About Captain Cassidy

Cassidy was raised Catholic, converted to Pentecostalism in her mid-teens, married a preacher, and deconverted after college. She blogs about religion, deconversion, video and tabletop gaming, psychology, modern culture, and other such topics at Roll to Disbelieve.

You can find the Captain on Facebook, Twitter, and Tumblr.

The Power of Prayer in Christian Marketing.

Last time we met up, we were talking about Christian marketing and why it sucks. Christians are required to put faith in stuff that simply isn’t true–and their magical thinking carries through to their strategies around revitalizing their brand, guaranteeing failure. [Read more…]


Stay in touch with Roll to Disbelieve Facebook:

Why Christian Marketing Sucks — And Why It Must.

As one might expect, the leaders in the religion are doing their best to combat their groups’ losses with a public-relations and marketing blitz. Unfortunately for them, those efforts are doomed–thanks to the efforts of those selfsame leaders. [Read more…]


Stay in touch with Roll to Disbelieve Facebook:

Fundagelical Preppers and the Problem with ‘Pokkalypses.

Last year I wrote about the rising numbers of fundagelical Christians getting into prepping, a subculture devoted to preparing for some imagined upcoming apocalypse. Not only are their efforts not actually very useful or helpful to anybody, but all this preparation speaks more to their own fear of change than to any possible future troubles the world might face. I’ll show you how today. [Read more…]


Stay in touch with Roll to Disbelieve Facebook:

You Lost Me: Why Nothing Can Change.

This past week we were talking about the 2011 book You Lost Me by David Kinnaman. The book was about why modern Christian evangelical churches were losing so many young-adult members, and how they could possibly reverse that trend. Christians either agreed wholeheartedly with this book’s ideas or they hated every word of it. Either way, however, nothing whatsoever changed in the modern Christian evangelical church as a result of it. Today I’ll show you why nothing changed, and why nothing ever actually could. [Read more…]


Stay in touch with Roll to Disbelieve Facebook:

The Trouble with Tribbers.

A long time ago I wrote about fundagelical preppers and how the doom-preparation community had been taken over by fundagelical zealots fearing Rapture and Armageddon. There are some new developments in that story–but first, here are some new Rapture scares to look at! [Read more…]


Stay in touch with Roll to Disbelieve Facebook:

Lord Snow Presides #8: Meet Texe Marrs.

I’m looking at end-of-the-world conspiracy theorists right now and ran across a name I hadn’t heard before: Texe Marrs. I’m wondering how he’s managed to evade my notice until now, considering he clearly ran in the same sort of circles I did back in the late 1980s! [Read more…]


Stay in touch with Roll to Disbelieve Facebook:

You Lost Me: How to Create Change Without Changing a Thing.

There’s another magic spell he wants to teach Christians to cast here, and that spell revolves around reframing unpleasant and negative ideas so that churches won’t have to change anything they’re doing with regard to all the stuff that people cite as reasons to steer clear of Christianity. [Read more…]


Stay in touch with Roll to Disbelieve Facebook:

You Lost Me: No No, Y’all, David Kinnaman is All Wrong.

To say the least, we haven’t been, um, impressed by it a whole lot. And the funny thing is, a lot of his fellow fundagelicals aren’t either. It seems like for every fan of the guy’s ideas, he’s got a couple of detractors–all of whom have their own pet ideas about What the Big Problem Here Is and How to Fix It. [Read more…]


Stay in touch with Roll to Disbelieve Facebook:

You Lost Me’s Push for Discipling: Hold On, Y’All, He Knows Exactly What to Do.

David Kinnaman’s central idea is that The Big Problem Here is that modern churches aren’t properly discipling their youth and that if this starts happening properly, young people will stop leaving and maybe even return to the groups they’ve already left. Today I’ll teach you what this confusing term means–most of the time anyway–and why this author is totally wrong. [Read more…]


Stay in touch with Roll to Disbelieve Facebook:

You Lost Me: And How They Lost Us.

David Kinnaman always couches Prodigals’ disbelief in terms of how they came to disbelieve. The exact stuff we don’t believe doesn’t interest him nearly as much as how we related to our last Christian group–and how we might relate to another in the future. [Read more…]


Stay in touch with Roll to Disbelieve Facebook: