Baby Contracts Life-Threatening Infections After Mother Eats Placenta

Baby Contracts Life-Threatening Infections After Mother Eats Placenta April 16, 2019

An Oregon mother consumed encapsulated placenta and infected her newborn baby multiple times with Group B Strep. A Notes from the Field case study about the woman appeared on the Centers for Disease Control website in 2017. Despite the warning two years ago about consuming encapsulated placentas, companies still offer the products and women still consume their placenta.

In Notes from the Field Study, the authors outlined a case of a mother that infected her newborn twice with Group B Strep. According to the report, the mother gave birth in September 2016. A routine vaginal exam of the mother at 37 weeks was negative for Group B Strep.

Despite her negative swab for GBS, the baby began to show signs of respiratory distress after their birth. Doctors transferred the baby to the neonatal intensive care unit with a tentative sepsis diagnosis. A culture taken from the blood of the infant provided a positive result for penicillin-sensitive, clindamycin-intermediate GBS.

When doctors learned of the GBS culture, they started the infant on antibiotics. After an eleven day treatment of antibiotics, doctors discharged the infant home.

Only three days later, the mother brought the infant to an emergency department at another hospital for irritability. Doctors admitted the infant into the hospital. Again, a blood culture revealed a positive result for penicillin-sensitive, clindamycin-intermediate GBS.

A hospital lab tested the infant’s cerebral spinal fluid, and the mother’s expressed breast milk, and both were negative for GBS. Without a source for the secondary infection, doctors started to search for other options.

After three days in the second hospital, a physician from the birth hospital contacted the second hospital to share information that might help them. The physician at the birth hospital said the mother requested her placenta after her birth. She told doctors that she planned to encapsulate the placenta.

Learning the new information, the physicians from the second hospital spoke with the mother. She confirmed that she hired a company to encapsulate her placenta.

Additionally, she admitted that she was taking two capsules of the placenta three times a day. The mother said she began taking the placenta capsules three days after the birth of her child.

Immediately, doctors instructed the mother to stop consuming the placenta capsules. Then the doctors took a sample of the pills to the lab for testing. As expected, the placenta capsules tested positive for GBS.

For the second GBS infection, the baby needed several rounds of antibiotics to kill the bacteria. After fourteen days of multiple antibiotics, doctors discharged the baby home.

An analysis of the cultures from the baby’s blood and the placenta capsules revealed the same GBS infection. The infections had the same profile and same sequence. Due to the similarities, doctors determined the baby contracted the GBS from the mother. She passed the bacteria to her baby by consuming the GBS infected placenta capsules.

After the CDC published the study in 2017, they advised against the consumption of placenta capsules. The CDC warned that there is no standard for processing placentas for eating.

While many companies heat the placenta to 130 Fahrenheit and cook for 121 minutes, the heat is not high enough to kill strep infections. The temperature of 130 degrees can kill Salmonella.

Because several bacteria infections are not killed by heating, the CDC warned women that consuming encapsulated placenta is dangerous. Additionally, the CDC instructed doctors to inform women about the risks associated with placenta consumption.

Women that consume the placenta believe that the placenta contains hormones and vitamins to assist in their post-partum recovery. However, a study published in the American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology debunked the theories pushed by companies that process placentas.

Companies and midwives that promote placenta encapsulation say that the capsules contain progesterone and estrogen. Additionally, they believe the capsules also contain high levels of iron and B12. However, the study by AJOG indicated that no traceable amounts of vitamins or hormones remain in the placenta after encapsulation.

Due to the finding by the AJOG, many women now will eat the placenta raw or cook the placenta and drink in a smoothie. Both means of consuming the placenta are dangerous. The raw placenta will expose the mother to a host of bacterial infections that can transfer to the infant.

The baby in the CDC case spent nearly a month in the hospital because of their mother’s false belief about placenta consumption. GBS infections in babies can be fatal. Even though her baby developed a GBS infection after birth, the mother continued to consume the placenta.

To date, there is absolutely no scientific evidence that supports the claims that placenta consumption will improve hormone and vitamin levels in women. What is known is that eating the placenta can transfer infections from the mother to the baby. Additionally, there is the ick factor of consuming a waste product of the infant.

No culture in the world has ever eaten the placenta following birth. The popular trend appears to be another woo-filled experiment by the crunchy community to use “natural” remedies to treat medical conditions.

A better bet for women is to work with their doctors after their birth. Doctors can prescribe iron, multi-vitamins, and anti-depressants if needed. Postpartum depression should not be treated with placenta consumption. In fact, eating the placenta could prevent the mother from receiving help from a doctor to manage her symptoms.

While there is no information about the baby today, I genuinely hope the hospital reported the mother to child protective services. She could use a class or 400 on parenting.

 

*Katie Joy is a columnist and hosts Without A Crystal Ball on Patheos Non-Religious Channel. She writes articles on parenting, disability advocacy, debunking pseudoscience, atheism, and crimes against women and children.

She co-hosts the YouTube show, “The Smoking Nun,” with Kyle Curtis on The Non-Sequitur Channel. The show airs weekly and tackles pseudoscience, current events, and crime stories.

Communicate with Katie on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, and Pinterest.

Merchandise available at Teespring.

Buy Katie Joy a cup of Coffee. 

Buy Me a Coffee at ko-fi.com

Individuals wishing to help Katie with her expenses can become patrons. Patrons gain exclusive access to stories, new projects, and future books.

 

 

"Not gonna happen. The GoFundMe is headed "Medical Freedom for Noah" and EMERGENCY FUND, SAVE ..."

Judge Orders Florida Boy to Complete ..."
"Several well-documented side effects of chemo and radiation mean that the treatment is working.Hair falls ..."

Judge Orders Florida Boy to Complete ..."
"Here’s a great way to stop the spread of diseases! Tell those same parents that ..."

Anti-Vax Facebook Group Threatens to Overthrow ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


TRENDING AT PATHEOS Nonreligious
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • nmgirl

    As I’ve said for years: doG must really like stupid people cuz he made so many of them!

  • Artor

    I’m missing something here. The problem seems to be with improper food preparation. Why is the article harping against the placenta specifically? I don’t see how a placenta is any more prone to harboring pathogens than pork or venison. Yes, there is no regulation of placentae to be consumed as food, but that seems like an FDA oversight rather than anything inherent to the specific source of protein.

  • andrea

    Some people who eat placenta aren’t even eating only THEIR placenta because the encapsulation specialists are prepping a whole bunch of placentae together and cross-contaminating.

  • Tawreos

    The body ejects things for a reason so trying to put them back into the body , one way or another, is not a wise idea.

  • Jennny

    Eating the placenta became fashionable in the UK as part of the natural childbirth movement…because all animals do it, we should too. There was also the lotus thing, leaving the placenta attached and letting it decay as you carried it round in a bag….I can only think of the smell and the hygiene, attached to a delicate newborn!

  • Raging Bee

    “All animals?” Really?

    I also heard something about some Native American or other non-tech tribes eating placentas. Or was that just a legend promoted by “naturalist” woo-mongers?

  • Raging Bee

    Additionally, there is the ick factor of consuming a waste product of the infant.

    What, specifically, is in a placenta at the time of birth? I heard eating one’s placenta after giving birth was recommended because it contained some of the nutrients used to support the baby inside the womb, so recycling those concentrated nutrients would be good for the mother. But if it’s an interface between the mother’s and baby’s bodies, it might also contain output from the baby as well as input. So…what’s REALLY in a placenta?

  • The Bofa on the Sofa

    My thought on reading this article was, hey, at least the company actually encapsulated HER placenta.

    I mean, as is noted,

    The CDC warned that there is no standard for processing placentas for eating.

    As far as anyone knows, the capsules contain sawdust.

    I have said it many times, it is unfortunate I have ethics, because it would be SO easy to scam people with this. If you want to make it look better, just go to the butcher and get the cheapest organ meat you can. Dry it, shred it, put it in a pill capsule and sell it for stupid amounts of markup.

    Who would know the difference?

  • The Bofa on the Sofa

    The reason animals do it is to remove all traces of blood. It’s not a safe thing to do, to leave decaying meat laying around attracting predators when you have defenseless babies.

  • andrea

    Yea, you wouldn’t know. Ew.

  • Ding ding ding!

  • persephone

    Nothing useful. It’s just the crunchy, earth mother BS. A lot of cultures bury the placenta, some of them under a tree, considering it part of the magical process, but I think first world goopers are the only ones stupid enough to ingest a waste product.

  • persephone

    The placenta allows blood to pass, and with that blood can come diseases. It’s a waste product, of no nutritional value, and can be full of all types of germs.

    Then they’re shipped off to companies that are mixing them up altogether, so a healthy woman’s placenta is getting ground up with a placenta that could contain any number of infectious organisms, then they’re heated up enough to dry them out and kill certain microbes, but not hot enough to kill disease organisms.

    1. The mother isn’t getting her placenta back.
    2. The placenta is prepared in a manner that results in the worst possible outcome.
    3. It’s a waste product that should be tossed out as medical waste and incinerated.

  • firebubbles310

    Gods. I read about lotus birth existence on xojane years ago and knew that I didn’t want to google to find out what it was. Years later I now know I was completely correct. I am going to go drink and hopefully forget.

    I get that there are issues with modern medicine but these new trendy actions can cause so much suffering. There are better ways to spend first days as a mother. Ugh.

  • Banrion

    This is what I was wondering. If the mother was GBS negative, where did the GBS in the placenta come from?

  • Banrion

    For it to be improper food preparation the placenta would need to be considered a food substance, rather than what it is, biological waste. Making safe food-handling regulations for placenta is impossible because placenta is not a safe food to eat. The FDA doesn’t regulate roadkill as meat, either, for the same reasons.

  • Raging Bee

    So they’re embracing diversity!

  • AnonCar

    Animals (species dependent granted) will also lick their babies’ behinds to stimulate waste production and also eat their babies’ waste to keep the nest area clean. I don’t see any of these placenta-eating advocates suggesting doing that though.

  • AnonCar

    Pork and venison have not been shown to transmit pathogens such as Group B Strep, HIV, Zika, etc that cannot be killed via standard food sanitation/preparation processes. Placentae can contain and transmit those pathogens. Those pathogens cannot be cooked out of a placenta in the same way that salmonella, E Coli, or lysteria can be cooked out of actual food.

  • LA Julian

    They eat the ones that die of SIDS or the whole litter if they’re stressed/threatened, too. Maternal Cannibalism – it’s natural!