Religion Coverage is Going to the Blogs

The Pew Research Center’s Project for Excellence in Journalism and The Pew Forum on Religion & Public Life have released a study that analyzes news coverage of religion for 2009. The take-home message? Mainstream media coverage of religion continues to shrink (0.8% of the news, as opposed to 1% last year), and new media (blogs, web sites, podcasts, etc) is taking up the slack, and becoming the primary outlet for religion news, debate, and discussion.

In 2009, religion attracted significantly more attention in new media sources than in the mainstream media.in a sample drawn from millions of blogs and social media finds that religion was a top story in nearly a quarter of the weeks studied (11 out of 45 weeks) … The blogosphere and other social media tools have grown over the past few years. According to the Pew Internet & American Life Project, 51% of internet users post online content that they have created themselves. Eleven percent of all adults use blogs. The use of Twitter has tripled since 2008. At the same time, the number of reporters assigned to the religion beat in the mainstream media has been shrinking. According to Debra Mason, executive director of the Religion Newswriters Association, at least 16 major print news outlets have reduced or abandoned their religion beats since 2007. At the same time, she says, online newspapers such as The Huffington Post and Politics Daily have increased their religion staff. “We’re in the midst of growth of the [religion] beat online,” Mason says, “but newspapers haven’t kept up with the trend and have instead let religion coverage languish.” An analysis of nearly a year’s worth of commentary

Not only is new media now dominating in coverage of religious news, we’re more diverse as well. While MSM religion coverage, when it happened, was primarily focused on Pope Benedict or religious angles to developments within the Obama Administration, new media religion stories “were broad in scope”, and wildly successful in engaging their audience.

Another interesting tidbit I found is that while new media sources continue to rely heavily on mainstream media as a jumping-off point for opinion and analysis, a growing number of bloggers are creating their own content.

“The blogosphere and other social media tools have grown over the past few years. According to the Pew Internet & American Life Project, 51% of internet users post online content that they have created themselves. Eleven percent of all adults use blogs. The use of Twitter has tripled since 2008.”

As this shift to new media continues, you’ll continue to see the professionalization of the religious blogosphere. If you take a quick look at the Social Science Research Council‘s study “The New Landscape of the Religion Blogosphere”, you’ll see that a good number of the leading blogs and web sites driving religion coverage on the web are either run by journalism professionals, are extensions of non-profits, or are part of for-profit ventures (even The Wild Hunt is attempting to evolve into an NPR donation-supported model).

There’s a reason why The Huffington Post has dived into religion coverage, the public is hungry for news and analysis on this large and unwieldy subject, and the mainstream media doesn’t seem to have the inclination or resources to do the job properly. In the future, the “big” religious stories will be reported on the Internet first, and “trickle up” to cable news and newspapers. So it makes sense that we’ll see more new media start-ups, like HuffPost and Patheos.com who want to be a part of driving that discussion. For minority faiths (and minority groups in general), it’ll be more important than ever to have a strong Internet news-making and reporting presence. Without one, we’ll have little to no say in how news about our communities gets reported, and groups that have no desire to participate in a link-based economy will find themselves increasingly marginalized.

Quick Note: American Mystic Movie Trailer Now Up

The film “American Mystic”, one of twelve entries in The Tribeca Film Festival’s World Documentary Feature Competition for 2010, has released its official trailer and web site.

A still from the “American Mystic” trailer.

Directed and co-produced by Alex Mar of Empire 8 Productions, the film features Pagan priestess Morpheus Ravenna, who, along with her husband Shannon, operates the Stone City Pagan Sanctuary in California’s Diablo Range, just outside the San Francisco Bay Area. If this trailer is any indication of the overall quality, it may be one of the best documentaries featuring modern Paganism in recent memory.

Morpheus Ravenna is planning to be in New York for the premiere, so hopefully we’ll hear about her experiences regarding the film, and get a sense of how the audience reacted. I’ll try to keep you posted regarding screenings, the eventual DVD release, and hopefully an interview with director Alex Mar regarding the project.

The Fall of a Witch-Hunter

News media in East Central Illinois have been following the case of Andrew L. Thomas, a youth minister and track coach in Rossville, Illinois who’s been charged with the rape of 16-year-old boy he was mentoring.

“Andrew Thomas made his first appearance in court today. He’s been the youth minister at Rossville Church of Christ for three years, according to court records. Prosecutors say he had sex with a 16 year old boy he was mentoring. They say it happened over the last few months. The victim came forward to police. Thomas was arrested last night. If convicted, Thomas faces up to 15 years in prison. His friends, family, and church community are standing behind him. Prosecutors say more charges could be filed. They are investigating whether he may have child pornography on his computer.”

While these accusations against a Christian clergyman seem sadly pedestrian in an age of massive abuse scandals, this case draws special attention for our community. For while Thomas was allegedly abusing young boys, he was also leading an anti-Pagan crusade in order to drive Witch School out of Rossville, Illinois.

“Andy Thomas, youth minister at the Rossville Church of Christ, said residents had a spiritual responsibility to drive the witches out. If they didn’t, he said, young people were in danger of being pulled off the Christian path …”

The bitter irony of a man trying to protect “young people” from Witches while allegedly abusing them hasn’t escaped the folks at Witch School (since relocated to Salem, Massachusetts), who have released a statement concerning the matter.

“Pastor Andy Thomas, which claimed superior rights has now been arrested for Criminal Sexual Assault against a minor, and will face trial for them. He is alleged to have had sexual encounter with a 16 year old boy under his mentorship, and is under investigation for child pornography. He is still innocent until proven guilty, these are serious charges that question the intentions and his moral standing in the community. Our heart goes out to his alleged victim and there families, as this must be very difficult to deal with. We feel for the Rossville community, which trusted this man to give them clear spiritual advise, and instead betrayed them, in this case with their own children. In truth, he abused their trust as well, when he led them in vigorous protest against Witch School, which had never once involved in any activity to harm the community. Pastor Andy Thomas worked hard to assure the community and the nation knew how awful it was that Witch School was, while he was the individual who was bringing real harm to the community.”

You can see further reactions from Witch School at Rev. Don’s Vlog.

While his church community claims to be standing behind him, one has to wonder how many in Rossville are now questioning the past actions of this pastor, and if his obsession with driving out the “harmful” Witches wasn’t an externalization of the same deep seated psychosis that allegedly drove him to abuse children. Did he believe that by driving out the “other” he could also drive out the same demons that haunted him? Or was his religious zeal all a smokescreen for a deep-seated abusive nature? In any case, no matter what the ultimate outcome, this Witch-hunter has fallen.

Update: The Wiccan Dagger Murder

On Tuesday I was complaining that police officials and local media seemed to be ignoring the voices of the Pagan community in the case of Angela Sanford, an Albuquerque resident who used her ritual blade (athame) to kill Joel Leyva, allegedly in self-defense after an attempted sexual assault. Well, that’s all changed, local television station KRQE interviews Wiccan Linda Owl, and she isn’t happy.

“That excuse is not sitting well with other Wiccans. Linda Owl, a local practicing Wiccan, said Sanford is using the Wiccan religion as an excuse for her actions on Monday. Owl says a Wiccan would never use a ritual dagger as a weapon. “A dagger like this,” Owl told News 13 as she held her own 12-inch long dagger. “Would be blessed and cleansed in rituals and (to use it as a weapon) it would be so wrong.” Wiccans, according to Owl, place heavy symbolism on items like candles and necklaces. None of those items were part of Sanford’s ritual.”

I don’t know about you, but if I felt truly threatened, I’d be tempted to use a consecrated blade in my defense. I also find it problematic that Ms. Owl is taking the “she was doing it wrong” defense, especially considering the wide variety of eclectic practice in modern Wicca. Still, at least the press is talking to local Pagans. Meanwhile, APD Chief Ray Schultz, recovering from his “solstice” gaffe, has been inundated with calls from Wiccans, and is clarifying his department’s stance on Sanford’s religion.

“Albuquerque Police Chief Ray Schultz said his detectives are trying learn more about the religion Sanford claims to practice. “Our detectives are trying to educate themselves and I know we have some community members of the Wiccan [practice] who have offered to share information with us about what the religion is and is not,” said Schultz. Schultz said he’s getting a lot of e-mails and phone calls from the Wiccan community in New Mexico and across the country stressing that murder and violence are not part of their beliefs.Schultz said Sanford’s Wiccan connections are not confirmed.”We’ve been very clear from the beginning [that] the offender, Ms. Sanford, is a self-proclaimed Wiccan. We’ve never said we’ve been able to directly link her to any Wiccan society. That’s just her telling us that,” Schultz said.”

Let it not be said that speaking up doesn’t work. The tone of the religion angle to this story has completely changed in the course of 48 hours, and may very well affect how this case is prosecuted.

Here in the comments section of The Wild Hunt, a local Albuquerque Pagan has come forward to give some insight into how the community has been reacting to this situation, and also noting that Sanford is “unknown” to the larger community.

“There is doubt in the local community that this person is Wiccan, not only because this incident happened at all, but also because it involved a (in the great words of the Abq Journal again) “Wicca ceremonial dagger” [sic] and she said the holiday was Beltane. For whatever its worth (which may not be much), the suspect is unknown in the larger local pagan community.”

Also of note is that an alleged former boyfriend of Sanford’s has come forward saying that there is no way she could have murdered Leyva in cold blood.

“Angela was my ex girlfriend. She did not murder him. It had to be self defense. She had a phobia about men after being raped. I went to that area where she stabbed that guy with her many times. She is not that kind of person. She raised her daughter and her nephew. That guy had to of done something to her to cause her to do such a thing.”

It should be noted that no one really knows what happened between Sanford and Leyva, and despite the inconsistencies in Sanford’s story, it very well could be a case of self-defense, or at least a trauma-related break from reality. Either scenario could explain the discrepancies between the collected evidence and her statement to police. So let’s remember that she’s innocent until proven guilty, and not be too quick to pass judgment from incomplete press reports and police statements. Let’s keep our criticisms to how the press and law enforcement are handling this case, and not focus overmuch on if Sanford was being ritually correct, or using the proper terminology.