I can believe that you used to be an atheist. An atheist is simply someone without a god belief. It’s the “just like you” part that I’m having trouble with.

Lots of Christian apologists introduce themselves as former atheists. Lee Strobel, for example, often begins presentations with a summary of his decadent, angry atheist past. The implied message is that people like me convert to Christianity all the time. With the ongoing prayer experiment, I want to revisit this question and make a few changes.

Here is my original argument. First, consider three groups of people.

**Group 1.** Christians are here.

**Group 2.** The atheists need two groups. People in Group 2 are technically atheists because they don’t have a god belief, but they don’t know much about arguments in favor of Christianity, rebuttals to those arguments, or arguments in favor of atheism. Nothing wrong with that, of course—the God question doesn’t interest everyone—but they’re not well informed about atheism.

**Group 3.** These are the well-informed atheists. They understand both sides of the ontological, teleological, cosmological, transcendental, fine-tuning, and moral arguments and more. They are at least well-educated amateurs on evolution, evolution denial, and the Big Bang. They can make positive arguments for atheism, not just rebut Christian apologetics. And so on. I put myself into this group.

For each of these groups, how likely is it for people in these groups to be argued into the opposite camp?

**Group 1, Christians.** Lots of Christians have deconverted: Rich Lyons from the Living After Faith podcast. Matt Dillahunty of the Atheist Community of Austin. Dan Barker of the Freedom From Religion Foundation. Bob Price, the Bible Geek. Bart Ehrman, author of *Misquoting Jesus.* The hundreds of pastors in the Clergy Project.

They’re now all in Group 3, and they’re particularly interesting because they were very well informed Christians. Education turned them away from Christianity.

**Group 2, Uninformed Atheists.** Many in this group have converted to Christianity. This sounds like the group that the imagined former-atheist-now-Christian came from.

**Group 3, Well-Informed Atheists.** But here’s my point: I’ve never heard of anyone in Group 3, the well-informed atheists, who converted to Christianity because of intellectual arguments. Of course, this makes me vulnerable to the No True Scotsman fallacy—rejecting any counterexample with, “Oh, well that guy wasn’t *truly* a well-informed atheist”—but I invite you to comment with anyone I’ve omitted.

Well-informed Christians deconvert to atheism (and are happy to explain, using reason, why they left), but well-informed atheists don’t convert to Christianity through reason. More education about the history and origins of Christianity increases the likelihood that the Christian will deconvert, but more education increases the likelihood that the atheist will stay put.

This is an asymmetry that I don’t think apologists appreciate. Becoming a well-informed atheist is a one-way street. It’s a ratchet; it’s a gravity well. Once you become a well-informed atheist, you’re stuck. (What about conversion through *non-*intellectual reasons? Let’s set that aside for the moment.)

Here’s why I argue that no well-informed atheists convert to Christianity through intellectual arguments. By their fruit, you would recognize them.

Well-informed atheists, now Christians, wouldn’t make the arguments that apologists make. They wouldn’t make arguments to which I have a quick rebuttal. Indeed, they would focus on those arguments which they knew (since they’d been just like me) I had no response to.

These former atheists would know all the secret passwords and trap doors to get into my secret atheist lair, and, as Christians, they would walk back in and blow it up. *But we never see this.* Christians are still making the same old arguments, banging on the atheist stronghold with a rock hammer. I never see an “ex-atheist” who hits me where I live, who explains why my arguments are wrong from my perspective.

*Next time:* Let’s take a look at some prominent atheists who have become Christians. Do they disprove this argument?

*Of all tyrannies *

*a tyranny sincerely exercised for the good of its victims *

*may be the most oppressive. *

*It may be better to live under robber barons *

*than under omnipotent moral busybodies.*

*The robber baron’s cruelty may sometimes sleep …*

*but those who torment us for own good *

*will torment us without end, *

*for they do so with the approval of their own conscience.*

— C.S. Lewis

*(This is a modified version of a post originally published 10/5/11.)*

*Photo credit:* Wikimedia

Pingback: How Could an Atheist Convert to Christianity?

