A modern Pagan perspectivePosts RSS Comments RSS

(Pagan) News of Note

My semi-regular round-up of articles, essays, and opinions of note for discerning Pagans and Heathens.

SF Weekly interviews Sister Edith Myflesh from the Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence and discusses the group’s popularity, charity work, religious diversity, and what real-live nuns think of them.

“…the sisters have no affiliation to any one creed. Some are pagan, some Jewish, even some practicing Catholics. Despite the church’s stance that the order “mocks” women who’ve taken traditional religious vows, Sister Edith swears the nuns she’s met have been nothing but supportive. “They get what we do,” she says, explaining that the tasks of the female clergy – caring for the sick, raising money for charity – have a lot in common with the sisters’. And like parishioners going to confession, Sister Edith has found that people blurt out the most personal things to a member of the order in full makeup. “When we look like that, we’re not human anymore. We become mirrors for people to project onto,” she says, recalling the times she’s given relationship advice to strangers.”

More subtle hints that as religion becomes ever-more female dominated boundary maintenance and the castigation of blasphemers will slowly lose its importance, replaced instead with a more pragmatic stance regarding the usefulness of holy fools?

Over at his Beliefnet blog, Gus diZerega gives a three-part argument (part one, part two, part three) against a “Pagan clergy”. In his final installment, diZerega argues that completely severing matters of faith and religion from government control (marriage, military, prison chaplaincy) will serve us far better than trying to construct an institutionalized clergy model.

“To sum it up, as our numbers increase we will need a larger professionally trained group of Pagans who can do some of the kinds of counseling work that Christians do through their clergy.  But we do not need that kind of institutionalized status to do it, and our traditions and the core of who we are will be safer if we do not seek it  We are on much safer ground to invoke the issue of religious freedom, now that we are widely recognized in the courts and among many religious leaders as a legitimate spiritual practice.”

DiZerega seems to assert that Pagan religious leaders should stick to ritual, rites of passage, and teaching, while other Pagans should pursue academic experience in counseling and medicine (and I’m assuming, legal arbitration), avoiding the  (corrupting?) confluence of power and influence usually associated with the monotheist clergy/laity model. Indeed, according to diZerega, the entire modern concept of “clergy” can contaminate us in our search for mainstream respectability.

The lesbian-focused site Lez Get Real features a short e-mail conversation with Pagan author Deborah Blake concerning Wiccan and Pagan attitudes towards homosexuality.

“First of all, in answer to your question about homosexuality–in general, Pagans accept all paths, very definitely including homosexuality. My step-daughter is gay and a Pagan. In fact, many gays, lesbians and transgenders are attracted to Wicca and Paganism in part because it is such an accepting religion. There is absolutely nothing in our beliefs that says that alternative sexuality is bad, forbidden or in any way “lesser” than more conventionally accepted sexuality.”

Always nice to see more communication between the LGBT community with the modern Pagan community. While there are a variety of attitudes within different modern Pagan religions concerning LGBT-folk, I would say that the vast majority are fully accepting and welcoming to gays. Indeed, as I’ve pointed out before, gay marriage is very much a Pagan issue too.

Over at Letter From Hardscrabble Creek, Chas Clifton passes along the news that HBO’s “Rome” may rise again as a feature-length film.

“A feature version may be in the works to wrap up the unresolved plot strands of the award-winning HBO/BBC TV series Rome, which dramatised the dirty-politics underside of Rome’s transitional period from republic to virtual monarchy amidst civil war.”

As much as I enjoyed the series, I thought it went (historically speaking) off the rails towards the end of its second season. I mean, they couldn’t even give poor Cicero his famous last words! Still, the sets were fantastic, and the religious elements engaging, so I suppose I’d fork over the cash to see a big-screen version should it actually come about.

In a final note, if you want to know how hard it really is to uncover Pagan news on a daily basis, check out the Pew Forum’s examination of religious news coverage in 2008.

“Throughout much of 2008, the media generally seemed to follow two patterns in its coverage of religion. First, religion reporting was often episodic, clustering intensely around big events such as the pope’s visit and religion stories related to the 2008 holiday season. Religion stories also faded quickly from the headlines. Second, the angle of religion coverage frequently gravitated toward controversies, such as Barack Obama’s relationship with Jeremiah Wright and stories about the clergy sex-abuse scandal that surfaced during the pope’s visit. This was particularly problematic for the presidential and vice-presidential candidates, who were inundated with questions concerning their faith.”

All in all, only 1% of mainsteam media coverage focused on religious news (on par with education, immigration, and race), and nearly 40% of that centered on the Pope’s visit to America. Considering the huge impact faith and religion have on the world, you would think it’d be a bit higher. If it weren’t for the Internet, blogs, and Google scouring every online news source, I doubt we’d hear much at all concerning minority faiths.

That’s all I have for now, have a great day!

8 responses so far

  • http://godsrbored.blogspot.com anne johnson

    Pagans don't get a lot of press, but I would never have found my Grove if it hadn't been for coverage in the Philadelphia Inquirer. Speaking of Groves, the pastoral model advocated by DiZerega is very Druidic.

  • http://witchschool.wordpress.com Ed Hubbard

    Getting press is also a lot of work. They just don't come seeking you out most of the time. You have to work to make yourself available. I know that sounds deeply cynical, but Media is a business, not a public trust. There is no requirement to cover all things fairly. The marketplace of ideas dominate, and it is a matter of eyeballs, bought and sold on a daily basis. (Wildhunt does not have this advertising..it is allowed to report as they choose).

    The press cover stories that they think will gather people to read/view/hear their product and listen to their advertising, in which they place stories around. Getting news stories published is a multi-billion dollar industry

  • Bjorn Odinsson

    I disagree with DiZerega. I do not think that the clergy model is harmful, rather it is the doctrines espoused by the monotheist clergy. In every Pre-Christian culture there has been a priest caste, rank, or profession. These people were supported by their community so that they could devote their entire lives to the understanding and preservation of the lore, rituals and maintain good relations with the Gods and Spirits. Pagan clergy need not be elitists, nor should they replace an individual's personal quest for connection with Diety. However very few of us can devote our entire lives to mainting a public temple, planning rituals and counselling students. This is one of the reasons HPs and HPSs burn out so regularly, as they are trying to live two full-time careers, their spiritual one and their mundane job.

    The Pagan community needs leaders who can devote their time and resources to deep study and reflection, and these leaders cannot exist without community support, as no one can live without income.

  • Bjorn Odinsson

    I would not seek out a secular therapist for spiritual issues, that therapist could be atheist, christian, jewish or muslim and have absolutely zero understanding of what it is to be a Heathen. How could this government sanctioned "professional" be of any help to me during a spiritual crisis?

    I am all for more secularized services being made available, but I am fully opposed to Pagan Priests becoming anachronistic.

  • Tomas

    I agree. What "clergy" means in Christianity and what "clergy" means in pagan religions are very different, and professional clerical classes have historically been a part of pre-Christian European paganisms. We need respectable, learned and professional people in our communities to provide guidance and direction, to facilitate rituals and sacrifices, to divine, to help propagate and continue traditional knowledge and lore, and to be spiritual and cultural leaders, and certainly pagans are capable of fulfilling those roles without adopting the Christian model of "clergy." Not everyone can be clergy, it takes a special person, but they are needed and their willing service and dedication should be welcomed, encouraged, and respected.

    Pagans need to stop looking at hierarchy, authority and tradition as if they are inherently bad and corruptible things.

  • AmericanTrikstr

    I miss Rome, though I haven't seen some the later episodes of Season 2. Would also pay good money for a big-screen version.

    I'm not fully against the idea of pagan "clergy" for services but I would be wary of any sort of institutionalization of our beliefs.

  • Baruch

    Unitarian Universalists have clergy, but manage to avoid the corruption that Gus thinks is endemic among clergy. UUs have had ministerial misconduct problems — improper sexual conduct with adult women in congregations — but have handled and resolved them well enough internally that there was no need for the media to break open the situation, nor for any parallel organizations comparable to SNAP.

    I think the basis for a model of Pagan clergy is the one I'm living with. My wife is an elder, a High Priestess and a secularly-trained counselor. She's currently counseling one of our coven pro-bono, and she has a secular public practice. This isn't a complete model, but it's a place to start, imho.

    Baruch Dreamstalker

  • Bjorn Odinsson

    YES! Finally someone who agrees! Thank you Tomas! What you said was *right* on and eloquently written. There is hope for Paganism!