Nate Phelps at the Reason Rally

Like Daniel Fincke, I found Nate Phelps’ talk at the Reason Rally to be one of the most moving and inspiring moments of the event. I think he delivered the single best line: “They called me a rebel. For years, I wore that name with shame until I realized that, confronted with the god of my father, rebellion is the only moral option.” Hear, hear.

"Ray Smith : Nations like Denmark, Ireland, Germany, The Netherlands and Sweden would demonstrate otherwise.Unfettered ..."

Gingrich Has an Autocratic Idea of ..."
"I think you might be half-remembering:We knew the world would not be the same. A ..."

Wiles: God Didn’t Create Judaism or ..."
"That contract that the Russian hitman was paid to take out?"

Gingrich Has an Autocratic Idea of ..."
"You forgot Kakistocracy = rule by the worst.(Also not sure "democracy" applies here. Let's never ..."

Gingrich Has an Autocratic Idea of ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • The Lorax

    Sometimes I wish the Four Horsemen would appear and bring the Apocalypse, just so I can pick up a baseball bat and defiantly attack them.

    You know what they call it when you’re brought to a place against your will and forced all your life to obey an all-powerful master? Slavery.

    Live free or die, even if you must kill God himself! Better to rule in Hell than serve in Heaven!

  • Bronze Dog

    Live free or die, even if you must kill God himself! Better to rule in Hell than serve in Heaven!

    For me, it’d be better to have moral integrity in Hell. The only ruling I’m interested in is self-rule.

    Of course, Heaven would require that we abandon self-rule and abdicate all moral responsibility. Their “morality” is designed to be incomprehensible to humans so it can allow their god to commit torture, genocide, slavery, rape, and all the worst evils humans are capable of and some we aren’t capable of. This conveniently provides the Heaven-bound with a convenient excuse to do any obvious evil when the mood strikes and not feel responsible for it.

  • LightningRose

    To add to The Lorax’s comment, it’s better to live on one’s feet than to die on one’s knees!

  • hybrid


    Don’t you mean it’s better to die on one’s feet than to live on one’s knees?

  • jesuslovesbags

    This was my favorite speech of the day.

    Here’s the audio

  • laurentweppe

    Yet, as I expressed earlier, beginning one’s speech by

    This is the largest secularist gathering in the history of the world

    in front of a puny crowd of ten thousands people cannot but wake my smug french side: ten thousand people, and he calls this a large secularist gathering? When we gather, a whole Nation stands still, and governments tremble before us.

    This recent beginner’s effort is far from it.

  • LightningRose

    Hybrid @#4,

    Nope. I got it right. It’s far, far, better to live on one’s feet than to die on one’s knees!

  • peterh

    Phelps epitomizes all that is good in all those who have gone that lonely road and found there is much companionship at its end. His heartfelt simplicity was truly eloquent.

  • Michael Heath

    The Lorax:

    Better to rule in Hell than serve in Heaven!

    If we’re going to concede the whole Christian thing and God being a judging god, than I’ll have to disagree. Eternal punishment by God in the Bible is suffering beyond any other affliction I’ve seen imagined.