A modern Pagan perspectivePosts RSS Comments RSS

An Ethical Lapse of the Online Pagan Community?

Reading through the news today, I noticed an odd story that ends up painting at least one corner of the online Pagan world as lacking in ethical common sense. It regards a woman, Spokane resident Gypsy Lawson, who was convicted of smuggling a rhesus macaque monkey from Thailand.

“Gypsy Lawson took the rhesus macaque monkey on a flight from Thailand to Los Angeles in the United States. The 29-year-old drugged it with sleeping pills and hid it under her blouse during the trip. A month later she bragged about the monkey she called Apoo to a shop assistant who then called police.”

Seems pretty cut and dried, but there was an interesting wrinkle to the story. Seems that Ms. Lawson is a Pagan and turned to a local Pagan e-list for magical/energetic “help” in smuggling the monkey out of Thailand.

“On their way back, Ogren reportedly emailed an online witches and pagan community asking for “last-minute energy” to help them smuggle the animal.”

Doing some more digging, I found a Spokesman Review article from July that gives a bit more detail regarding this online request.

“The following day, the indictment alleges, Ogren sent an e-mail to “NE Washington Witches and Pagans” at a Yahoo account “and asked for last-minute energy” to help them safely smuggle the monkey into the United States. “The Witches group replied by e-mail ‘consider it done,’ ” the indictment says.”

I can’t seem to find the list at Yahoogroups any longer, so perhaps the negative publicity forced it to close down, but a serious question remains: why didn’t these Pagans realize an illegal act was taking place and report it? Indeed, why did Witches and Pagans offer spiritual aid to enable this foolish woman to smuggle an animal into the country? Leaving aside the serious legal issues involved here, there are also moral and health-related issues involved in keeping primates as pets.

“If you try to keep them as pets you’re creating a mentally disturbed animal in 99.9 percent of the cases,” said Wright, director of conservation, science and sanctuary at the zoo. “The animal will never be able to fit in any other home. Never learn how to get along with other monkeys. And, more often than not, will end up with a lot of behavioral traits that are self-destructive.”

The article about Lawson’s conviction should have read “she bragged about the monkey she called Apoo to a local Pagan list, many members of that group then called the police”*, that it didn’t should cause us to examine why members of the Pagan community were enablers in this drama rather than heroes. As for “Apoo” the monkey, he is now safe at a primate rescue center in Oregon.

* This isn’t to say we should all become informants for any perceived or suspected violation of law, there is a range of justifiable opinion on certain ordinances, and such a thing as unjust laws, but the ethical course here was rather plain and obvious.

16 responses so far

  • Diana Rajchel

    I guess I’m just trying to wrap my head around why someone would want to do this in the first place. It’s cruel, and it seems like this lady is mentally unbalanced.It also seems as though some people need to write in to these publications and remind the writers that in journalism there is also an ethical obligation for accuracy.If Pagans do bad things, bad press is part of the consequences, just as if we do good things, we deserve recognition. One way or the other, I prefer the press to be accurate!

  • Yewtree

    Unfortunately being a Pagan doesn’t automatically confer immunity from serious stupidity and immorality. I can think of any number of selfish idiots who believe in all sorts of pseudo-history and other nonsense, and who behave very selfishly indeed, who call themselves Pagans. (Fortunately I can also think of lots of good people with whom I am proud to share the label.) But it’s sad if there was no-one on the list who pointed out that it is cruel and wrong to keep primates as pets.

  • Robin Edgar

    I am kind of hoping that Gypsy found some Rhesus Pieces in her blouse following the smuggling. :-)

  • Robin Edgar

    “If Pagans do bad things, bad press is part of the consequences, just as if we do good things, we deserve recognition.”Good point. How often to pagans get any press when they do good things? Of course, the way the media operates, plenty of “good things” done by other religious communities go unreported. It seems that the media is much more interested in “bad news”.

  • THE Michael

    I’m sorry, but being Pagan does not insure any sort of upstanding charactor or mental stability. Unfortunately, our “alternative” existance does attract those who aren’t exactly playing with a full deck, just like the fundamental factions of the “mainstream” religions tend to do.I myself find it hard enough apologizing for being simply HUMAN, with all the ethical and moral baggage THAT confers on anybody.

  • Erynn

    I’m on a lot of email lists. It doesn’t mean I read and endorse every post that comes through. It doesn’t even mean I pay attention to most of the posts — the vast majority, I see the subject line and delete them unread. I suspect that most other people do the same.That said, unless we know exactly what her email to the list really said, how do we know she was broadcasting her illegal activity to the entire NE Washington Pagan community?My ex used to get martial arts catalogues in the mail. One of those catalogues was advertising “traditional medicine” made from tiger bones. You can bet your ass I reported that company for trafficking in endangered species. It’s easy to get up in arms about transgressions in the Pagan community, but let’s wait until there’s some proof that the majority of said community was actually guilty, eh?

