Trio Arrested in Viral Feel Good GoFundMe Scam of $400,000

Trio Arrested in Viral Feel Good GoFundMe Scam of $400,000 November 16, 2018

Online crowdfunding sites are all the rage to help raise money for a litany of causes. GoFundMe is the granddaddy of all the sites. While most users that raise money on the site are honest with their stories, there is a pocket of users that use the site for fraudulent purposes. A viral campaign to help a homeless veteran raked in more than $400,000.00. However, yesterday prosecutors in New Jersey said the campaign to rescue the vet was built on a lie. Authorities arrested Johnny Bobbit, Mark D’Amico, and Katelyn McClure for their massive theft from more than 14,000 donors.

In November 2017, McClure and D’Amico created a campaign on GoFundMe. The campaign titled “Paying it Forward” told a compelling story about a homeless veteran.

In the now removed campaign, the campaign told donors that McClure ran out of gas on an off-ramp. After running out of gas, the campaign said that Bobbit gave McClure his last $20 to fill up her gas tank.

“I never ran out of gas before, and my heart was beating out of my chest. I pulled over as far as I could, and got out of the car to head to the nearest gas station,” she wrote.

“That’s when I met Johnny. … He told me to get back in the car and lock the doors. A few minutes later, he comes back with a red gas can. Using his last 20 dollars to make sure I could get home safe.”

To thank him for his good deed, McClure said she wanted to raise money to help Bobbit get back on his feet.

The money raised in the campaign was supposed to help Bobbit secure housing. Initially, donors flocked to the campaign, and by mid-December 2017, the campaign raised more than $400,000.00 to help Bobbit.

As the campaign continued to raise money, Bobbit, D’Amico, and McClure made appearances on multiple media outlets. They appeared on Good Morning America and Ellen.

Media outlets around the world picked up the story. The couple was praised for their efforts in helping Bobbit. Bobbit became a media hero for assisting McClure in her time of need.

By Summer 2018, the relationship soured between the couple and Bobbit. Bobbit sued the couple for stealing campaign money. The couple appeared on the Today show to deny Bobbit’s allegations of theft. D’Amico and McClure started to look like greedy swindlers. The media portrayed Bobbit as a victim.

As summer of 2018 wrapped up, the couple and Bobbit took their fight into the courtroom. In court proceedings, the couple admitted there was no money left for Bobbit.

Based on this in court admission, authorities began investigating the theft allegation against D’Amico and McClure. Authorities executed a search warrant on their property in September. Police raided their home and removed a 2015 BMW, jewelry, cash, and the couple’s personal and business financial statements.

Police seized the couple’s phones and got access to more than 60,000 text messages. As a result, investigators uncovered the fraud committed by the couple and Bobbit.

Only hours after McClure uploaded the campaign to GoFundMe, she text messaged a friend. The message read:

“The gas part is completely made up … but the guy isn’t. I had to make something up to make people feel bad … So, shush about the made up part.”

Additional messages between D’Amico and McClure revealed the two met Bobbit more than a month before she launched the GoFundMe campaign. The couple initially met Bobbit panhandling off the interstate in October 2017.  The New York Post shared excerpts from their conversation:

“[I don’t know] why but that homeless guy by sugarhouse [sic] just keeps popping in my damn head today,” McClure, 28, text messaged her boyfriend on Oct. 16, 2017.

“Dude I just thought about him!!” replied D’Amico, 39, as the conversation turned to ways to help out the 35-year-old former Marine: Food, clothes, a Nintendo Switch, even a job, and a house.

According to prosecutors, the couple decided to go back to off-ramp where they first met Bobbit. The couple found Bobbit, took the photo and conspired with Bobbit to create the campaign. The entire story about McClure running out of gas was a lie.

Initially, authorities believed Bobbit played no part in the conspiracy to defraud donors. However, they uncovered a 2012 tweet by Bobbit that spun a very similar tale.

“So this girl runs out of gas and has a flat tire at the same time in front of Wal-Mart and is blocking traffic,” he wrote. “So I run to the gas station and then change her tire. I spent the only cash I had for supper, but at least she can get her little children home safe.”

Authorities were unable to determine if the 2012 incident occurred. Investigators are unsure if the story was real and used to inspire the 2017 campaign. However, authorities did say they do not believe it’s a coincidence.

Additional texts between the couple admitted their role in spending the money raised for Bobbit. They admitted to purchasing a car, taking multiple trips, and buying expensive handbags with the money.

D’Amico seemed confident that even if they ran out of money from the campaign, he and McClure could secure a book deal. Unfortunately, what unraveled the fraud appears to be the greed of McClure and D’Amico.

New Jersey prosecutor Scott Coffina told the media in a press conference how the scam ultimately fell apart.

