A modern Pagan perspectivePosts RSS Comments RSS

Religious Drug Wars and other Pagan News of Note

Top Story: Jon Lee Anderson of the Guardian brings us a riveting look at the massively violent drug wars raging in Rio’s favelas, where over 5000 people were murdered last year, and police-affiliated militias can be as deadly as the gangs. While exploring the question of if this situation can be reversed, and the culture of these gangs, Anderson focuses on Fernandinho, a gang-leader who converted to evangelical Christianity in 2007 and melds Christian morals with the violence of his trade.

“On 20 August 2007, a banner headline of the Rio tabloid Meia Hora said: “Thug beheads those who don’t follow his rules”, and underneath, “Fernandinho Guarabu, Dendê’s boss, uses an axe to execute his victims. The evangelical trafficker forbids even macumba in the favela.” (Macumba refers to one of the country’s African-derived religions, along with Umbanda and Candomblé, which strict evangelicals see as little more than witchcraft.) That same day, in the broadsheet O Dia, this report appeared: “In spite of his violence, the ‘word of God’ must always be propagated, sometimes in a radical way. Guarabu has supposedly banned Umbanda and Candomblé rituals, as well as spiritualist séances. At 6pm every day, a pastor’s prayer echoes on the narrow alleys.” What had happened was that Fernandinho had become friendly with Pastor Sidney, and had been born again. He took to his new faith with great enthusiasm. He had “Jesus Cristo” tattooed on one of his forearms in big letters, and Morro do Dendê was soon covered with new religious graffiti. The community swimming pool he had built now had a sign above it saying, “This Belongs to Jesus Christ”. Also, Fernandinho had supposedly ordered his men not to carry out “violent” crimes, such as carjacking, armed robbery and murder, although he was still selling drugs.”

Naturally, the story of Fernandinho’s conversion doesn’t have a happy ending for the Christians who sought to curb his violence. His gang is back to murdering informants, and Fernandinho is estranged from the pastor who converted him. That hasn’t stopped other, less scrupulous, pastors from ingratiating themselves, or even allowing their churches to be used by his operation. Proof, perhaps, that mere conversion can’t solve these problems, and may even redirect the violence into places they hadn’t anticipated (the violence against non-Christians in his favela for instance). With the international spotlight shining on Rio for the upcoming 2016 Summer Olympics, it should be interesting to see what the government does to curb gang violence and reform the police forces before massive floods of international tourists arrive.

In Other News: The Poughkeepsie Journal has a surprisingly solid article by Lauren Yanks exploring the Winter Solstice from a variety of view-points both secular and spiritual. This includes a local Wiccan shop-owner and a Norse Pagan employee.

“Patrick Twamley also works at the Awareness Shop. Twamley follows the Norse pagan tradition. “In the Norse pagan tradition, the night before the solstice is usually called Mother’s Night,” he said. “It’s a time to honor the female ancestors of your line. This probably goes back to the idea of the mother giving birth to the sun.” As part of the Norse tradition, on the winter solstice Twamley sprinkles everybody with ale as a way of bestowing a blessing, usually out of a blessing bowl. Then there is a feast and a toast to the female spirits. “It’s a way to show gratitude for all we’ve been given,” he said.”

Yanks also asks academics about Native American traditions relating to the Winter Solstice, and interviews the minister of the Uniterian Universalist Fellowship in Poughkeepsie. Maybe papers should encourage more academics (Yanks teaches English at SUNY New Paltz) to write features for them, they, at least, know to quote multiple sources.

It seems English Catholic Archbishop Vincent Nichols made a theological faux pas while at a visit to a Hindu temple in London and (allegedly) placed flowers on the altar of the Hindu deities. This most likely unwitting violation of the First Commandment has gotten Rod “Crunchy Con” Dreher’s dander up.

“I’ll say this for the Muslims: they know better than to get into this syncretism garbage. It is not only possible to honor other religions without paying homage to their gods, it is mandatory for Christians. I would not expect a Jew or a Muslim to cross himself at a Christian altar, or before a Christian crucifix or an icon. Nor would I be insulted in the least if he didn’t. It’s those who are indifferent to what a gesture like this means that worry me.”

Ah yes, “syncretism garbage”. Never mind that this wasn’t an act of “syncretism”, but most likely an unwitting mistake, it’s enough of an excuse to unleash the river of bile and snark Dreher holds for minority non-Christian faiths in general, and for Pagan and African diasporic faiths in particular. Did a polytheist kick his puppy as a child? Did Wiccans steal his lunch-money? It can’t simply be Christian piety that drives this particular immaturity.

So have you heard about the Goth Pagan Robin Hood yet? No? You are so missing out! It seems a man calling himself Frater Osiris Xnoubis robbed a bank wearing black leathers and then proceeded to hand the money out at a local sandwich shop.

“He handed a note to terrified cashier Laura Sulling telling her he was armed and demanded she hand over the cash in her till. Xnoubis, a Pagan worshipper, stuffed £6,570 into a bag and told her to “have a nice day” before calmly walking out of the HSBC branch in Terminus Road, Eastbourne. He walked a few yards to The Gildridge pub where he handed barmaid Gemma Clark a £20 note for a bottle of beer and told her to keep the change. After downing his drink he left and went to nearby Harrisons sandwich bar. He handed the bag of cash to astonished owner Clive Benneys, who was also his landlord, saying: “You are good people, help yourselves.” Xnoubis left the shop and promptly went to the police station in Grove Road where he confessed to the robbery.”

A psychiatric report stated he was depressed, but not mentally ill. A judge sentenced him to three-and-a-half years after a guilty plea. Perhaps years from now they’ll sing ballads for brave Frater Osiris Xnoubis, who stole from the rich and gave to the poor. Perhaps they’ll give him a merry band of goths and Pagans who help him in his quest! Hey, stranger things have happened.

In a final note, Erynn Rowan Laurie has a review up of “Ten Years of Triumph of the Moon”, a collection of essays inspired by, deriving from, or just celebrating the influential work of historian Ronald Hutton. She finds several things to like about the collection, but says its hindered by sloppy editing and some rather mediocre essays.

“There are a number of other articles in the book, some of which are passable, but unfortunately one of the editors had the least readable and least useful article in the whole compilation. It’s unfortunate he didn’t himself have an editor to look over his own work. I think that if you’re a Hutton fan, you’ll find a lot to like in this book, as well as a few things that might challenge your opinions. If you’re not specifically a Hutton fan but are interested in the state of scholarship regarding Paganism and the occult today, this will also be quite worth reading. Just be prepared for a lot of bad editing.”

Shame about the editing really, you’d expect better from an academic-oriented collection. Still, I’m looking forward to getting my hands on a copy for review (and my own edification).

That’s all I have for now, have a great day!

26 responses so far

  • Hathor

    I'm continually surprised at all the sneering at syncretism from xians as of late. Go back far enough and you'll discover that all the monotheistic traditions borrowed freely from their neighbors all the time, used their myths, their Gods and holy days freely and wrote them into their own sacred traditions. No culture develops in a vacuum. There is even evidence that points to an early henotheistic Hebrew culture that revered many Gods at once! There is just no such thing as a single "pure" religious tradition, period.

  • http://www.hecatedemetersdatter.blogspot.com Hecate

    I'm still not sure how the bank robber's religion was relevant to the story.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Baruch Baruch

    When you see that kind of reaction, you should hypothesize that it's a defense and ask the question: By what or whom are they threatened? In this instance I would suggest that the sneerers see syncretism as a threat to Christianity, and they may be right. The kind of Christianity that depends on a strict interpretation of Scripture is coming up against female priests and gay bishops these days, with consequent schism in the offing, and may see syncretism as the next step on a very slippery doctrinal slope.

    BTW I use the same frame to look at Pagans who get bent out of shape by Christo-Paganism. That I assume to be the menacing residue of a toxic Christian upbringing.

    Baruch Dreamstalker

  • Hathor

    I always considered Christo-Paganism to be the default faith of most of our ancestors, wherein a Christian belief exists side by side with folk beliefs and customs and the people don't see any problem with that outlook. Because of that, I have no problem with that path either. ;)

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/chuck_cosimano chuck_cosimano

    Don't take Dreher too seriously, no one else does.

    Now, about Rio. Considering that the gangs are better armed than the police, one wonders what the going ransom will be for Olympic Athletes.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/GreenWaySkull GreenWaySkull

    A merry band of goths and pagans! TeHee. I like that.

  • sarrii

    I'm a little concerned that you seem to be praising the goth pagan robber. Just why is this given such a good reporting. Are you asking all pagans or goths to emulate this fellow? I think you've gone a bit daffy this time with that reporting.

  • William

    "This probably goes back to the idea of the mother giving birth to the sun."

    According to what? WHICH mother? Sounds a bit "Wiccatru."

  • Mageprof

    "A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds." That includes praising all the law-abiders and condemning all the law-breakers.

    In a world like ours, in which so much large-scale economic activity comes down to legally sanctioned theft, laws are often badly out of step with natural instincts about fairness and justice. A robbery like this one, where the robber turned himself in immediately afterward, somewhat restores the balance.

  • http://quakerpagan.blogspot.com/ Cat C-B

    Not Asatru, or a Norse specialist, but I have paid a bit of attention to the Old English Angles, Saxons, et al. There's not a lot to go on, but there is a reference in Bede to "Modronicht" as, I believe, Christmas Eve. There's that and the mysterious bas relief figures of three women identified as the Mothers (whose implements, hard to make out, have been identified in all sorts of ways, as food stuffs or midwifery equipment) bear at least some resemblance to other, Germanic figures identified with the disir… who are, in turn, variously identified with land spirits and ancestor spirits.

    Now, that's not a lot to base a holiday on… but, realistically, we have even less scholarly support for the pre-Christian Celtic celebration of Samhain. So, "Wiccatru"? Well, if nothing can be considered Asatru that's not in the Eddas, sure. But perhaps a soupcon of syncretism can be incorporated into modern Pagan reconstruction communities without their becoming bland and flavorless Wiccan offshoots (which seems to be the implication of William's jibe).

    It all depends on how purist you want to be. I do hope there's room for those who are creative and adaptive celebrants of Norse religion outside of Wicca. I suppose time will tell.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/thewildhunt Jason Pitzl-Waters

    Finding an isolated bank-robbery story amusing is a far cry from advocating a life of crime.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Nope Snoozepossum

    If everyone who was inclined to be a criminal (or a severely depressed nutjob) would do it by emulating this guy, instead of gunning people down as seems to be the current popular trend, we'd all be better off. I hope they're nice to him while he's in.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Nope Snoozepossum

    RE Archbishop Vincent Nichols goes a' visitin':

    Sigh. I don't have a problem with syncretism; I think it's more prevalent than orthodoxy. Also think the "syncretism" label is off the mark. "Interfaith" means they include representatives of multiple faiths in an action or event, not a blending of those faiths. Looks to me more like he was merely a good house guest, with hospitality gifts that were appropriate, and found ways to present them that were neither an insult to the host nor an abandonment of his beliefs.

    If I go to a Heathen friend's home for dinner, I'm likely to take cookies or cake, and give some to their house vaettir, disir, and ancestors. That's not syncretism, that's being a decent house guest.

  • Pitch313

    One of the advantages of Neo-Pagan polytheism that I hadn't thought of is that nobody complains about offerings that an adherent makes on whichever altar.

    What's the Catholic Archbishop to do when invited to a large and flourishing Hindu temple? Turn them down? Or be a decent sort and pay a visit, give a talk, nurture good fellowship among communities and religions?

    Speaking as somebody strongly influenced by and devoted to several Hindu deities, I don't think that this Archbishop placing flowers on a Hindu altar repudiates his Catholic faith or insults his co-religionists. At all.

    In some understandings of the Vaishnava pantheon, Jesus is regarded as an avatar of Vishnu, which after a fashion incorporates Christianity and Catholicism into the greater fold of Hinduism. Catholics could, in a similar manner, look at Hindu deities as "angelic," and grant them at least a glimpse of their heaven.

  • http://twitter.com/thelettuceman @thelettuceman

    See the movement best classified as Northern Tradition Pagansim, as opposed to more specific and purist or reconstructionist groups like Asatru or Heathenism. I personally have an issue with how Wicca, at least Neo-Wicca has gotten it into people's heads that they can mix and match whatever they wish into their own mish-mash of faith. But this is more an individual issue than that of the faith as a whole.

    But people also need to realize that not everyone who follows a Nordic or Northern Tradition cosmology is "Asatru" or identifies as a Heathen and some have faced active hostility in the community for their choice of worship. So yeah, it is basically your perspective and how purist you want to be.

  • http://twitter.com/thelettuceman @thelettuceman

    Yeah, I know. There needs to be more citation for a statement like this, else its veracity should be questioned. A blanket statement like this sort of presumptuous and sounds like its based more on hearsay than any factual account of some cultural understanding. In the Gylfaginning, High made mention of Mundilfaeri to Gangleri, who was the father of the Moon and Sol, but not who the mother is (and I cannot recall of there is any entity ever mentioned in the texts of the Edda that fills that role or not).

  • Jake

    Dreher would do well to reread his Burke, who expressed admiration and respect for Hinduism.

  • http://twitter.com/thelettuceman @thelettuceman

    I think you're reading too much into this. Do you sit in front of the television when you watch the evening news and wonder if they're advocating arson by listening to a newscast about it?

  • Nick Ritter

    I think that the Anglo-Saxon and Old Norse evidence don't have to be considered apart from one another. I agree with most scholars that the Germanic peoples as a whole practiced more-or-less the same religion, with some variations from people to people and across time. Therefore, it seems that, while there isn't much information on the religious practices of the Anglo-Saxons specifically, what evidence there is can be used to give a broader picture of Germanic religion in general.

    Bede gives the name as "Modra nect", which we can confidently normalize to "modra niht" translated "Mothers' (plural) Night". You mention disir, which is one possibility. Another possibility is the Norns. Oh, and there is evidence from Church penitentials that people would set out food for the "mothers" on this night, with three places set and three knives.

    Regarding syncretism: As a reconstructionist, I'm a bit leery of it, to say the least. However, I think that there could be a place for small syncretisms, so long as they are used sparingly and in an informed manner. I'll try to give an example of what I mean. Say that I know that a pair of Lithuanian twin gods, the dieva suneliai, are similar in origin, function, and mythology to the relatively more obscure Germanic twin gods, the Alcis. Of course, they're also similar to the Greek Dioskuroi and the Indian Ašvinau. Based on all of these sources (but primarily on the Baltic evidence, because they're the more nearly related culture to Germanic), I could base my knowledge of and worship of the Alcis, at least until more direct information comes to light; I might even use Baltic symbols and objects in that worship. This is syncretism, but it is an informed, and theoretically temporary syncretism.

    Syncretism based only on surface similarities (for instance, between the Germanic "mothers" and, the Magna Mater of the Phrygians, or between, say, Freyja and Astarte) runs the risk of misunderstanding the more obscure figures in favor of the better-known ones, or of misunderstanding both. This kind of syncretism doesn't do justice to any of the traditions being syncretized, in my opinion (pace, those of you who think otherwise).

  • http://www.walkofthefallen.com Labrys

    I tend to agree. I do have Ancestor Gumbo. I find it hard to choose one "pure" path and ignore the rest of my personal history and ancestry. I tend to be a skeptical sort and generally only speak to deities who speak to me FIRST. And no, they do not always get along perfectly; even the relatively insensible type that I am, I "feel" a rivalry between Athena and Freyja, for instance. Athena has been a personal "matron" relationship deity since I was 20 and not even formally pagan! I do have a tendency to syncretism—it is the only way I can keep a handle on all the threads of ancestry and spiritual connection.

  • http://twitter.com/thelettuceman @thelettuceman

    See the movement best classified as Northern Tradition Pagansim, as opposed to more specific and purist or reconstructionist groups like Asatru or Heathenism. I personally have an issue with how Wicca, at least Neo-Wicca has gotten it into people's heads that they can mix and match whatever they wish into their own mish-mash of faith. But this is more an individual issue than that of the faith as a whole.

    But people also need to realize that not everyone who follows a Nordic or Northern Tradition cosmology is "Asatru" or identifies as a Heathen and some have faced active hostility in the community for their choice of worship. So yeah, it is basically your perspective and how purist you want to be.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Nope Snoozepossum

    Lessee, Dreher . . . Dreher . . . doesn't he have a brother named Crunchy Frog?

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Erynn Erynn

    I don't have any issues with well-thought-out syncretism either. No spirituality arose in a vacuum. Everyone in the ancient world was being influenced by somebody.

  • Sarenth

    In terms of syncretism and eclectic pantheon interactions, I have quite a number of Deities from a variety of backgrounds. Does this mean that I have cobbled together a personal pantheon willy-nilly with no thought to cultural overtones or undertones, or that I have taken in my information on these Deities and how I can relate to them in a vacuum? No.

    A lot of Deities that have come to me have come through others. I started off working with Brighid and Bres in a Neo-Wiccan fashion when I first started on my path in Paganism, then grew to know Anubis and Bast through an priestess who worked with Egyptian Deities. Before I began work with them, I did as much research as I could with what resources I had available. Any 'cracks' in my education I had to fill as I went along, or had to be experienced via UPG.

    I guess what I find refreshing is that only one person has poked fun at those who have syncretism as part of their practice has done so for a good reason: accuracy of information that can be verified from outside sources. In my personal experiences with Anubis I have had and do have experiences that Papyri and hieroglyphs give little or no indication to, but I believe I have nonetheless had them. I did much in the way of research before, a year after initial contact with Him, I accepted His invitation to work with Him.

    Not everyone that seems to patch together pantheons may simply be doing so just for kicks or is doing so in having a lack of understanding Deities and their particular place(s) in society, relationships to one another, etc. With most Deities that have come to me or vice versa for a working relationship, I personally engage after long deliberation, considering sources of information, and ultimately, trusting my feelings, intuitions, and experiences in addition to research. I'm not collecting Deities, I'm choosing to engage or not engage in relationships as they come to me.

    Have Anubis and Bast worked together in the past? This can be answered in some quantity by doing the research. Do these two work together in today's age? As I see it, this can be answered by personal experience, by asking another of their experience(s) with these two Deities, and/or applying ancient understandings of these Gods to modern times and working it out on your own as to what is the most logical. But to each their own.

    I definitely respect Reconstructionists for their dedication to understanding and, where possible, doing as much as possible with the remnants of the practices and workings of the cultures they are engaged with, connecting modern techniques in logical syncretism because of gaps in scholarly works and/or integrating their own experiences into their practice. This isn't easy, as I found in trying to keep to workings with Anubis when I started working with Him, as close to Ancient Egyptian ways as I could.

  • http://apaganheart.blogspot.com embreis

    Yes, Peace, Nick. We also like you fine even if you do believe you can "reconstruct" ancient religions that never actually existed as a uniform body of belief by imposing relatively by imposing relatively modern concepts on a ffew scattered fragments of information about ancient practices that may or may not have been in any way related.

  • Nick Ritter

    How are you, Embreis? It certainly sounds like you have some spleen to vent concerning Reconstructionism. Very well, fire away. What "relatively modern concepts" do we impose on our scattered fragments of information, and how, specifically, are we led into error thereby? Also, please give examples, where possible, of people doing what you say. Spare nothing, friend, the forum is yours!