  • Jason Pitzl-Waters

    Erynn,I’m not saying the “majority” was guilty, I’m asking why not even a single person on the list thought to report it? Further, the indictment alleges she specifically asked this group for magical help in her monkey-smuggling, otherwise why would the indictment even mention it?I’m not “up in arms”, I’m not persecuting anyone. I’m asking questions, and hoping for answers.

  • Ben Gruagach

    Without actually reading the email list’s archives, it’s hard to know that the smuggler actually talked openly about planning to commit a crime.I’ve been on lots of messageboards and lists where people will say they are “going through some tough times” and ask for positive thoughts to be sent their ways. How do we know this wasn’t the case here?

  • Jason Pitzl-Waters

    If she just said she was going through tough times, why would law enforcement cite the message at all? I mean, I’m as skeptical as the next person, but I can’t imagine they would mention the posting if it didn’t have some bearing on the case (which ended up in a conviction).

  • Carol Maltby

    Note the choice of words –the articles refer to her “allegedly” (in the indictment) or “reportedly” (regarding the conviction) emailed the Yahoo group.Both Lawson and her mother were convicted on smuggling and conspiracy charges. Her boyfriend did a plea bargain and testified against her.Perhaps the email was tied in in an attempt to get addition conspirators. It would have to be called “alleged” before a conviction. I wonder if thereportedly” means they weren’t able to prove she sent it (Shared computer? Posting deleted by moderators?)

  • Livia Indica

    Just to play devil’s advocate: I wonder if, by some chance, she was trying to save the critter from a worse fate?

  • ofthespiae

    It’s likely that the list was deleted by Yahoo, themselves, and not the list oweners. It’s a direct violation of Yahoo’s ToS for users to allow certain services to support or encourage criminal activities. Say the woman in question *did*, in fact, make a plea for energy on that list specifically for monkey-smuggling, unless the list owners deleted her post (and presumably warned her never to do it again) certain yahoo community administrators would view that as a direct violation of those clauses in their ToS and delete the whole list. It’s not fair, or even necessary, in some cases, but I know for a fact that similar has happened before.

  • nefaeria

    I personally don’t see Pagans being held to the same ethical/moral code(s), as we are a diverse lot. However, I would hope that any decent person would have done the right thing and thought of the animal she was smuggling, not helping this idiot in her dirty work!What this woman and others were thinking (or not!) is beyond me. Thanks for sharing the story.Slàinte!Laurel

  • Alice

    OK first I would like to point out that their is no way of knowing if a person online is telling the truth. I mean that you don’t really know if they are telling the truth or just trying to get attention!!!! Yes agreeing to send help was not the best way to respond. Also can you think how the phone cal would work.(hello is this the police I have a read on a message bored that someone is going to try to smuggle in a monkey from thiailand. no i don’t know them in person where do they live a I am not sure somewhere in such in such state) what i am saying is on the internet you don’t really know if their info is true and even if it is how much do you really put on it. Not that some one cannot be found but by the time that happens their is a monkey here already. Did anyone ever think that what was sent was for the monkey to end up safe and in the end a pagan group she bragged to did that. Isn’t that how it usually works in a natural way?

  • digital-dharma.net

    Since Rhesus are given to throwing excrement and public masturbation, it’s sort of a shame she didn’t have a chance to appreciate her choices more, before the creature was rescued.As to the online nonsense, people who believe such things are possible can hardly be held responsible for weak thinking in other areas.

  • avinriver

    Hello all,First, she was not “rescuing” the monkey. Monkeys would not be captured and held in cruel conditions if they could not be sold to Westerners. Second, as a responsible citizen if you hear of an illegal act over a board you should report it to the owners of the board (they have the best chance of knowing the poster’s real name and forwarding that name to the police). Third, as a Pagans who draw energy from and worship the wonderful and awe-inspiring world created for us by the God(s) and Goddess(es) we should never encourage an act of animal cruelty (which this is, and is even posted under that heading at SkyNews where the original story came from). In my life I have noticed that Pagans often operate outside of social boundaries, which is of no consequence when we are following a differing set of values derived from the worship of an earth-based religion, but can become a problem when a minority of Pagans start to slide morally on the idea of living outside the law (drugs, etc.). I have come into contact with some Pagans who have the most outlandish of morals (sex with minors, using magic to wish injury or death upon others, etc.). Personally I have a strict set of magical ethics but I know others may not be as strict and that’s okay with me up to a point. I often get folks who want to be taught magic and when they find out the rules they are let down. A certain base level of morality should be shared by humans living in a group. For most these are “laws” and with a small exception of prejudicial and unfair laws they should be followed. We as Pagans must follow a higher standard that allows for our place as keepers of the natural world around us and the energies that flow in it. Blessed Be.