or at all. That doesn’t mean those people didn’t try to make therapy work. There are so many different types of trauma and we all respond differently to those traumatic events. What works for one person won’t work for everyone.

Also, a person could be in therapy, and making progress with that, but still be struggling with PTSD triggers. We don’t get over our trauma overnight. It takes time. So that man who had to leave during the hymn might currently be in therapy.

You shouldn’t try to play therapist, but you should support people who are struggling with religious PTSD in your church.

We can sit here and condemn abuse in abstract terms, but that’s meaningless if we aren’t willing to embrace victims of abuse within our churches. If people who have been traumatized in our churches are brave enough to walk through our doors, we shouldn’t treat them as an inconvenience.

They aren’t a burden. They’re Christ.

"Lemme just lay this out: Playing hard to get is objectively harmful to both men ..."

Crossing the Line: Friendly, Flirty, or ..."
"We definitely need to figure out a way not to enable abuse. I'm actively working ..."

Discerning Spirits in the Age of ..."
"But you'll still be enabling and thus an accessory to sexual predators. But you can ..."

Discerning Spirits in the Age of ..."
"Is there a limit to how much abuse the church can do before you will ..."

Discerning Spirits in the Age of ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


TRENDING AT PATHEOS Catholic
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • This may be a stupid question, but if the church sometimes triggers negative feelings, can’t you just not go to church? Maybe you can still participate in the social events, volunteer projects, and other community activities but just avoid the service.

  • It’s not a stupid question. I don’t think there’s a one-size-fits-all answer. We’re supposed to attend Mass unless there’s a serious reason we really can’t. I think PTSD *could be* a legitimate reason for some people to miss, but I’m not an expert on that and can’t speak for all people with PTSD since it’s not something we all handle in the same way. I think the goal for someone who *wants* to attend should be to find a way to make that work, and part of that solution can be for people who are already in the church to be educated about PTSD.

    In some cases, a person usually isn’t triggered during a church service, so it might not make much sense for them to avoid church on the off chance their PTSD might get triggered that day. It’s hard to know for sure if something in church that morning is going to trigger a panic attack or not.

    If a person is thrown into a panic attack every time they walk into a church, that’s a very different scenario and should be evaluated with someone who can help them work out what’s healthiest for them.

  • Wow–that’s really bending over backwards for the benefit of the church.

    I realize that the church says that bad things will happen if you don’t go … but then that’s the same church that gave you the PTSD. When your common sense tells you something (in this case: “don’t go in there!”), I think that’s worth listening to, for your own health. Take a few months off and reevaluate your relationship with the church, putting yourself first, not what you’ve been told about what Jesus wants.

    Have you watched Julia Sweeney’s “Letting Go of God”? There’s a TED talk as well as a much longer one-woman show. It’s quite funny, and she talks about her journey, starting out as a very strong Catholic.

    I realize that I’m coming at this as an outsider, so my suggestions may not work for you. But I offer them as food for thought in the hope that they can help. Your situation is far more serious than just “I think I’ll sleep in and miss mass today” that I think stepping back and rethinking would make sense.

  • I appreciate your concern. My traumatic experiences happened in a Mennonite church, not the Catholic church (I’m a convert) so Mass doesn’t bother me the way some Evangelical services do. I don’t think anything bad will happen to me if I miss Mass. I miss Mass frequently because of migraines and I haven’t gotten struck down…yet. I actually like going when I can. Some people love attending or feel a strong need to attend and they shouldn’t have to stay away just because other people can’t be a little sensitive. I don’t want to pressure anyone to attend. I mostly want to pressure church members not to be jerks to someone with PTSD. (Or not to be jerks at all because *that* would sure be a nice change.)

    I once had a panic attack while buying coffee at Wal-Mart. That doesn’t mean I should give up coffee or stop going to Wal-Mart. Sometimes it’s best to avoid something that triggers PTSD, but not always. That’s up to the person with PTSD to evaluate their own needs. I couldn’t say what someone else who was traumatized within a church should or shouldn’t do. Usually, when someone is traumatized in that way, it strips them of control. I’d never further strip someone of their control by trying to dictate whether they should or shouldn’t attend church.

    I took over 10 years off from Christianity and that was a good move. Sometimes we need to get out and clear our heads from all the garbage we’ve been exposed to. I think it’s healthy to get out of the bubble and explore other options. I fully support anyone who needs to walk away temporarily or permanently if that’s the healthiest move for them to make. In regards to people who’ve been victimized within religious circles and leave for those reasons, if God is God, I don’t believe he would punish anyone Christians have run out.