Pingback: You Shall Know Them By Their Fruits

Pingback: Google

Pingback: hefalimp cardijon

Pingback: dryer cleaning houston

Pingback: acheter cialis sans ordonnance

Pingback: cialis vrai

Pingback: cialis effet indesirable

Pingback: online slot games

Pingback: vente cialis

Pingback: visit site,

Pingback: music download

Pingback: divorce lawyer

Pingback: how to make ejaculation last longer

Pingback: commander cialis france

Pingback: macarons kopen belgie

Pingback: how do you make yourself last longer in bed

Pingback: payday loans

Pingback: cialis da 10 mg

Pingback: achat cialis

Pingback: zyrtec premature ejaculation

Pingback: buy friends google plus

Pingback: bitcoin casino

Pingback: cialis 30 mg

Pingback: buy youtube likes

Pingback: lawyer directory

Pingback: electronic cigarettes auckland

Pingback: achat cialis espagne

Pingback: Alex Begum personal injury attorney

Pingback: nujet tech

Pingback: Ultralase

Pingback: Optimax

Pingback: New Songs

Pingback: Driving School Torquay

Pingback: Orlando vacation rentals

Pingback: porn massage

Pingback: Slendera

Pingback: ροζ τηλέφωνα

Pingback: Penis enlargement

Pingback: cialis acquisto

Pingback: Sydney escorts

Pingback: Pension

Pingback: Telecharger les Sims 4

Pingback: cupboards

Pingback: kitchens

Pingback: kitchen cupboards

Pingback: kitchen cupboards

Pingback: Kids & Teens

Pingback: best wireless speakers

Pingback: Flight Tickets

Pingback: camilo concha

Pingback: Richard McArthur Real Estate

Pingback: Richard McArthur Realtor

Pingback: Richard McArthur Washington

Pingback: electric bike

Pingback: buy cheap likes

Pingback: distante rutiere

Pingback: K3vin Envoy

Pingback: Social Justice

Pingback: cialis pressione

Pingback: Viagra

Pingback: electric bikes

Pingback: download outlook.com

Pingback: garage doors san francisco

Pingback: edward maldonado

Pingback: insane value

Pingback: love online games dating

Pingback: salsa en malaga

Pingback: doc love online dating

Pingback: desensitizing creams for premature ejaculation reviews

Pingback: dbz nappa vegeta raditz in one box toys

Pingback: Mortgage company

Pingback: sex online

Pingback: Empower Network Scam

Pingback: Home Improvement

Pingback: Appliance Repair Albuquerque

Pingback: wordpress theme design company

Pingback: Bakersfield CPR

Pingback: bakersfield cpr

Pingback: Northern Virginia Dryer Vent Cleaning

Pingback: Anonymous

Pingback: mental training: the art of life or death decision making

Pingback: food

Pingback: Canada mortgages

Pingback: renta de autos en cancun

Pingback: forex robot

Pingback: Malian

Pingback: Productivity apps

Pingback: renta de autos en cancun

Pingback: Porno Filmes

Pingback: legal highs uk

Pingback: fish oil

Pingback: bladder cancer diabetes

Pingback: more info

Pingback: podiatry clinic

Pingback: puffy eyes

Pingback: cube world gameplay mods

Pingback: advertise property for sale

Pingback: podiatric medicine

Pingback: Viagra Pills

Pingback: machines sewing

Pingback: FSBO Seattle WA

Pingback: Tabitha Hoops

Pingback: online casino

Pingback: Payday loans

Pingback: daily tarot reading

Pingback: holistic

Pingback: payday loans

Pingback: diy crossfit equipment

Pingback: buy gold

Pingback: beauty and health

Pingback: anal

Pingback: Make Money

Pingback: Buy Fans

Pingback: bets10

Pingback: plan for college

Pingback: Bloomfield Twp

Pingback: Oakland County college planner

Pingback: appliance repair Manhattan

Pingback: cheap juicy couture

Pingback: Entertainment News

Pingback: get more

Pingback: vitamins for anxiety

Pingback: appliance repair Manhattan

Pingback: MovieStarPlanet Cheats Tool

Pingback: betting

Pingback: dive centre

Pingback: usa business directory

Pingback: Anonymous

Pingback: deer antler spray

Pingback: Games and softwares free download

Pingback: what is premature ejaculation yahoo

Pingback: modere

Pingback: appliance repair Glendale

Pingback: sex

Pingback: Baltasar sanchez haz

Pingback: notepad bluebox

Pingback: cracked seo tools

Pingback: m?s informaci?n

Pingback: buy hydrocodone

Pingback: buy adipex

Pingback: valium online

Pingback: carpet cleaners pretoria

Pingback: appliance repair company

Pingback: film izle

Pingback: blackhatprotools

Pingback: link m88

Pingback: buy ambien

Pingback: designers perth

Pingback: cheap viagra

Pingback: free sex

Pingback: web design perth australia

Pingback: best pay day loans

Pingback: Devvon Terrell Jason Derulo Marry Me Cover Is Breath Taking

Pingback: epub gratis

Pingback: tarot oraculo

Pingback: Bee Wild Pest Control

Pingback: teen chat app

Pingback: umbrella company

Pingback: cheap home insurance quotes

Pingback: dinner cruises

Pingback: compare auto insurance quotes by zip code

Pingback: Sydney Wedding Photography

Pingback: Compare property insurance

Pingback: bail bond orange county

Pingback: sunroom winchester

Pingback: Winchester sunroom

Pingback: free car insurance calculator

Pingback: nether hacks

Pingback: sunroom germantown

Pingback: free online slots games for fun

Pingback: Persewaan Mobil Elf surabaya

Pingback: buy tramadol

Pingback: buy soma

Pingback: germantown sunroom

Pingback: hydrocodone without prescription

Pingback: buy tramadol

Pingback: cialis

Pingback: bdoutdoors

Pingback: new york dinner cruise

Pingback: celebrity leaked photos

Pingback: college football

Pingback: sex

Pingback: divorce mediation

Pingback: locksmith Farmington Hills

Pingback: Criminal Lawyer Toronto

Pingback: Aspergers

Pingback: Cialis

Pingback: penis enlargement

Pingback: kundalini awakening experience

Pingback: Aspergers

Pingback: iphone 5c cases armor box

Pingback: banana blue

Pingback: musica

Pingback: witryna www

Pingback: ATH-M50.net/

Pingback: cerrajeros cartagena

Pingback: plan my trip

Pingback: arkitekter

Pingback: kansas city bbq

Pingback: netflix account

Pingback: Local Movers

Pingback: Best Rated Best Rated appliance repair Chicago

Pingback: gerald buchoff

Pingback: hecigarette review

Pingback: mortgage finance

Pingback: landscaper

Pingback: toshiba laptop akció

Pingback: lose weight fast

Pingback: Oregon Social Security Disability

Pingback: Wellness Dog Food Coupon

Pingback: salon semo

Pingback: blog sobre la alcachofa de laon

Pingback: criminal attorney

Pingback: salon semo

Pingback: hearthstone arena guide

Pingback: spalacze tluszczu

Pingback: kaski narciarskie

Pingback: grafik komputerowy

Pingback: gold maps

Pingback: what is hacking?

Pingback: Home improvement services

Pingback: commonwealth towers showflat location

Pingback: StrategyDB.com custom TradeStation consulting

Pingback: make money

Pingback: harga kasur busa

Pingback: scandal news

Pingback: garage flooring fort collins

Pingback: Street Jumpers

Pingback: gadgets now

Pingback: sex

Pingback: Guia de negocios

Pingback: drugs

Pingback: Accident Attorney, Divorce Lawyers, Personal injury lawyers

Pingback: email blaster

Pingback: samaa news

Pingback: GreenSmoke e-cigarettes

Pingback: hair bumps from shaving

Pingback: stopthestresstoday.com/contact

Pingback: Trusted Company

Pingback: the plumbing cure

Pingback: commercial roofing fort worth texas

Pingback: buy seo

Pingback: newport beach

Pingback: online flashcards

Pingback: seo in uk

Pingback: Hair Transplant

Pingback: Newport Beach

Pingback: agence web

Pingback: Wigs Denver

Pingback: aloe vera gel 99

Pingback: House Cleaning Sydney

Pingback: indicizzazione google

Pingback: betboo

Pingback: binary options strategy

Pingback: betboo

Pingback: guttering London

Pingback: بفركس احتيال

Pingback: Zebra Printer Repair

Pingback: aluminium gutters

Pingback: bureaux ferm?s centre ville Montr?al

Pingback: check this video

Pingback: alaska fishing trips

Pingback: locksmith in Farmington Hills

Pingback: digital media marketing

Pingback: kinder joy

Pingback: sex

Pingback: Mad ud af huset

Pingback: international courier rates to usa from hyderabad

Pingback: legit reviews

Pingback: Homepage

Pingback: Property Management

Pingback: rehabilitacja po udarze

Pingback: bikini body

Pingback: cheap fifa 15 coins

Pingback: computer repair muskegon

Pingback: auto locksmith

Pingback: kangen water filter

Pingback: larin chat

Pingback: larina igraonica

Pingback: precoce comment faire

Pingback: Ryan Hattaway

Pingback: Pygmies, Buffalo, and Christian Hardwiring

Pingback: Julefrokost

Pingback: vaincre éjaculation précoce

Pingback: okna

Pingback: Law Book Shop

Pingback: ejacculation precosse

Pingback: vaincre éjaculation précoce

Pingback: spy

Pingback: pets

Pingback: coaching for competition

Pingback: best noise cancelling headphone

Pingback: cpa firm

Pingback: blogger layouts

Pingback: Magical Spells

Pingback: cupon

Pingback: Preston Byrd

Pingback: Preston Byrd

Pingback: Preston Byrd

Pingback: Daily Amar Desh

Pingback: Magnetic Messaging

Pingback: dolphin nose

Pingback: www.livestreamvoetbal.tv

Pingback: citizen watches online review

Pingback: Godkjent renholdsfirma Oslo

Pingback: fake review

Pingback: whaling washington

Pingback: women's suede & Shearling

Pingback: Anonymous

Pingback: click

Pingback: Auto Insurance Quote

Pingback: digital signage ad network

Pingback: house loans singapore

Pingback: vimax porno

Pingback: vimax

Pingback: ahernandezlaw.com

Pingback: vimax

Pingback: vimax zvacsenie

Pingback: Beauty GWP

Pingback: superbahis

Pingback: Cord Blood banking

Pingback: umbilical cord blood banking

Pingback: employee handbook translation

Pingback: bail bondsman

Pingback: Aspergers Test

Pingback: bets10

Pingback: sedewakantystyczna krytyka

Pingback: watercolor

Pingback: bitcoin

Pingback: odziez reklamowa

Pingback: hostel w poznaniu

Pingback: prozac conspiracy

Pingback: Home Theatre Calgary

Pingback: sprzatanie zielona góra

Pingback: Kim Kardashian

Pingback: gay porn

Pingback: Tiffanie Craddock

Pingback: bonneau south carolina

Pingback: Puremature.com

Pingback: buy google +1

Pingback: DIRTY ARMY

Pingback: Tagesdeals

Pingback: tu-get

Pingback: director of marketing communications

Pingback: Designer Engagement Rings

Pingback: vimax

Pingback: see here

Pingback: Gheata Carbonica

Pingback: molotov mitchell

Pingback: adwords konto

Pingback: search marketing

Pingback: his comment is here

Pingback: Professional Logo Design

Pingback: table topper

Pingback: Anonymous

Pingback: simply essentials tweezers for ingrown hair

Pingback: Matelas

Pingback: bars in durham

Pingback: sell house fast

Pingback: HEALTH and

Pingback: Chicago Credit Card Web Design

Pingback: Straipsniu rasymas ir talpinimas

Pingback: Remarkamobile Videos

Pingback: cialis online without prescription

Pingback: kinder surprise

Pingback: additional reading/25/the-levin-papantonio-law-firm-launches-xarelto-lawsuit-website-in-response-to-expanding-litigation/

Pingback: valium without prescription

Pingback: viagra without prescription

Pingback: Hosting

Pingback: Waar studeren

Pingback: Transfer, fares

Pingback: orlando taxi to busch garden

Pingback: Vadim Enikeev

Pingback: Pueraria

Pingback: property valuations sydney

Pingback: goophone i6

Pingback: Kosher auditing Asia

Pingback: Website

Pingback: alarme maison pas cher

Pingback: wynajem sceny

Pingback: Website

Pingback: Spam

Pingback: cars history

Pingback: acorn stairlifts

Pingback: our site

Pingback: kezia noble

Pingback: gun oil

Pingback: Synergy Boiler

Pingback: national congress

Pingback: Tamarac Talk

Pingback: Sharon Baron

Pingback: melanotan 2

Pingback: sex

Pingback: android L review

Pingback: online pharmacy cialis

Pingback: online sports betting

Pingback: Free Viagra

Pingback: Taxi to Gatwick

Pingback: purificadoras de agua.

Pingback: Mayday Games Review

Pingback: sony

Pingback: mytopbrokers.com

Pingback: como agrandar el pene

Pingback: cual es el precio de garcinia cambogia

Pingback: Casino

Pingback: garcinia cambogia funciona

Pingback: showbox on pc

Pingback: sex

Pingback: Kamagra

Pingback: Leading Hair Transplant Surgeons Recommend Hairfor2

Pingback: umbrella companies

Pingback: ??????????????·???(??????))

Pingback: pebble tiles

Pingback: sydney property valuers

Pingback: sliced pebble tile

Pingback: Wow it no good bad!

Pingback: vision board

Pingback: cerrajeros 24 horas valencia

Pingback: gel nails scottsdale

Pingback: anal viagra

Pingback: desatrancos y poceria madrid

Pingback: dream boards

Pingback: poker system

Pingback: poker system

Pingback: tramadol generic

Pingback: adventure games

Pingback: Garage door repairs white plains ny

Pingback: alkaline ionized water

Pingback: Canadian steroids

Pingback: Watch videos here at Supernatural & Sci-Fi Flicks

Pingback: sexy emails

Pingback: buy steroids

Pingback: naples pet sitters

Pingback: sexy emails

Pingback: fearless presentations

Pingback: Doug Ducey Arizona

Pingback: loyal 9 marketing

Pingback: comedy videos

Pingback: fearless presentations.

Pingback: Toronto Product Photography

Pingback: pfanswers

Pingback: Toronto Product Photography

Pingback: annuaire

Pingback: leaders institute

Pingback: scam

Pingback: kannada songs

Pingback: kpop2

Pingback: buyer review

Pingback: Website

Pingback: alkaline water

Pingback: Minneapolis Locksmith

Pingback: rick highsmith

Pingback: House demolition

Pingback: leaders institute

Pingback: JT Foxx

Pingback: JT Foxx

Pingback: leaders institute.

Pingback: leaders institute.

Pingback: directory

Pingback: teléfono inversa búsqueda de número de

Pingback: best rates hotels

Pingback: Minneapolis Locksmith

Pingback: Darian Braun Lawsuit

Pingback: onlive knives

Pingback: Hip Hop Blog TripleR

Pingback: penis

Pingback: pioneer screens

Pingback: viagra penis

Pingback: seo münchen

Pingback: seo münchen

Pingback: small business loans

Pingback: satellite direct tv

Pingback: Cloud Hosting Los Angeles

Pingback: seo training

Pingback: water ionizer

Pingback: crewe locksmith

Pingback: techos de aluminio

Pingback: video games

Pingback: Portovelo

Pingback: superbahis217

Pingback: London Escorts

Pingback: Google

Pingback: click here

Pingback: rental cars

Pingback: Josh Griggs of Michigan

Pingback: blackberry tether

Pingback: blank clothing

Pingback: porn

Pingback: penis cakes

Pingback: online poker

Pingback: click here

Pingback: süperbahis

Pingback: Amauris Bastidas

Pingback: click here

Pingback: ranger

Pingback: yoga hong kong north point alliance church

Pingback: Free Viagra

Pingback: easy gold from wow auction house

Pingback: back to school shopping blog

Pingback: juku

Pingback: leaders institute

Pingback: leaders institute.

Pingback: leaders institute.

Pingback: leaders institute,

Pingback: leaders institute,

Pingback: additional info

Pingback: how to jump higher

Pingback: Chad Conley Bail Bonds

Pingback: adjustable kettlebell

Pingback: explain it

Pingback: Everiss

Pingback: Everiss

Pingback: exercise

Pingback: water ionizer

Pingback: hcg drops

Pingback: how to lose weight fast

Pingback: LIDAR Jammer

Pingback: teemco

Pingback: Garcinia Cambogia,

Pingback: property condo

Pingback: Carpet Cleaner

Pingback: porn movie

Pingback: color lens store

Pingback: process server Chicago il

Pingback: Viagra

Pingback: milf porn

Pingback: Nigeria Idol

Pingback: bForex scam

Pingback: designer clothes for men

Pingback: Hostgator coupons

Pingback: bForex set-up

Pingback: comprar colombia

Pingback: comprar y vender

Pingback: bForex scam

Pingback: Hypnosis Adelaide

Pingback: comprar en mexico

Pingback: spy

Pingback: furniture singapore

Pingback: konaklamali turlar

Pingback: spy

Pingback: husa

Pingback: anal viagra

Pingback: sex

Pingback: Personal trainer Neve Monsun

Pingback: free gold maps

Pingback: Skepvet

Pingback: how to steal credit cards

Pingback: Orange County Bail Bonds

Pingback: Orange County Bail Bonds

Pingback: đen trang trí

Pingback: dèn ngh? thu?t

Pingback: viagra canada

Pingback: Anal

Pingback: vippi

Pingback: spy-shop

Pingback: pigeon forge cabin rentals

Pingback: spy-shop

Pingback: vibrator

Pingback: Receiving Mails

Pingback: spy

Pingback: Receiving and Logistic

Pingback: Lawsuits

Pingback: warez

Pingback: cheapest online mba

Pingback: lenceria sexy

Pingback: ask fm tracker

Pingback: ask fm hack

Pingback: lenceria sexy

Pingback: bus tours to new york from halifax

Pingback: anahata yoga hong kong costa

Pingback: data rescue

Pingback: data rescue

Pingback: bus tours to new york from moncton

Pingback: fowllowme

Pingback: credit repair kit

Pingback: goji actives bula

Pingback: orthovela

Pingback: orthovela

Pingback: orthovela

Pingback: sexy-angels

Pingback: coleus Forskohlii Root Standardized

Pingback: fdpod.com

Pingback: same day edit vancouver

Pingback: Underwater housing

Pingback: Underwater housing

Pingback: Reverse Directory

Pingback: Free Directory Of Laptops

Pingback: Underwater housing

Pingback: Telephone Directory UK Free

Pingback: Porno.

Pingback: Porno.

Pingback: auto loan with bad credit

Pingback: Alpharetta plumber

Pingback: Locksmith Oklahoma City

Pingback: vpnserialkey

Pingback: yorkshire wedding photographer

Pingback: Aditya Mittal

Pingback: pirater un compte facebook

Pingback: cheap mens clothing usa

Pingback: plastic surgery pittsburgh

Pingback: plastic surgeons pittsburgh

Pingback: lesbian sex game

Pingback: make money online

Pingback: cheapest car insurance

Pingback: Lasik San Diego

Pingback: Lasik San Diego

Pingback: Key logger

Pingback: Locksmith OKC

Pingback: pr ajansı

Pingback: anal viagra

Pingback: website

Pingback: personal trainer tools

Pingback: website

Pingback: degage

Pingback: telephone service

Pingback: sell my house fast

Pingback: degage

Pingback: escort vienna

Pingback: using saran wrap for weight loss

Pingback: escort vienna

Pingback: FSBO Illinois

Pingback: escort vienna,

Pingback: escort vienna,