“[McClure] did not run out of gas on an I-95 off-ramp, and [Bobbitt] did not spend his last $20 to help her,” Coffina said. “Rather, D’Amico, McClure and Bobbitt conspired to fabricate and promote a feel-good story that would compel donors to contribute to their cause.”

He explained that Bobbit’s lawsuit against the couple unraveled the story. If McClure and D’Amico had given Bobbit a more substantial chunk of the proceeds from the campaign, authorities might have never uncovered their fraud.

In the press conference, Coffina said that McClure and D’Amico had been arrested for their role in the fraud. The couple had been processed and released pending a court date in December.

Bobbit was taken into custody in Pennsylvania. Coffina said they are awaiting extradition of Bobbit to charge him for his role in the crime.

Coffina stressed that Bobbit does deserve respect for his service, but reiterated that Bobbit is not innocent in the scheme.

“He deserves our appreciation for his willingness to serve our country as a United States Marine, and he has our sympathy and concern for the homelessness that he’s experienced, as well as his publicized struggle with addiction,” Coffina added.

“But it is imperative to keep in mind that he was fully complicit in the scheme to defraud contributors.”

GoFundMe promised to refund the more than 14,000 contributors to the campaign. McClure’s attorney issued a statement placing the blame solely on the shoulders of Bobbit and D’Amico:

“I’m confident that in the end, the evidence will reveal that Kate had only the best intentions,” Gerrow said. “She was used by Mr. D’Amico and Mr. Bobbitt, and she thought throughout that this money was going to a homeless veteran. She was unaware that they had concocted this scheme. It wasn’t until September when meeting with prosecutors that she came to realize that she had been used by both of them.”

The couple and Bobbit are scheduled to appear in court in December. If convicted on the charges, the trio will face up to a decade in prison.

When something sounds too good to be true, there is a likelihood that the story is not real. It appears this story falls in that category.


Follow me on Facebook

Talk to Me on Twitter

Follow my Boards on Pinterest

On Instagram

If you enjoy my articles, please consider a one time gift via my Buy Me a Coffee Account. I work hard to provide insightful content every day for you to enjoy.

Buy me a coffeeBuy me a coffee


Subscribe and commit to a small monthly donation to support my writing. Funding provided by donations allow me to pay for images, pay contributors, and raise funding for grants for families of children with disabilities.

Subscribe to My Patreon Account



"Has it ever been confirmed that Jani tested at a 146 IQ? I've seen that ..."

Girl from “Born Schizophrenic” Off All ..."
"Somebody failed biology in high school!"

CDC Blames Anti-Vaxxers for Worst Measles ..."
"Top selling =/= top profits.Try again, this time with metrics that matter. You won't, because ..."

It’s Time to Admit That Anti-Vaxxers ..."
"But we don't have a decent system so the question does need to be asked. ..."

Judge Rules that Denying Boy Chemotherapy ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • WallofSleep

    It’s deceptions like this which can cause people to shun the needy. In their malicious efforts to enrich themselves, they will cause others to think twice about charity.

    “She was unaware that they had concocted this scheme. It wasn’t until September when meeting with prosecutors that she came to realize that she had been used by both of them.”

    Bull. Shit. She knew it was a lie from the start. Any judge that falls for that BS deserves to be impeached/disbarred.

  • given text messages prove otherwise – we can say – “that was a lie”

  • WallofSleep

    Still, it’s nice to know that there are still cons out there who will throw their co-conspirators under the bus at the first hint of trouble.

  • persephone

    I have given to a few gofundmes, but they were always referred by someone I know or have reason to trust. I don’t have a lot to spare, but putting in $10 or $20 occasionally helps someone. I’ve been way broke, beyond broke, and I know the pain of literally counting pennies, having electricity shut off, struggling to keep up appearances at work, etc.

  • Jim Jones

    > After running out of gas, the campaign said that Bobbit gave McClure his last $20 to fill up her gas tank.

    I found that a dubious story, however I waited for evidence.

    (And my mind flashed to John Bobbit, ironically named).

  • WallofSleep

    “… ironically named.”

    I’m glad I’m not the only one to notice that. SMTA.

  • B.A.

    That makes 3 of us. Great minds think alike,lol.

  • WallofSleep

    I’m sure everyone knows that “bobbing” can mean the same as “docking”, as in docking an animal’s tail, right?

  • Cozmo the Magician

    What really really sucks about this is that the money these crooks got probably would have gone to help people who REALLY needed it. How many homeless starved or froze to death because they did NOT get help because people gave the money to these evil pricks? That is what bugs me.

  • and the homeless guy blew through $25,000 on drugs

  • Sara Bersani

    I hope that the raised money will be redistributed to real people in need