Apparently in France the legal concept of defamation treats attacks on honor as a form of assault. Karin N. Calvo-Goller, an Israeli author, is taking a German book reviewer to court in France over a four paragraph long negative review on Global Law Books, a New York Web site associated with The European Journal of International Law. The crime committed in the review? “Harming her reputation”:
The reviewer, Thomas Weigend, a law professor at the University of Cologne, adopted a measured and patiently condescending tone. He said the book “meticulously covers all relevant topics,” and he praised its occasional “analytical nuggets.” But he faulted the book for “rehashing the existing legal set-up” and questioned Ms. Calvo-Goller’s “conceptual grasp” of some matters.
Ms. Calvo-Goller responded by demanding that the review be deleted.
“I am aware of the extent of freedom of expression under the First Amendment,” she wrote to the site’s editor, Joseph Weiler, a law professor at New York University. “However, the extent of that freedom ends where its exercise damages the reputation of an individual.”
Brian Leiter aptly noted the obvious:
The author has obviously done more damage to her reputation by making this criminal complaint than would have been possible by any book review, let alone the one in question
Your Thoughts (as long as I deem them not damaging to my reputation, of course)?