Is Religious Circumcision of Male Infants Morally Defensible?

Last month a court in Cologne, Germany ruled against allowing the circumcision of children too young to give consent. CBS News summarized the facts:

a German court ruled that circumcision infringes on a child’s right to be protected from bodily harm.

The regional court in Cologne said that circumcision went against the “fundamental right of the child to bodily integrity outweighed the fundamental rights of the parents.” They added that religious freedom would not be curtailed because the child would be able to choose later whether he wanted to have a circumcision. However, if the parents decided for the boy, it changed the body of the child “irreparably and permanently” and went against that child’s rights to choose his religious beliefs.

“The religious freedom of the parents and their right to educate their child would not be unacceptably compromised, if they were obliged to wait until the child could himself decide to be circumcised,” the court added.

The ruling has now set a precedent that anyone in the future who performs a circumcision on a child not old enough to consent could potentially be breaking the law.

The YouTube description of the video above introduces the dialogue participants and background materials:

Ari Kohen is Schlesinger Associate Professor of Political Science and Director of the Human Rights and Humanitarian Affairs Program at the University of Nebraska. Brian D. Earp is a Research Associate at the Uehiro Centre for Practical Ethics, University of Oxford. In this clip, they debate the ethics of religiously motivated circumcision.

Here is Ari’s academic page: http://polisci.unl.edu/dr-ari-kohen
Here is Brian’s academic page: http://oxford.academia.edu/BrianEarp/About

Here are their duelling blog posts.

Brian’s at Practical Ethics:
http://blog.practicalethics.ox.ac.uk/2012/06/religion-is-no-excuse-for-mutila…

Ari’s at Running Chicken:
http://kohenari.net/post/26421082181/germany-circumcision

Andrew Sullivan also weighed in in favor of the court’s ruling.

Your Thoughts?

"Getting out of religion and back into nature is incredibly difficult. Cult-ural Science, cult-ural religion, ..."

Have I Considered Catholicism Sufficiently?
"Following on from my last past here - As pervasive as the term original sin ..."

Have I Considered Catholicism Sufficiently?

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment