My arguments aren’t reasonable! Checkmate, atheist!

I get this type of comment from believers a lot, most recently from a chap named Bob Hunt who didn’t like Glodson’s glorious take down of the first cause argument:

Mr/Ms. Glodson,

Atheism is irrational because the classic arguments against the existence of God are arguments from faith, not reason.
You have many good questions re: the First Cause Argument. I’m afraid, however, that your response betrays a basic understanding of Aquinas’ argument. I work nights, so I’m only getting home recently and finding your post. I’ll get back to you on that.
I do enjoy respectful, meaningful conversations with those who think differently than I. I hope you do, too.

I just don’t get it.  How can you lead off with “my arguments are not based on reason” and still think you’re in the argument?  Hell, Hunt clearly thinks announcing that his arguments aren’t reasonable gives him a leg up!

Faith is simply poison to the minds of liberals and fundamentalists alike, even if the poison isn’t quite as debilitating in some.  But they all think faith is a good justification for believing the most outlandish things.  In a just world, they’d all be embarrassed.

"It does come off as shady, doesn't it."

I’ll be doing a debate in ..."
"so you are against the mentally challenged as well, huh, "Ed"? Seems you have no ..."

Frank Turek fears me. Also he ..."
"sure, Ed, sure....again, when you can't make an argument, and like most new atheists, start ..."

Frank Turek fears me. Also he ..."
"ah yes...when you have no evidence nor scholarly authoritative knowledge, make the usual ad-hominem attacks...well ..."

Frank Turek fears me. Also he ..."

Browse Our Archives

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment