Strange debate experience

Yesterday I was at REASONFEST 2012 at Lawrence, Kansas, where the organizers had set me up to debate whether Islam and science can coexist.

It was a strange experience. My opponent, a Muslim social scientist called Leila Chahine, turned out to be more of an illustration of my thesis than anything else. From creationism to science-in-the-Quran apologetics, she endorsed all the stereotypically conservative Muslim pseudoscientific nonsense. She kind of made my point for me; I should have turned my time over to her.

Oh well, I don’t think much of these sorts of debates anyway. If it were up to me, I’d set up not a formal debate but a discussion between people who are close enough to each other to have lots of common ground but yet have some interesting disagreements.

"You note that Aristotle would hold that there can be a secular foundation for objective ..."

Taking Atheism Ignorantly
"Thank you for your clear and relevant comments, and especially for the quote from Feser ..."

Feser’s Case for God – Part ..."
"Yes, my thinking has been influenced by the analytic tradition. The typical reader of Feser ..."

Feser’s Case for God – Part ..."
"Thank you for your clear and relevant comments."

Feser’s Case for God – Part ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment