When countering anti-evolutionary views such as those put forth by the intelligent design (ID) movement, anti-ID commentators often refer to “methodological naturalism” as a “ground rule” of science.

I’m not entirely happy with this, but I don’t see any great problem either — provided we think of this “ground rule” as a pragmatic rule, not an a priori straightjacket on investigation.

We like to stick with methods that have a good prospect of working, judged according to our present knowledge of how the world actually works. We may be wrong. Hence anyone — such as any of the ID philosophers — is welcome to propose doing things differently, but the scientific community needs a damn good reason to depart from its tried and true methods. Whining about exclusion is not sufficient. But on the other hand, if the ID people were able to demonstrate that their way of doing things allowed us to learn a good deal more about the world, well, our methods are not set in stone and we’d have to change them.

So far ID has no signs of success in this direction, and I would guess a snowballs chance in hell of ever getting anywhere. So I wish they’d stop whining.

Still, I worry when anti-ID commentators give the impression that “methodological naturalism” is something set in stone, or that it jumps out of a philosophical hat without being connnected to real-world reasons concerning what works. When that happens, ID-sympathetic philosophers correctly object that it looks like we’re offering up an arbitrary prejudice as if it defined science (sez who?) and enforcing it by what boils down to force rather than argument.

I would prefer that we were more careful not to give them such an opportunity.

Pingback: wholesale nfl jerseys()

Pingback: nike air jordan unc foot locker()

Pingback: neon gucci shoes cheap()

Pingback: buy timberland 74013()

Pingback: timberland homes tulsa()

Pingback: gucci gucci parody lyrics()

Pingback: gucci sale outlet online()

Pingback: flora by gucci zestaw()

Pingback: cheap wow gold()

Pingback: buy wow gold()

Pingback: moncler doudoune sans manche femme()

Pingback: ugg scontati 20()

Pingback: peuterey group telefono()

Pingback: taschen louis vuitton günstig()

Pingback: jordan legend blue()

Pingback: nike foams()

Pingback: jordan 11 legend blue()

Pingback: jordan retro 11 legend blue()

Pingback: legend blue 11s()

Pingback: www.metroparanormal.org()

Pingback: nike kd vii black history month()

Pingback: nike kd vii black history month()

Pingback: mcm red backpack price()

Pingback: http://www.timeashore.info//ysk0hz.asp()

Pingback: retro jordan 11()

Pingback: legend blue 11()

Pingback: jordan retro 11()

Pingback: Jordan 10 Red Cement 2015()

Pingback: Lady Liberty 10()

Pingback: jordan 11 legend blue()

Pingback: http://www.baodebank.com/givenchyen/givenchy-handbags.asp()

Pingback: legend blue 11s()

Pingback: air jordan 11 legend blue()

Pingback: lebron 12 data()

Pingback: www.totalbodycontouring.com()

Pingback: nike kd 7 texas()

Pingback: www.truewesthome.com()

Pingback: sac longchamp pas cher()

Pingback: jordan legend blue 11()

Pingback: Jordan 11 retro legend blue()

Pingback: canada goose chilliwack()

Pingback: nike kd 7 black history month()

Pingback: Red Cement 10()

Pingback: Retro Jordans()

Pingback: jordan 11 legend blue()

Pingback: www.surpluslines.com()

Pingback: b and q uk()

Pingback: ryna.co()

Pingback: canada goose coats for women()

Pingback: Red Cement 10()

Pingback: nike kd 7()

Pingback: nike kd vii texas()

Pingback: jordan 11 retro legend blue()

Pingback: gumtree classifieds()

Pingback: jordan retro 11 legend blue()

Pingback: asics america()

Pingback: www.shredcorp.com()

Pingback: foamposites()

Pingback: canada goose artic program()

Pingback: ravens jersey for kids()

Pingback: Jordan Lady Liberty 10()

Pingback: Jordan Lady Liberty 10()

Pingback: jordan 11 legend blue()

Pingback: legend blue 11s()

Pingback: asics wrestling shoes clearance()

Pingback: canada goose canada()

Pingback: legend blue 11s()

Pingback: new balance mr 1064()

Pingback: new balance best price()

Pingback: new balance 730 review()

Pingback: Red Cement 10s For Sale()

Pingback: www.rasarang.org()

Pingback: Air Max Australia()

Pingback: jordan 11 Columbia()

Pingback: Jordan Red Cement 10()

Pingback: Lady Liberty 10()

Pingback: jordan 11 legend blue()

Pingback: Jordan Retro 10()

Pingback: Jordan 10 Red Cement 2015()

Pingback: asic miner avalon()

Pingback: asic 2170 mens()

Pingback: new balance 420 enfant()

Pingback: new balance sg store()

Pingback: new balance babyschuhe()

Pingback: asics gt 2150 womens()

Pingback: air jordan 11 legend blue()

Pingback: Jordan Lady Liberty 10()

Pingback: legend blue 11s()

Pingback: new balance 420 black blue red()

Pingback: http://www.parsnew.com/av98d.asp()

Pingback: asics nimbus 15()

Pingback: http://infocienciasdigital.fc.ul.pt/jsdwtx.asp()

Pingback: asics gel vigor()

Pingback: kids new balance uk()

Pingback: legend blue 11s()

Pingback: mt101 new balance()

Pingback: legend blue 11s()

Pingback: lebron 12 shoes()

Pingback: www.mosaikmtl.com()

Pingback: asics triathlon shoes()

Pingback: asics gel lyte iii review()

Pingback: Jordan Retro 10 Lady Liberty()

Pingback: nike free 3.0 damen rosa()

Pingback: wow gold()

Pingback: asic nimbus()

Pingback: jordan 11 retro legend blue()

Pingback: jordan legend blue 11()

Pingback: metallic gold foamposites()

Pingback: realgouldsparts.com()

Pingback: Cheap Air Max 90()

Pingback: www.stagedoorenglishsetters.com()

Pingback: nike free run wei脽 blau()

Pingback: jordan 11 retro legend blue()

Pingback: jordan 11s()

Pingback: retro 11 legend blue()

Pingback: www.mymsa-eg.com()

Pingback: nike free 3.0 pink gelb()

Pingback: jordan retro 11 legend blue()

Pingback: nike blazer grau rosa()

Pingback: replica Givenchy handbags()

Pingback: lebron 12 shoes()

Pingback: foamposites for sale()

Pingback: nike free run shops()

Pingback: keerthisarees.com()

Pingback: nike free 3.0 hybrid id()

Pingback: foamposites metallic gold()

Pingback: nike free 42 g眉nstig()

Pingback: nike free 3.0 rot grau()

Pingback: Givenchy replica bags()

Pingback: バーバリー コート メンズ アウトレット()

Pingback: nike free gr眉n blau()

Pingback: www.applied-optronics.com()

Pingback: 三陽 バーバリー コート メンズ ブラック()

Pingback: nike blazer rot damen()

Pingback: Air Max Australia()

Pingback: Gucci outlet UK()

Pingback: nike outlet nrw()

Pingback: 販売中 バーバリー チェック キルティングコート レディース()

Pingback: nike id roshe run floral()

Pingback: ugg bailey button womens boots()

Pingback: pulsco.com()

Pingback: nike air jordan 9 retro olive()

Pingback: cat 4 brother()

Pingback: legend blue 11()

Pingback: nike kd 7 black history month()

Pingback: www.fintubellc.com()

Pingback: Nike roshe run ID red()

Pingback: Hermes bags outlet()

Pingback: alkaline water machine()

Pingback: プラダバッグ()

Pingback: シャネル コココクーン()

Pingback: Air max 90 Online()

Pingback: シャネル バッグ 一覧()

Pingback: Roshe Midnight Navy Black()

Pingback: nike air max 1 leopard print usa()

Pingback: Nike roshe shopstyle()

Pingback: Air Max shoe box()

Pingback: Order Nike roshe run()

Pingback: Nike air roshe run review()

Pingback: http://www.xmcoop.com/htjbaz.asp()

Pingback: Roshe run FB leopard eBay()

Pingback: Womens air max 97()

Pingback: jordan retro 11 legend blue()

Pingback: Nike roshe run junior JD()

Pingback: Discount nike free()

Pingback: jordan 5 cement tongue()

Pingback: Black and grey roshe runs()

Pingback: new jordans()

Pingback: hornets 13s()

Pingback: louis vuitton outlet()

Pingback: louis vuitton outlet store()

Pingback: louis vuitton handbags()

Pingback: Nike air max man()

Pingback: replica bags uk()

Pingback: louis vuitton sale()

Pingback: cement tongue 5s 2015()

Pingback: UGG 3161 Sparkle Boots()

Pingback: hare 7s()

Pingback: Nike air max 90 size 8()

Pingback: collector cl 144 19()

Pingback: louis vuitton outlet()

Pingback: louis vuitton outlet()

Pingback: Roshe run men all black()

Pingback: urantiaalaska.org()

Pingback: louis vuitton outlet()

Pingback: jordan 7 hare()

Pingback: hare 7s()

Pingback: www.stellavirium.org()

Pingback: jordan retro 13()

Pingback: jordan 5 cement tongue for sale()

Pingback: low hornets 13()

Pingback: louis vuitton luggage()

Pingback: Nike roshe trainers black()

Pingback: louis vuitton bag()

Pingback: jordan 13 low hornets 2015()

Pingback: louis vuitton official website()

Pingback: www.lemonadeviaggievento.com()

Pingback: jordan 5 cement tongue()

Pingback: louis vuitton belt()

Pingback: 2012 new mayuko grosgrain bow long moncler down coat orange()

Pingback: hare 7s()

Pingback: guild wars 2 gold()

Pingback: FNoJGGlo()

Pingback: Dr Dre Beats()

Pingback: Toms shoes()

Pingback: Canada Goose outlet sale()

Pingback: cheap Nike Free Run()

Pingback: louis vuitton usa()

Pingback: retro 5 cement tongue()

Pingback: comprar relojes baratos mujer()

Pingback: jordan 13 low hornets()

Pingback: jordan retro 7()

Pingback: replica dior men shoes()

Pingback: louis vuitton outlet store()

Pingback: www.gatewayswinford.com()

Pingback: givenchy replica handbags on sale()

Pingback: cheap louis vuitton()

Pingback: jordan retro 13 hornets()

Pingback: who sells nike roshe runs()

Pingback: jordan 5 cement tongue()

Pingback: louis vuitton neverfull()

Pingback: Nike Air Max classic sale()

Pingback: Mulberry()

Pingback: Mackage()

Pingback: Moncler Canada()

Pingback: Nike roshe run mid QS NYC()

Pingback: www.sesef.co.uk()

Pingback: jordan 7()

Pingback: mens nike free run shoes()

Pingback: シャネル 財布()

Pingback: acheter le moncler dernier bleu 2014 berre des en duvet veste a capuche meilleure vente en femmes ligne()

Pingback: シャネルのバッグ()

Pingback: nike free 5.0 v4 running shoe()

Pingback: louis vuitton outlet store()

Pingback: jordan 13 hornets()

Pingback: シャネル ヴィンテージ バッグ()

Pingback: シャネル バッグ チェーン()

Pingback: シャネル バッグ ピンク()

Pingback: nevadog.ru()

Pingback: jordan retro 5 cement tongue()

Pingback: nike free 5.0 46 schwarz()

Pingback: jordan retro 7()

Pingback: wrtruyjgvgcszbrdr()

Pingback: nike schuhe free g眉nstig()

Pingback: low hornets 13s()

Pingback: nike air max 1 og 44 5()

Pingback: dr dre beats studio mlb()

Pingback: nike roshe run customize()

Pingback: hare 7s()

Pingback: nike free womens 5.0 sale()

Pingback: Canada Goose jacket outlet()

Pingback: Moncler UK()

Pingback: Louis Vuitton Canada()

Pingback: Mackage coat outlet()

Pingback: alkaline water()

Pingback: Sanders()

Pingback: Maduras()

Pingback: Porno()

Pingback: alkaline water()

Pingback: cheapest auto insurance()

Pingback: useful reference()

Pingback: get social media followers()

Pingback: シャネル ショルダーバッグ()

Pingback: przedszkole montessori Warszawa()

Pingback: free instagram followers()

Pingback: business and social media()

Pingback: https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/profile/8830ee69-a635-4327-9fff-82aa28cb8314()

Pingback: signal decoding software()

Pingback: employment history background check()

Pingback: videos porno()

Pingback: xxx()

Pingback: tragaperras online()

Pingback: kingsford waterbay condo()

Pingback: free autoresponder()

Pingback: Austin()

Pingback: videos porno()

Pingback: sexo casero()

Pingback: best buy fashion bracelets()

Pingback: click to investigate()

Pingback: thj-2201 powder()

Pingback: botanique at bartley floor plan()

Pingback: Stromio Gmbh()

Pingback: best buy smartphone accessories()

Pingback: useful link()

Pingback: Signs Of Pregnancy()

Pingback: bk-2c-b()

Pingback: london sports shop()

Pingback: Westwood Residences ec()

Pingback: over here()

Pingback: visit here()

Pingback: videos porno()