Women’s Ordination: Another Route To Automatic Excommunication

Not only does approving an abortion necessary to save a woman’s life in a case where her fetus would die in either case get you automatically excommunicated from the Roman Catholic Church, but so does seeking ordination while being female.  Lifelong Catholic Janine Denomme this week was denied a Roman Catholic burial for having the audacity to seek ordination into the priesthood:

Last month, Janine was ordained in a simulation, according to the Archdiocese, which carries an automatic penalty.

“Any woman who seeks ordination incurs excommunication,” said Fr. Daniel Smilanic.

Archdiocese Canon lawyer Smilanic said the Cardinal had no choice. Janine knew that when she took her vows a month before she died.

Her longtime partner, Nancy Katz, said that Janine was also aware that she risked being denied a formal church funeral.

“I don’t think she believed the church would lack a pastoral sensibility,” said Katz. “And what she said to me as we talked about her funeral wishes, ‘I can’t imagine having my funeral anywhere but my parish.’ And yet she knew that there was a risk involved with heeding her call for ordination.”
“We have to understand what the theology is,” Smilanic said. “The Holy See has said that if people do this, they are automatically excommunicated. And the excommunication is reserved to the Holy See.”

Translation: orders from Rome. Instant excommunication. Decreed by the same authority which takes years to excommunicate priests who abuse children.

However unjustly sexist and misogynistic the policy against women’s ordination is, one does understand an organization’s right to enforce its policies with penalties and to make clear distinctions as to who its acknowledged authority figures are and are not.  But automatic excommunication for acts of conscientious protest?  That’s pure authoritarianism of thought and practice.  This would be the equivalent, in my mind, of a nation that denied citizenship to anyone who committed an act of civil disobedience (all the while letting criminals such as, say, pedophiles, get off free).  Signs of an institution guided by a Holy Spirit?  Nope, not at all.  It is evidence quite to the contrary.  It is frustrating that people whose lives the Church has no genuine interest in understanding or helping to flourish still clamor for her favor and die desperate for it.  It is like a religious Stockholm Syndrome.

Thanks to my friend and colleague Tim Czech and condolences to his mom, who was a friend of Janine.

Your Thoughts?

"I applaud your approach and recommend, if you like, “Rogerian Argument” which does - as ..."

Making Arguments Less Tediously Repetitive, Contentious, ..."
"Perhaps this idea's time has come. I like your logical and convincing presentation. I have ..."

Making Arguments Less Tediously Repetitive, Contentious, ..."
"Yes! We need methods to help us have conversations with people we disagree with. Since ..."

Making Arguments Less Tediously Repetitive, Contentious, ..."
"Snoke is not well developed because he does not need to be. We already know ..."

Religion and Philosophy in The Last ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment