As far as I am concerned the vast majority of blogs I read, whether they realize it or not, are values blogs. And this is because values are an inescapable and fundamental part of life. Most of the political, social, and personal questions that concern us daily are unintelligible apart from their values dimensions. If I am right, judgments about values cannot even be rooted out of science, and is especially relevant to what we do with what we learn from science.
Conservatives like to claim a lock on values. They often preposterously charge that those who want to question and revise received values are against values entirely. Some even argue that values cannot be reasoned about at all. They think both fundamental values and particular value judgments must be simply accepted as dictates from a supernatural source with no input from human beings. Others, from across the whole political, philosophical, and theological spectrum, claim that values are just a matter of arbitrary emotionalism.
Libby Anne of Love Joy Feminism and I want to counter these impressions. We want to showcase explicitly how forward thinking people reason about values and spur discussions of under-examined values questions that have real world ramifications. Twice monthly we are going to raise a question for our commenters and our fellow bloggers. Then two weeks later we will round up our favorites from our commenters’ remarks and provide links to the bloggers that participated constructively, with representative excerpts of their posts. We want these to be collaborative conversations that explore the complexities of problems and the diversity of insightful, rational approaches that can be brought to bear for solving them.
We need your help, commenters and fellow bloggers. Or, to put it the other way around, we are willing to help you get your thoughts heard on important values questions that you care about! If you participate in our project and write a post, be sure to e-mail your link to the blogger who posted it. My e-mail is camelswithhammers (at) gmail (dot) com. Libby Anne’s is lovejoyfeminism (at) gmail (dot) com. Look for new questions and responses to old questions on the first and third Mondays of each month. A week ago, Libby Anne kicked us off. Here’s her first prompt:
Our first prompt involves an issue that is, I think, too often left undiscussed. It is my suspicion that differing ideas about the nature of civic responsibility and what all it includes often underlie political differences in ways we do not always recognize. I believe that we as forward thinkers would benefit from bringing this issue out of the shadows and discussing it directly and enthusiastically. And so, without further ado, I give you this month’s Forward Thinking discussion question:
What does civic responsibility mean to you?
Reply by Sunday to be sure you’re in her round up this coming Monday (1/21).
Your Thoughts? Your Blog Posts?