à tout à l’heure, Shane

For those of you who have followed along this last week, Shane and I have volleyed back and forth 7.5 times in a vigorous, rigorous, and somewhat wide-ranging debate primarily aimed at establishing whether or not religious faith constitutes an illicit appeal to arbitrary authority and whether religions, therefore, can be denounced on epistemological grounds for cultivating bad habits of thought in people.  I said yes to these positions and Shane said no.

Shane is putting the debate on hiatus for the time being to return to his summer research with less distraction.  Hopefully, he will be back later in the summer or fall to pick up where we left off and go some more rounds.  In the meantime, I encourage you to catch up on any of the debate you may have missed and to utilize the comments sections to chime in yourselves on any of the threads of discussion.

Check tomorrow at 3pm for my response to a couple of remarks that Chris has made along the way.  That post will further lay out some of my fundamental qualms with believing on faith.  And some day, I will address comments from Evangelos and Dave which deserve their own separate blog posts.

Thanks again to everyone who reads and especially to everyone who contributes!

Objections to Religious Moderates and Intellecuals 1

Objections to Religious Moderates and Intellectuals 2

Objections to Religious Moderates and Intellectuals 3

Objections to Religious Moderates and Intellectuals 4

On Teleology and Intellectual Virtues and Vices (5)

How Faith Is Not Like Other (Revisable) Reflexive Assumptions (6)

Against Faith and In Defense of Naturalism and Induction (7)

Shane’s Last Word

And from outside of Camels With Hammers, on Facebook, Shane offers this extra retort:

Hey Dan, the 19th Century called, they want their epistemology back

"The "good and faithful" stuck out to me too, though actually Snoke called him "my ..."

Religion and Philosophy in The Last ..."
"Congrats, dear! I'm so glad you both found each other."

Our Wedding Video
"Wonderful. But as an atheist, non-religious, why marriage? There must be a column in that."

Our Wedding Video
"On October 29, 2016 I married my wife, Lex.Yup, she definetly looks better with hair. ..."

Our Wedding Video

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment