Ernesto Cardenal and Eliot’s Two Fingers

Ernesto Cardenal and Eliot’s Two Fingers April 27, 2016

800px-Ernesto_Cardenal_a_la_Chascona_2

Ernesto Cardenal reads his poems in La Chascona (Santiago, Chile)Roman Bonnefoy – GNU Free Documentation License 

 

To quote Eliot “against” Tradition, I feel justified borrowing from the supreme borrow himself. Eliot, the Old Possum, the scribbler of “Tradition and Individual Talent” and “Rhetoric and Poetic Drama” – the definitive binary summations of Modernist meditations on “tradition”/tradition/Tradition – points in two directions at once, always.

One finger points this way: Revolutionaries(!): consider the past, not necessarily more systematically, but more comprehensively. Not everything new is good. Eliot parodies the professorial tics of the time in his prose, always a muffled laughter somewhere in his learnedness (“I, therefore, invite you to consider…”). Always an ironic boho posturing to his elucidations – irony being the grease that kept his wheels spinning:

“There remains to define this process of depersonalization and its relation to the sense of tradition. It is in this depersonalization that art may be said to approach the condition of science. I, therefore, invite you to consider, as a suggestive analogy, the action which takes place when a bit of finely filiated platinum is introduced into a chamber containing oxygen and sulphur dioxide.”

Alright then. Typically “conservative” Eliot. Chum casually tossed out to The Egoist crowd. But then this:

“All the ideas, beliefs, modes of feeling and behavior which we have no time or inclination to investigate for ourselves we take second-hand and sometimes call tradition.”

And not only that, but (of course) an appended footnote:

“For an authoritative condemnation of theories attaching supreme importance to tradition as a criterion of truth, see Pope Gregory XVI’s encyclical Singulari nos (July 15, 1834), and the Vatican Council canon of 1870, Si quis dixeritanathema sit.”

That’s the Eliot I love. The one that quotes the Pope “against” Tradition, pressing home the point that Tradition is often misinterpreted to mean an untouched bindle. A vault. Miss Havisham’s festering homestead.

Nope, says Eliot. It’s not the untouched things. It’s the things that we take the time to reexamine scrupulously. “Tradition…cannot be inherited, and if you want it you must obtain it by great labour.”

You must obtain it. And it aint easy. That’s the direction Eliot’s second finger points in. Reclamation.

Eliot writes of having an eye towards a “simultaneous existence” with the past and future. A palimpsest of consciousness bleeding through time like a water mark. “The past is altered by the present as much as the present is altered by the past.”

It’s not just literature. It’s science:  “An experiment by Australian scientists has proven that what happens to particles in the past is only decided when they are observed and measured in the future. Until such time, reality is just an abstraction.”

I, therefore, invite you to consider the role this conception of tradition, time, and causality has on the anti-colonial poetry of Ernesto Cardenal. How his poems about the past, specifically With Walker in Nicaragua, are meant simultaneously as reclamation of the past and an alteration of the past through an observation located in the present:

And those flames spread like wildfire in the street from the lake.

And Henningsen’s message was:

“Your order has been obeyed, sir:

Granada is no more.”

More on Cardenal to follow, hopefully sooner than later.

 

 

 

"I don't think these are necessarily incompatible ideas of "freedom" as such: surely both are ..."

Ockham Makes “Freedom” A Synonym Of ..."
"“[O]ur freedom is exercised not only in our will, but in our intellect, ourimagination, our ..."

Ockham Makes “Freedom” A Synonym Of ..."
"Excellent analysis. We are so used to equating "freedom" with "free will" that we fail ..."

Ockham Makes “Freedom” A Synonym Of ..."
"There's nothing controversial about that claim!"

FJ: “Cold Irons Bound” – Bob ..."

Browse Our Archives

TRENDING AT PATHEOS Catholic
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment