HAPPY THANKSGIVING, 2017 Edition November 23, 2017


I recalled that last year at this time, I wasn’t feeling terribly thankful because of the result of the US presidential election. So I looked back to see what I wrote, and found that my characteristic optimism was holding up pretty well.

  1. I suggested that we could be thankful for people who felt more impassioned than ever to uphold our democratic and secular values.

That hasn’t changed. We had the Women’s March! We had the Virginia elections in which a transsexual woman won a state representative seat from a religious conservative. Trump and Republican legislators are so far down in the polls that Democrats are hopeful about taking over the house in 2018 and maybe the Senate too.

  1. I pointed out that Obamacare and Medicare still existed.

And a year later, they still do! Granted, the Republican-dominated House and Senate tried their best to repeal Obamacare, but so far, it hasn’t worked. A few pesky Republican senators won’t let it happen. Does that ever make Trump mad.


Medicare reductions are in the new tax bill, but that hasn’t passed yet and why should we think that it will? The Republicans haven’t passed any significant legislation since they’ve been in power.

  1. Then I asked for your help, because I couldn’t think of anything else that was positive.

Now, as I look over this year’s list, I notice a focus on negative things that have not yet happened. But truly, it could be worse. The nuclear button has not been pushed, for instance. And we still have all the non-political things to be thankful for that we had last year and have every year, really, as humanists:

  • Family and good friends (real and “virtual”);
  • The great stroke of luck we all got when we were born into this world;
  • The opportunity to live the one life we have with as much enjoyment as we can muster;
  • A commitment to make things better for ourselves and others while we’re here and for future generations. That could be a lot of hard work, but it beats counting on a non-existent rapture.

**Editor’s Question** Looking back a year ago, what are you feeling thankful for?


Linda LaScola 4-14Linda LaScola is co-author, with Daniel C. Dennett, of Caught in the Pulpit: Leaving Belief Behind (2013) and “Preachers who are not Believers” (2010). She is an independent qualitative research consultant who works out of Washington, D.C. She holds a Master’s Degree in Social Work from the Catholic University of America and is a co-founder of the Clergy Project.

>>Photo Credits: “Donald Trump September 3 2015” by Michael Vadon – Own work. Licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0 via Commons – https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Donald_Trump_September_3_2015.jpg#/media/File:Donald_Trump_September_3_2015.jpg

by M. Rehemtulla – http://www.flickr.com/photos/quoimedia/5289972209/in/set-72157625057312514/, CC BY 2.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=12737421 :  By Jan Luyken – Bowyer’s Bible, Bolton, England, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=7550941

By Robert Walter Weir – PwHe6-AEvwmbIw at Google Cultural Institute maximum zoom level, Public Domain, (pilgrims) https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=21913652

"> I will add that as someone with past experience as an alcoholism counselor, he ..."

Privilege – Male/White/Ivy League/Christian/Whatever
"> ... a fundamental reality I appreciated years ago when dealing with the power and ..."

With Awe Comes Shock
""No room at the inn".Actually, in those days all the travelers slept in their clothes, ..."

Secular Sermon Series:   #1 Noah’s ARKS
"> ... Noah and the Ark, which was originally plagiarized from the Sumerian Epic of ..."

Secular Sermon Series:   #1 Noah’s ARKS

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • mason lane

    Very thankful for you Linda LaScola and all the work you do on “Rational Doubt” as Editor in Chief.

    Now, if I get a perfectly cooked https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/0f7bbbe793c38e1fa70755883abb8c61e45fad5e68d71723f88d2c4d15ff24e9.png , falling off the bone turkey leg, my heart and stomach will be full of blissful secular joy!

    • mason lane

      Gosh, they were all white meat lovers, so I got both legs & had #2 today! What a lovely secular blessing. 🙂

  • Tony D’Arcy

    Thank God that all those awful narrow minded bigoted Christians got kicked out of England by other equally awful narrow minded bigoted Christians to end up in what is now known as the USA ! Our Church of England is now a tame old beast indeed. As Marx put it in the 1st Preface to Capital ; The Church of England would rather part with 38 of its 39 Articles, than part with 1/39th of its income.

    Whatever, enjoy the turkey and cranberry sauce We have far more in common, than what divides us.

  • Mark Rutledge

    Yes thanks Linda. And thanks to TCP members. And thanks to the growing number of progressives in our world who will not be silenced.

  • ElizabetB.

    Yes — the nuclear button has not been pushed, plus Congress is debating the wisdom of there being no checks on the president’s ability to push it at whim. (Hurry!!)

    Maybe David Brooks’ idea that our current White House occupant has galvanized opposition to sexual predation — which may result in a permanent sea change in acceptable behavior. Let’s hope!!!

    I stay thankful for those “virtual friends”!! ….for dialog partners here and — we Thanksgivinged with our soon-to-be-married offspring who met their beloved online, maybe 4 years ago, and have negotiated the real-world challenges of living & working on 3 separate continents & islands. Some new developments are good for the heart : ) and I’m very, very thankful