A modern Pagan perspectivePosts RSS Comments RSS

The Return of the Revenge of Witches on Reality Television

Hard to believe its been nearly a year since I had to post about modern Pagans appearing in a trashy reality television program! I should have known that the siren-call of money and fame/infamy would be too much for some in our extended community to miss. This time its an Australian program entitled “The One: The Search for Australia’s Most Gifted Psychic”, a game show/reality television program in the vein of “America’s Got Talent” or “Hell’s Kitchen”, only with psychics.


The host and contestants of “The One”.

“English statutes against witchcraft were repealed in 1736 and public executions are no longer sanctioned as entertainment, at least not in Australia, but Channel Seven has devised an alternative ordeal – a televised quest for Australia’s top psychic. Seven contestants – mediums, psychics, clairvoyants, a “medical intuitive” and a witch – undergo tests to prove their paranormal abilities. They have to find a lost boy in the bush with a bit of help from his teddy, examine memorabilia from celebrities and deduce who they belong to, and find contraband inside a shipping container.”

So this spoon-bending Survivor already has one Witch as a contestant, but we get a double-dose this time around, because one of the two judges is a Witch too!

“Using the good cop-bad cop formula loved by reality TV, two judges – Richard Saunders, vice-president of the Australian Skeptics, and Stacey Demarco, a practising witch and author – decide each week who stays or goes until three contestants are left. The winner will be chosen by a public vote … Stacey Demarco, who teaches metaphysics and has written books on how to apply witchcraft in the boardroom and the bedroom, is the believing panellist. “I’m a rational type of expert, I’m not the purple tie-dye type of witch. I just want people to come into this with a really open mind. It’s not a circus act or an act of any kind. “The contestants are normal people, they’ve got husbands, wife, kids, pets, a house in the suburbs and they are considered weirdos, freaks, satanists just because they have these abilities.” Only a couple of episodes have been shot but, Demarco says, the show lives up to its billing that it will make “hairs stand up on end”.”

So who is Stacey Demarco? Well, she authored two books for Llewellyn, “Witch in the Bedroom: Proven Sensual Magic”, and “Witch in the Boardroom: Proven Business Magic”, was initiated as a solitary Witch (though I’m not sure what she means by that), and has a background in PR and marketing (which most likely explains how she got this gig). Demarco’s role marks something of a step up for Pagans in reality television, from mere entertainment fodder to playing a role in the selection/elimination process. Of course the larger question is if modern Pagans should be participating in the vapid, soulless, and cheapening reality television market in the first place.

While shows like “Wife Swap” and its ilk have portrayed Wicca and modern Paganism as bizarre lifestyle choices (instead of, say, a serious religious faith), “The One” will most likely portray Witchcraft as an enhancement/byproduct of possessing psychic powers (though I suppose I could live in hope…). Neither of these approaches does much to broadcast an accurate picture of our family of faiths, or give insight into the fact that we worship multiple gods, have our own holidays, and are (generally speaking) rather pedestrian in our lifestyle choices and attitudes. The saddest thing is that every time our faiths get run into the ground on one of these programs, there is always another Witch or Pagan out there who thinks “I’ll be different”. To them I say, no one is more powerful than the video editors, those great powers who decide which of your words to emphasize, and actions to highlight.

I suppose there is always the chance that this program will be different. But I’ve been down this road before, and don’t hold out too much hope that our faiths won’t be trivialized for the sake of entertainment. To my readers in Australia, keep an eye on this show (which premieres on Tuesday) and fill me in on how it is. Who knows, maybe we’ll all get lucky for a change.

11 responses so far

  • HR Mitchell

    So, when we will subjected to the search for America’s Top Christian, or Jew, or … oh, how about just a decent human being?I detest (un)Reality TV.

  • syren

    I’ve just checked the TV guide for next Tuesday and sure enough there it is 7.30pm. Just what we need, yet another (yawn) “reality tv” show. I may watch it once, just to see how big the cringe factor is or I might just be too busy bathing my son and reading him bedtime stories.

  • ~Illisse

    The only way that we will ever be shown in a more realisic light on “reality” tv is to get one of us on who is so boring that they would have to edit him/her into ‘normalness’ in order to make the show interesting.And since that will never happen….~Illisse

  • Anonymous

    The sceptic on this piece of rubbish The One looks very weak in the promo. Does he not understand that they will gobble him up in the edit suite and leave the public believing this CRAP! The One is already in trouble as it is founded on a ‘false premise’. The outcome has been decided; psychics exist!!. If I were a working sceptic I would be running down the nearest rabbit hole in order to save my reputation. Surely there are more ‘legitimate’ areas to get the message out!

