Humanists UK takes on Catholic Education Service … and loses

Humanists UK takes on Catholic Education Service … and loses February 23, 2019

A LEGAL challenge against Catholic schools advertising that jobs that can only be filled by practicing Catholics has been dismissed.

Humanists UK, which campaigns against faith schools, argued that EU law means that such advertising breached EU law and amounts to illegal discrimination, and it brought a case against the Catholic Education Service (CES).

But the Rt Hon Lord Justice Flaux has upheld an earlier ruling in the High Court that described Humanist UK’s arguments as having “a certain artificiality”.

Image via Chartered College of Teaching

Paul Barber, above, the Director of the Catholic Education Service, describes the ruling as:

Highly significant and extremely welcome.

Barber said recruiting Catholic staff ensures the schools maintain their character.

There are certain posts for which it’s really important that you have somebody who is a full member of the believing community.

More than 850,000 children attend Catholic schools, which Barber says make up 10 percent of all state schools. They’re popular with both Catholic and non-Catholic families.

In order to provide them with an authentic Catholic education it’s essential that we’re able to have Catholic staff to lead and teach in those schools

Humanists UK campaign against faith schools, and believe it’s wrong for education funded from taxes to be provided to Christian denominations. The attempt to launch a judicial review over job adverts was part of that campaign.

Barber says the Catholic Church will continue to defend its role in primary and secondary education vigorously.

It’s not something that can be done lightly or cheaply and we need to have the resources to fight those battles because the alternative is that we lose the rights and freedoms that we’ve enjoyed for many years.

CES says the latest court decision isn’t open to further appeals, and so Humanists UK will not be able to launch its proposed Judicial Review proceedings.

"If I, for some reason, set myself on fire, my neighbours would be in their ..."

Angry anti-vaxxers reportedly ‘lose their minds’ ..."
"Your failure to join in the community immunity signals that you don't wish to join ..."

Angry anti-vaxxers reportedly ‘lose their minds’ ..."
"Vaccines are a public health solution. There's no valid issue."

Angry anti-vaxxers reportedly ‘lose their minds’ ..."
"Vaccine companies have legal immunity from being sued for problems under control only of others. ..."

Angry anti-vaxxers reportedly ‘lose their minds’ ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


TRENDING AT PATHEOS Nonreligious
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Jim Jones

    > CES says the latest court decision isn’t open to further appeals, and so Humanists UK will not be able to launch its proposed Judicial Review proceedings.

    Best to keep working on making all public schooling religion free. Religion should support its own indoctrination.

  • Broga

    “the Rt Hon Lord Justice Flaux has upheld an earlier ruling in the High Court that described Humanist UK’s arguments as having “a certain artificiality”.
    Not as much artificiality that I, as paid up pleb, (I admit my circumstances I have dramatically improved since then) feel towards a judge with his title and his very likely expensive private education.

    Was it Elvis Presley who said, “You can take the man out of the ghetto, but you can’t take the ghetto out of the man.” That is true.

  • Matt G

    I think a religious school in the US can only discriminate based on religion for religious jobs (like chaplain) but not for other positions (teacher, administrator, etc). Correct me if I’m wrong. Or am I thinking of religious organizations themselves? Or both.

  • guerillasurgeon

    “In order to provide them with an authentic Catholic education”
    There is no such thing as a Catholic education. There is simply religious instruction.