The Deadly Belief that Cervical Cancer Screenings Are Unnecessary

The Deadly Belief that Cervical Cancer Screenings Are Unnecessary December 21, 2018
Shutterstock

Every two hours a woman dies from cervical cancer in the United States. An estimated 13,000 women are diagnosed with the disease each year. 33% of women diagnosed with the disease will not live beyond five years. Routine screening for cervical cancer, via pap smears, has decreased the prevalence of the disease by 50% since 1974. However, there are women around the country that believe pap smears are not needed, spreading their message, and putting others lives at risk.

The internet is filled with articles, blogs, and forums dedicated to slamming cervical cancer screening. Women argue that they are coerced, bullied, and forced into the exam by providers.

A blogger noted in her diatribe against pap smears that women report feeling “assaulted” as a result of the exam.

“Women are avoiding seeking medical advice for other issues, because they are scared of being coerced into having a smear. This is widespread. Who knows how many women develop and die from other cancers due to delayed medical advice? If you think I am being dramatic, take a simple google search into female message boards to see how terrified some women are.

Given that 1 in 4 women are survivors of sexual abuse, assault or rape, all medical investigations should be trauma-led. There are women who report being or feeling assaulted during the examination. This then puts them off seeking medical help for other issues. There must be more efficient, less invasive ways to test such as urine testing.”

If patients have a history of sexual abuse or assault, having an open conversation about their fears with their providers can help providers determine how best to approach the exam. While trauma from sexual assault is real, a caring provider will help a patient navigate them through the exam with compassion, kindness, and minimal trauma.

Pap smears, completed in clinics, are relatively painless and take minutes to perform. A doctor places a speculum inside the vagina. The speculum holds open the vaginal walls so the doctor can scrape cells from the cervix.

Once complete, the cells collected are sent to a lab to study the cells. If the cells obtained are abnormal, doctors can perform additional tests. By detecting abnormal cells, doctors can take steps to prevent the cells from developing into cancer.

Since the Pap smear was implemented in 1974, the prevalence of cervical cancer in women has dropped by 50%. Exams help by identifying cancer that is in very early stages. When cancer is detected in the cervix in an early stage, the five-year survival rate for cervical cancer is 92%.

Overall, the testing has helped fewer women develop cancer and has reduced deaths associated with cervical cancer.

However, there continues to be misleading information online that pap smears are not necessary. Recently in a Facebook group, a woman asked if cervical exams are required. One woman responded with the following:

The woman responding told the poster that “most cases of cervical cancer clear up on their own.” Additionally, she reminded the woman that the HPV vaccine is a fraud and mammograms cause breast cancer.

Unfortunately, the woman received potentially deadly advice from the group. While there is a truth that some abnormal cells do clear up on their own, not all cells will clear by themselves. The virus that causes cervical cancer, human papillomavirus (HPV), has many different strains and types.

Milder or moderate abnormal cells associated with HPV may clear on their own. However, there are two strains of HPV, HPV-16, and HPV-18, that cause 70% of all cervical cancer incidents in women. Individuals with these strains of the virus are most at risk when their body does not naturally clear the cells on their own.

““High-risk” HPVs are types of genital HPV that are more likely to cause cancer. For most people, the immune system is able to get rid of this type of infection. However, some people develop a lasting infection. Over the course of many years, the infection transforms normal cells into precancerous lesions or cancer.”

Without regular screening of the cervix, doctors are not able to monitor for the development of abnormal cells. While cancer can take years to develop, testing and removal of the cells improve the patient’s long-term survival.

Since most of us don’t have “gut instinct” about whether abnormal cells are growing inside us, screening removes any doubt we may be feeling. Additionally, when someone tells you that screening can cause “mutations,” that is just pseudoscience fearmongering.

Women in natural and alternative lifestyle groups are at risk of listening to the echo chamber spread false information about modern medical techniques. A Pap Smear is a minimally invasive test that takes less than five minutes. Due to fact that abnormal cells grow slowly on the cervix, screening is only necessary every three years.

A screen completed once every three years, can be the difference between life and death for many women. Cervical cancer is most deadly when it has gone undetected for years and spread. When dedicated in later stages, 33% of women will not survive more than five years.

In addition to a pap smear, HPV vaccinations can help prevent the spread of HPV through sexual intercourse. Additionally, the HPV vaccine helps prevent women from contracting the two strains of HPV that cause cancer. While the vaccines were only previously available to women under 25 years old, the FDA expanded the vaccine to include women under 45 years old.

Despite anti-vaccine propaganda that the HPV vaccine causes a host of injuries and death, there is is no scientific data to support their claims.

Always consult your primary physician regarding questions on safety, effectiveness, and reasons for having regular pap smears. While the internet can be a wealth of information for most, there are groups and articles that continue to spread false information.

Cervical cancer screenings save lives.

Please make sure you are current today!

 

Follow me on Facebook

Talk to Me on Twitter

Follow me on Flipboard

Follow my Boards on Pinterest

On Instagram

If you enjoy my articles, please consider a one time gift via my Buy Me a Coffee Account. I work hard to provide insightful content every day for you to enjoy.

Buy me a coffee Buy me a coffee

Or

Subscribe and commit to a small monthly donation to support my writing. Patrons receive access to individual messages from me, inside information, and a community to talk with other like-minded people.

Subscribe to My Patreon Account

 

 

 

"I've never checked out these videos before, but 30 seconds of Tati's botoxed and filled ..."

Should Fans Trust Tati Westbrook After ..."
"judjes have to be judje when they fail.. police has to be fired when they ..."

Autistic Boy Dies After School Forcibly ..."
"Da​mn, da​mn, da​mn!. Now I have to take back that bridesmaid dress and see if ..."

Waiter who Accused James Charles of ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


TRENDING AT PATHEOS Nonreligious
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • kilda

    people avoiding gyn exams because of a history of sexual trauma is a real problem, and probably much more widespread than doctors realize. People who have been traumatized through assault or abuse can be legitimately terrified to let doctors do that type of exam. I have a friend who avoids the dentist for the same reason – it’s very triggering for her.
    The solution to this is for doctors to be aware and sensitive about the issue and for them to build trusting relationships with patients and talk about what will make the exam less scary. Some people may need anti-anxiety medication to get through it, much the same way some people use it to deal with flying. The solution is definitely not to scare people away from medical care more. Oh, and of course HPV vaccination will go a long way to reducing patient risk as well.

  • Yes, open communication between providers and patients is critical. I am a rape survivor and I have never once thought about a pap smear in conjunction with my rape. But that’s just me

  • Eli

    Yeah, even without trauma, I still find the exams scary and uncomfortable and, yes, painful. The first time I had it, I cried so much afterwards, it felt so violating, nice as my doctor is, and another time, I hyperventilated. I do still go despite all that because it is important, but a lot of people seem to not really understand that just talking about it casually doesn’t make it a casual, mundane exam for some of us, and some understanding of that goes a long way to helping.

  • Braitty

    I watched my mom go thru chemo/radiation(including *Brachytherapy aka internal radiation*) for cervical cancer at age 10-ish. The moment the HPV vaccine was available, I was bugging my parents to take me to the doctor’s; even though my arm swelled up like a orange, I would rather deal with that then cancer.

  • Jim Jones

    Australia could become first country to eradicate cervical cancer | Society | The Guardian

    Has the program been successful?

    Almost all Australian schools have chosen to participate in the National HPV Vaccination Program.

    Over 9 million doses of the vaccine have been given to girls and young women in Australia.

    Research studies have shown early signs of the vaccine’s success including:

    • a 77% reduction in HPV types responsible for almost 75% of cervical cancer
    • almost 50% reduction in the incidence of high-grade cervical abnormalities in Victorian girls under 18 years of age
    • a 90% reduction in genital warts in heterosexual men and women under 21 years of age.

    As cervical cancer usually develops over 10 or more years, the role of the vaccine in reducing cervical cancer will not be evident for some time.

    https://www.theguardian.com/society/2018/mar/04/australia-could-become-first-country-to-eradicate-cervical-cancer

  • tatortotcassie

    I’ve had it with all these fearmongering anti-science, anti-evidence bullshitters! Vaccines are bad, black salve is good, Pap smears are bad, Jilly Juice is good. FFS. Is there any way to spin some propaganda for these people that would convince them that the actual bad things (polio, cancer) are bad?