Alonzo Fyfe’s Alternative Answer to “Where Do Atheists Get Their Morality?”

Back in 2008 Alonzo Fyfe blogged about the question, “Where do atheists get their morality?” As an alternative to “the standard attempt to defend some moral theory,” he proposes the following answer.

“A lot of theists want to know where atheists get their morality because theists are bigots looking for an excuse to hate their atheist neighbors, and ‘You are morally inferior to us’ has long been a favorite dehumanization technique of the hateful bigot. Clearly, atheists do quite well when it comes to behaving morally, at least as well as their Christian counterparts. It may be natural to express some curiosity as to why this is the case. But to cast atheists as morally inferior in order to generate a reason to hate them – that’s not a course that a truly moral person would ever pursue.”

I’m not sure I can endorse this response, at least not in all cases. It assumes that the only reason someone would ask that question is bigotry, which seems false to me. It’s easy to imagine how someone thinking through the issues for the first time could genuinely wonder about the source of atheist morality, without in any way trying to suggest that atheists are morally inferior.
"My copy of Stump's book is AWOL. Can you summarize her argument, or at least ..."

The Laws of Physics and the ..."
"Yes, Parfit rejects the idea of abstract (Platonic) objects serving as the truthmaker for ethical ..."

Richard Dawkins and Moral Realism
"Keith, this is off from your OP, but it *is* about denying the PSR: are ..."

The Laws of Physics and the ..."
"Thanks, Hal. I will take a look."

The Laws of Physics and the ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment