New Details Emerge in the New York Medical Kidnapping Case

New Details Emerge in the New York Medical Kidnapping Case November 4, 2018

In a recent article, we shared the story of Nicholas Gunderson. Nicholas, 13, is in the middle of a bitter custody battle between his mother and Child Protective Services in New York. Nicholas is battling an aggressive form of leukemia. Doctors and CPS argue Nicholas needs to complete several more rounds of chemotherapy to treat cancer. Candace Gundersen, his mother, wanted to use alternative health treatments to keep Nicholas in remission. CPS took custody of Nicholas late last week, and Candace is all over social media crying Medical Kidnapping. We poked holes in her claims yesterday. Today new details emerged furthering weakening her claims of kidnapping.

In June 2018, doctors diagnosed Nicholas with an acute form of leukemia. The type of leukemia, acute mixed phenotype acute leukemia, is aggressive and deadly. Effective treatment of MPAL requires two phases of treatment. Patients receive induction chemotherapy to rid the body of cancer cells.

After the patient’s body is cleared of cancer cells, patients begin post-remission treatment. MPAL post-remission treatment consists of chemotherapy, radiation, and stem-cell transplants.

Nicholas’ mother, Candace, says doctors misdiagnosed Nicholas with the wrong form of cancer. After they received the diagnosis, she immediately asked for a second opinion. Doctors from NYU Winthrop told her Nicholas did not receive an incorrect diagnosis.

Candace claims doctors threatened to call CPS if she did not consent to chemotherapy. In an interview with ABC7 NY, Candace says, “They told me if I didn’t consent to the treatment they would call CPS and have me removed, and my son would have the treatment anyway. So I signed the consent.”

Naturally, Nicholas got very ill from the chemotherapy. Candace didn’t like how sick Nicholas became and decided she wanted to pursue other alternatives for his next round of treatment.

Candace is a wellness and health coach. She says she wanted to explore natural methods to keep Nicholas in remission. She worked with “doctors” in Florida to develop a treatment plan for Nicholas.

Candace alleges on her GoFundMe page that CPS agreed to the treatment plan. However, Nicholas needed to return to NY Winthrop for scheduled chemotherapy on October 25th. When she did not bring Nicholas back to the hospital on the 25th, Candace says CPS changed their tune about the treatment plan.

In the same interview with ABC7, Candace said:

“They told me he needed to have chemotherapy and that I needed to provide documentation that he was getting chemotherapy and that if he’s not getting chemotherapy, it’s going to be a problem.”

The report went on to say:

CPS brought an emergency removal proceeding on October 19th to seize control of Nick. Dr. Mark Weinblatt of NYU Winthrop testified a week later before a Suffolk County family court judge that Nick was in imminent danger of death. On October 26, the judge granted custody of Nick to CPS and ordered him back to Suffolk County. Nick left Florida and was admitted on October 30 to NYU Winthrop.

J. Edmund Keating with NYU Winthrop Hospital said in a statement to Eyewitness News: “Our treatment of the child is based upon the highest standards of medical care and is a result of collaboration with the child’s legal guardian, who directed that the child come to NYU Winthrop Hospital.”

Nicholas is now in the hospital receiving his needed chemotherapy. Apparently, Nicholas is upset about being in the hospital. He believes that because he doesn’t have cancer, he doesn’t need more treatment. However, at age 13, Nicholas is unable to understand the severity of his diagnosis.

Doctors, in this case, executed an emergency court proceeding because they feared Nicholas would die without chemotherapy. Candace’s plans to treat the illness are not backed by science nor approved methods for killing cancer.

Holistic treatments, diet, and supplements can be used in conjunction with chemotherapy. However, these methods do not kill cancer or keep aggressive forms of leukemia in remission.

Candace fails to understand the severity of her son’s diagnosis. Instead of relying on proven methods and recommended standards of care, Candace wants to try a route supported by pseudoscience and holistic scammers.

CPS, in this case, stepped in because doctors know Nicholas will die without more chemotherapy. Nicholas is not a victim of medical kidnapping.

Candace uses the fact that CPS and the hospital cannot speak due to privacy acts protecting juvenile cases and patient’s medical records. When only half the story is published, anyone could easily believe her claims.

She is also using all of this attention to fuel a GoFundMe set up for Nicholas’ treatments. However, she admits in updates the money is being used for attorneys for the legal case with CPS. A case that would not be necessary if she complied with the doctor’s orders.

Candace also has not secured permanent housing for her and Nicholas. Despite a GoFundMe account swelling to $31,000. In her most recent update on GoFundMe, Candace said the following:

If you are CPS and doctors, would you release a child to a mother that wanted to treat with quack medicine? Would you also be ok releasing a child extremely sick with a deadly disease to a mother that has no permanent address?

Of course not!

There are reasons that the state stepped in to protect Nicholas. Candace is not the victim here. She is a predator crying foul and garnering attention for her cause. Thankfully for Nicholas, the state recognizes the danger he is in and will keep him safe.

Candace may love her son. However, Nicholas’ best shot at beating cancer is in the care of CPS and doctors at NYU Winthrop.

Follow me on Facebook

Talk to Me on Twitter

Follow my Boards on Pinterest

On Instagram

If you enjoy my articles, please consider a one time gift via my Buy Me a Coffee Account. I work hard to provide insightful content every day for you to enjoy.

Buy me a coffeeBuy me a coffee


Subscribe and commit to a small monthly donation to support my writing. Funding provided by donations allow me to pay for images, pay contributors, and raise funding for grants for families of children with disabilities.

Subscribe to My Patreon Account


"Are you REALLY as stupid as you sound?"

Wife Prayed Instead of Reporting Husband’s ..."
"I remember seeing what was, I guess, the original documentary. I'm not a psychiatric nurse, ..."

Girl from “Born Schizophrenic” Off All ..."
"Is is possible, that him doing the courses, shed light on what was not working ..."

How The Landmark Forum Destroyed My ..."
"Definition of a cult: 1: a system of religious veneration and devotion directed toward a ..."

How The Landmark Forum Destroyed My ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Stacey H

    Candace may love her son, but she loves her ignorance more.

  • Desertphile

    “Kidnapping.” LOL. Gosh, medical care and saving a person’s life is now “kidnapping.”

  • Desertphile

    Alas, I see no evidence she likes her son, let alone loves her son.

  • Jim Jones

    Well, she read something on Facebook so of course she knows better.

  • B.E. Miller

    I’m hoping NY takes better care of its foster kids than Texas. The Dallas Morning News has been running a series about the problems foster parents face when attempting to get necessary medical care for the kids in their care.

    Here’s something from the Statesman.

    I’m wondering if the Texas foster care system really wants these kids to die off. Perhaps they see these kids as a burden to the system….

  • I’m convinced Texas hates children

  • B.E. Miller

    Unless they’re the “right sort” of children, then Texas is all about “protecting” them.

  • persephone

    She cares about her position in the health and wellness community. That’s all. She doesn’t love her son. She, like so many of the other parents, especially mothers, reported on this blog, is not really a mother. Nicholas is a symbol. If he dies in the process of her treatments, then she can be the grieving mother and have one less burden on her life. She’ll be embraced by the community and live on their kindness for months.

  • persephone

    Once again, I think my hypothesis on these mothers who don’t want to be mothers is getting more substantial support.

  • Chamber

    She probably heard about it from Jenny Not A Doctor Mcarthy. Someone needs to sew Jen Jen’s lips together.

  • Adrian

    A stray thought, couldn’t one of her jade eggs be added to to the procedure to gag her more more efficiently? That would make the damn things actually useful… 😛

  • Chamber

    You’re absolutely correct. That would be better.

  • “Apparently, Nicholas is upset about being in the hospital.”

    Well, yeah. Nobody really enjoys being in hospital.

    “He believes that because he doesn’t have cancer, he doesn’t need more treatment.”

    According to who, his mum, or trained oncologists? Because, you know, one’s an untrained woo-head, the others have been through nearly a decade of extra schooling, I know who I’m going to trust.

    “However, at age 13, Nicholas is unable to understand the severity of his diagnosis.”

    That’s not necessarily due to his age. He’s been effectively brainwashed by his mum into believing he doesn’t have cancer. Get him some counseling. Once his head’s on right, he should be able to understand at least the concept of “this disease is killing you, and we’re trying to keep that from happening.” Until that happens, the state has every right to step in and make sure he’s getting the medical care that he’s entitled to, because his mum clearly has gone off the rails.

  • Some “love”.

  • I think you’re on to something.