The Meaning of ‘miracle’ – Part 1

I just finished reading Richard Swinburne’s chapter “Arguments from History and Miracles”, Chapter 12 in The Existence of God (2nd ed., 2004), about the same time Taner Edis did his post Natural miracles?” (http://secularoutpost.infidels.org/2011/07/natural-miracles.html).
So, this seems like a good time to revisit the topic of ‘miracles’.

Back in 2008, I did a series of posts on the definition of ‘miracle’ proposed by Richard Purtill:

http://secularoutpost.infidels.org/2008/11/purtills-definition-of-miracle-part-7.html
http://secularoutpost.infidels.org/2008/10/purtills-definition-of-miracle-part-6.html
http://secularoutpost.infidels.org/2008/09/purtills-definition-of-miracle-part-5.html
http://secularoutpost.infidels.org/2008/07/purtills-definition-of-miracle-part-4.html
http://secularoutpost.infidels.org/2008/06/purtill-defining-miracles-part-3.html
http://secularoutpost.infidels.org/2008/05/purtill-defining-miracles-part-2.html
http://secularoutpost.infidels.org/2008/05/purtill-defining-miracles-part-2.html
http://secularoutpost.infidels.org/2008/05/richard-purtill-defining-miracles.html

Swinburne gives his own definition of ‘miracle’, and he also refers to definitions given by Aquinas and David Hume. I will start with Aquinas’ definition, move on to Hume’s, and then take a look at Swinburne’s.

One thing that troubles me lately about some of these definitions, is that they make the involvement of God a necessary condition for the application of the word ‘miracle’.

To be continuted…

"Your demand for a demonstration of "impossibility" for physicalism is -- explicitly -- impossible to ..."

Can you know what it is ..."
"Dianelos,Interesting take on NDEs. :-) I see nobody else has offered a reply, so I ..."

Can you know what it is ..."
"Ponzi,I noticed I did not answer all your questions. And, while researching Oliver Sack's views, ..."

Can you know what it is ..."
"In the words of Douglas Adams ( Hitchhikers' Guide to the Galaxy), " Well that ..."

Kreeft’s Case for God – Part ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment