Does it matter how people reject religion?

By and large, I’d prefer it if more people did not hold supernatural beliefs—or at least, if they did not hold politically potent supernatural beliefs. (While I’m at it, I’d also like world peace, for my knees to suddenly not show the effects of my age on the basketball court, and so on and so forth.)

I’m not sure it matters much how such nonbelief would come about. Given my general cynicism about the human race, I don’t expect that any widespread nonbelief would be due to careful, reflective rejection of supernatural claims. Sometimes I run into hopes that better science education, for example, might help—if more people absorbed a scientific outlook, they should be more critical of unsubstantiated fantastic claims about gods and revelations. But then, my experience suggests that broad-based, in-depth, quality science education is too resource-intensive to be realistically possible any time soon. And even for those small segments of the population today for which science education is available, I’m not sure it can make a lot of difference. Thinking scientifically across the board is too difficult, and religion too easily finds the many loopholes it can exploit to insinuate itself into normal human minds.

A better suggestion is that perhaps if life circumstances improve for many more people, if we generally have more secure lives, religiosity will also decrease. I guess it might, at that. And in some locations, Jesus may well become not the “done thing” anymore, while politically impotent dabbling in shamanic “wisdom” and alternative medicine drivel-of-the-month will become more common.

I can’t get much excited about such a scenario either. In any case, we’re almost certain to continue to collectively behave like morons. If religion were to wane, we’d just have one color fade a bit in a wide spectrum of human folly.

About Taner Edis

Professor of physics at Truman State University

  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/16342860692268708455 Angra Mainyu

    Does it matter to whom or to what end?

    In any case, I tend to agree in general with your view (if I read it correctly) that when belief in some immensely powerful being who for some reason hides from us yet responds to prayer in some mysterious way declines, such belief tends to be replaced by a similar belief (perhaps, changing the being), or by another absurd ideology in any case, usually involving mysterious stuff doing mysterious things.

    Still, I think there is some room for improvement, especially if standards of living do improve significantly.


CLOSE | X

HIDE | X