Jaclyn Hill’s lipstick saga got worse after YouTuber Pretty Pastel Please found metal and plastic in newly opened lipstick. Last week Hill denied that her lipsticks were contaminated or moldy despite numerous photos appearing on social media contradicting her statements.
In a video uploaded yesterday by Pretty Pastel Please, channel host Alex opened lipsticks she purchased from Jaclyn Hill. Last week Hill reported that less than 1% of her lipsticks appeared contaminated. However, Alex found many problematic lipsticks in the full collection she purchased.
During the video, Alex sat at a white table, fully clothed in a lab suit. As she opened each lipstick, she noted hairs, spots, fibers, and objects underneath the surface. After opening each lipstick, Alex began swatching the lipsticks on paper.
While swatching several shades of lipstick, Alex found fragments of metal, plastic, black hair, and white fibers. The foreign contaminants were not limited to only the top of the lipstick. In a video last week, Hill said hairs found on the lipstick were from gloves worn by workers. She insisted the fibers dropped from the gloves onto the top of the lipstick and stated her lipsticks were safe to use.
However, Pretty Pastel Please found the lipsticks littered with debris from top to bottom. In more than one lipstick, she found metal objects that stuck to a magnet.
Additionally, Alex pulled out black, curly hairs from many lipsticks.
In one lipstick, the YouTuber found a hard piece of plastic.
After Alex completed swatching the lipsticks, she found issues in nearly every single lipstick. The finding by the YouTuber puts into question statements made by Jaclyn Hill that less than 1% of consumers were dealing with contaminated products.
In her video, Jaclyn Hill insisted her products were safe to use. She denied the lipsticks contained mold. Additionally, she offered to replace and refund unhappy consumers.
On Twitter, frustrated customers demanded Jaclyn Hill recall her products. Others shared a petition through Change.org demanding that the FDA recall the contaminated lipstick. The petition that was started more than a week ago has over 24,000 signatures. Several individuals commented on the petition that they became sick after using the lipstick.
Despite the pressure by customers to recall the products, Jaclyn Hill Cosmetics continues with business as usual. The company has been busy processing refunds, responding to emails, and navigating the thousands of unhappy customers.
Over on YouTube, multiple channels have promised to send their lipsticks to labs for microbial testing. Because testing can take weeks to perform, results will not be arriving any time soon.
Despite demands for a recall of the product to the FDA, the FDA cannot enforce a recall of contaminated lipsticks. The FDA does not regulate cosmetics and therefore, cosmetic recalls are voluntary by the companies.
With no legal oversight preventing her from removing the products, Jaclyn Hill remains committed to keeping her contaminated and potentially dangerous lipsticks on the market.
Watch Pretty Pastel Please’s full video:
*Katie Joy is a columnist and hosts Without A Crystal Ball on Patheos Non-Religious Channel. She writes articles on parenting, disability advocacy, debunking pseudoscience, atheism, and crimes against women and children.
She co-hosts the YouTube show, “The Smoking Nun,” with Kyle Curtis on The Non-Sequitur Channel. The show airs weekly and tackles pseudoscience, current events, and crime stories.
Communicate with Katie on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, and Pinterest.
Merchandise available at Teespring.
Buy Katie Joy a cup of Coffee.
Individuals wishing to help Katie with her expenses can become patrons. Patrons gain exclusive access to stories, new projects, and future books.