Murderers are as bad as nonbelievers!

I’ve started reading yet another Muslim book explaining why True Islam is a religion of peace that utterly rejects terrorism: Terror and Suicide Attacks: An Islamic Perspective, edited by Ergün Çapan.

That’s fine and good: the more Muslims who reject jihadi ideology, the better. But immediately, the book gets off on the wrong foot. Fethullah Gülen, a very prominent Turkish religious leader, writes, in the first paragraph of his chapter, that “In Islam, killing a human is an act that is equal in gravity to unbelief.” Which presumably also means that unbelief is equal in gravity to murder. Just to make sure there is no misunderstanding, his last paragraph states that

Ibn Abbas said that a murderer will stay in Hell for all eternity. This is the same punishment that is assigned to unbelievers. This means that a murderer is subjected to the same punishment as an unbeliever. In short, in Islam, in terms of the punishment to be dealt on the Day of Judgment, a murderer will be considered to be as low as someone who has rejected God and the Prophet (an atheist in other words).

So Gülen is addressing an audience that already agrees that atheists are horrible human beings. He’s trying to convince his readers that murder is also unacceptable. In fact, murder is so bad, it is as bad as atheism!

Gülen, I should note, enjoys an international reputation as an apostle of tolerance and moderation. But as is often the case with Muslim religious leaders, his toleration refers to a modus vivendi between different religious communities—usually, in fact, between Abrahamic religions only. It will be a long time before atheism becomes as acceptable among Muslims as, say, among Southern Baptists.

About Taner Edis

Professor of physics at Truman State University

  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/02494141255401096538 uzza

    Wow!

  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/11983601793874190779 Steven Carr

    What categories of people reject the Prophet, beside atheists?

  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/11983601793874190779 Steven Carr

    The first page says that in Islam, nobody can touch an innocent person.

    Are unbelievers innocent, and so cannot be touched by Muslims?

    Why would Allah send innocent people to Hell?

    Because they are not innocent?

  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/03144472895165690444 M IQBAL RANA

    HUSBAND BUTCHERED IN NOV 2 SUICIDE BOMB
    RESPECTED SIR!
    WITH DUE REVERENCE AND VENERATION I BEG TO ARTICULATE THAT I AND MY FAMILY HAVE LITERALLY BEEN HOWLING, LAMENTING, WAILING, YOWLING AND MOANING IN FRONT OF AUTHORITIES.NOBODY IS HEEDING. MY HUSBAND WAS BUTCHERED IN NOVEMBER 2, 2009 SUICIDE BOMBING IN RAWALPINDI ALONG OTHER 35 PAUPERIZED AND NAIVE PEOPLE. (F.I.R. # 972 REGISTERED ON 02-11-2009 IN POLICE STATION CIVIL LINES RAWALPINDI.) HE WENT TO COLLECT HIS MEAGER SCANT AND SCRAWNY PENSION FROM NBC NEAR SHALIMAR. NO AUTHORITY HAS YET CONTACTED COMMISERATED AND SYMPATHIZED US.HE WAS THE BACKBONE OF MY FAMILY OF 10 PEOPLE.HE HAD NOTHING TO DO WITH THIS COMBAT.THE LOSS IS SO COLOSSAL THAT NO ONE BESIDES MY FAMILY AND THE OTHER AFFECTED FAMILIES CAN IMAGINE. DOES ANYBODY HAVE SYMPATHIES COMPASSION MERCY AND PITY AND ABOVE ALL THE CONSCIENCE TO GIVE JUSTICE, EQUITY, RETRIBUTION, REPRISAL , WOULD YOU PLEASE RESPOND AND RETORT?
    YOURS TURLY,

    SIDDIQA IQBAL I.D. CARD #37405-9876033-2
    WIDOW OF MUHAMMAD IQBAL (SLAUGHTERED IN NOV.2,2009 SUICIDE BOMB IN RAWALPINDI OUTSIDE SHALIMAR HOTEL)I.D. CARD #37405-8327976-9
    KHASRA 1283 STREET 5 IQBAL MARKET, LANE 3 LAKHAN ROAD, QUAID E AZAM COLONY DHAMIAL CAMP RAWALPINDI PAKISTAN
    0332 5231798
    0345 5346035
    051 5577427


CLOSE | X

HIDE | X