  • Stacey

    Hey,Im Stacey Demarco. I dont know who the hell you are either, but I wouldnt knock you without at least meeting you or contacting you or reading your work or watching the show. I am billed on the show as a Metaphysical Expert not a Witch. The role I have on the show is to explain and offer expert commentary on what the psychics are doing and as I have been a respected author, writer and lecturer on metaphysics internationally for over a decade on these subjects (no not two books but four)I think they made a darn good choice! I just happen to be a witch too. This is not a show about religion, but about psychic ability. I am careful to make that point.It just happens that some of us are witches. As you would also know, being a witch is something that does attract media attention so its no wonder that the media has picked up on this. I do everything I can to be a good ambassador for not only those with this kind of ability but of the Wiccans who do and I am very sad that you have chosen to go down such an intolerant path. We should stick together not bag each other. Dont you have someone more deserving to pick on?

  • An Unknown Philosopher

    Thank you Stacey for sharing your side of the story. We are all well aware of how the media will chose to portray anything that is outside of the ‘social norms’ that media outlets and our institutions seem so determined to enforce upon us.I personally find the concept of the show offensive; but that goes for most of the content on commercial television. Whomever was picked in that role of “metaphysical expert” in my opinion was already going to be “investigated” by media as to their “credentials” – and anything exploitable by the media was surely going to be exploited, unfortunately that seems to be the nature of the beast.Peace Profound.

  • Jason Pitzl-Waters

    “I wouldnt knock you without at least meeting you or contacting you or reading your work or watching the show.”Please explain how I “knocked” you? I certainly heaped plenty of scorn on the vile reality television industry, but I don’t remember writing any personal attacks on you. Unless being skeptical of “The One” is somehow construed as a personal affront. Heck, I even said your role is a “step up” for Pagans in reality television.“no not two books but four”I said you wrote two books “for Llewellyn”. Which is accurate, at least according to Llewellyn’s web site. Though I’m not sure exactly how many books you authored has to do with the topic at hand. I never questioned whether you were experienced enough to be a panel judge.“I do everything I can to be a good ambassador for not only those with this kind of ability but of the Wiccans who do and I am very sad that you have chosen to go down such an intolerant path. We should stick together not bag each other. Dont you have someone more deserving to pick on?”With all due respect Ms. Demarco, but the only thing I’m “intolerant” of is the dehumanizing reality television industry. Which has used the modern Pagan community as a cheap source for entertainment on several occasions. Any positive portrayal of our faiths in this medium has been a fluke, not the norm, and I hold strong reservations that anyone can overcome the sensationalism and tawdry thrills of the genre. I’m concerned that you feel I’m “picking” on you or being “intolerant” by expressing skepticism that “The One” will rise above its genre and positively portray Pagans. I’m also somewhat dismayed that you would even use the term “intolerant” in regards to commentary on a television program.As for “sticking together”, I have been rather tireless in sticking up for modern Pagans all over the world. It is through this work that I have come to the fair conclusion that reality television is harmful to our family of faiths. Will “The One” be different? Perhaps. But it will have to prove itself, and it certainly can’t expect the avid support of any Pagan who has witnessed how Pagans have been treated by the medium. I don’t live in Australia, but I have regular readers who do. So I’ll await their word on if this show is somehow different. Best to you, good luck with your career. – Jason

  • Morning Angel

    Two words: exploitation and sensationalism.

  • Jacqueline

    Ms. Demarco,You responded to almost nothing in the actual post. Jason is talking about how another reality TV show that exploits the term, “witch” (which they do in their promo materials for the show) is going to affect the entire religious community. I can only agree with his sentiments and ask you how you have come to the opinion that it will not be exploitive and harmful not only to those of Pagan faith but to those who are sorely misunderstood in this world due to having psychic gifts? The rest of it – griping that the number of books you’ve published wasn’t just right, etc – sounds petty and silly. The tone of your entire response is knee-jerk and insecure. Again, I would like to hear a clear response from you on what your intentions are in doing this show and if you really think it can have a positive effect on public perception of psychics and people of Pagan faiths. If you are just doing it to increase your own fame or income, that is your choice, but I would hope you believe there is more purpose in what you are doing than that.

  • astarrymist

    Hi Jason, I’m not sure if you’ve ever blogged about this, but there was a Lifetime series called “America’s Psychic Challenge” that seems very similar in premise to the “One.” http://www.mylifetime.com/on-tv/shows/americas-psychic-challengeI did not think the show did anything positive for the pagan community. The winner seemed to be the New Age Christian sort, but what really bothered me was the lady was so concerned about the runner-up, a practitioner of Voodoo, because she wanted to present to the public the idea the psychics were light-loving and not dark or creepy. While wanting the public to understand that psychic does not equal evil, she perpetuated other stereotypes instead. The “See? Some of us aren’t evil, but these others are” attitude doesn’t inform the unaware of the beauty of our diversity and also keeps alive the black and white idea that good and evil are at odds.

  • syren

    I did manage to catch the last half of the show. I was too busy bathing my son and putting him to bed to see the first half. It all seemed very shallow to me – no depth or “meat” to it. For me, the show gave the impression the people participating were irrelevant next to what they did and this aspect did not please me. I think I agree with Morning Angel. I won’t be going out of my way to watch it again.