Testing Supernatural Hypotheses

Are supernatural hypotheses testable? This was a question raised by Victor Reppert on his Dangerous Idea blog, and I responded a couple of weeks ago. The subsequent discussion got rather confused and confusing, and I would like to try to untangle things and see if I can get clearer on the issue here. Thanks much to interlocutor Richard Wein whose gentle but persistent probing of my remarks has pressed me to try to state things more precisely and cogently. What is a supernatural hypothesis? I … [Read more...]

Science is not democratic

Republican candidate Rick Perry is being compared to George W. Bush, our most recent president from Texas. Here is one place the comparison breaks down. Perry is not campaigning to be the “Education President,” as Bush did. Whatever its merits, Bush was president when the “No child left behind” act became law. Based on Perry’s recent comments, it looks like he is more interested in leaving every child behind. When a little boy in New Hampshire was prompted by his mother to ask Perry about evoluti … [Read more...]

Joel Marks essay

Take a look at Joel Mark's short essay in the NYT; "Confessions of an Ex-Moralist."It's nice to see amoralist points of views expressed once in a while. … [Read more...]

New Chick Tract

OK, from last month, but I've been away for a while. … [Read more...]

The Meaning of ‘miracle’ – Part 3

Swinburne's description of Aquinas' concept of a 'miracle':Aquinas wrote that a 'miracle' in a wide sense is any event brought about by a rational agent in virtue of powers greater than normal human powers; and so many events brought about by demons or angels would count as miracles. But in a strict sense, he claims, a miracle is that which occurs outside the whole system of created nature; it is that which no other agent except God has the power to bring about. See Summa Theologiae, Ia.114. … [Read more...]

“DM” nailed?

"DM," who had been flooding this blog with threats (which occasionally got through the spam filter and other trapping devices), finally seems to have overreached. We'll see if he stops. It would save me some time and general headaches. … [Read more...]

Rest is a human need

At ten-years-old, while still an Orthodox Jew, I wondered why an all-powerful God had to take a day off each week to rest. I also worried about what bad things might happen to us if such a controlling God should fall asleep at the wheel of the universe. As an atheist, I now appreciate the sentiment of a perceptive biblical writer more than I did when I believed rest was a commandment from God. Occasionally the Bible gets it right, and this is one of those occasions. Regardless of theological … [Read more...]

Laws of Supernature

On his Dangerous Idea blog Victor Reppert reprints an old exchange between us (we have been going at it for over 35 years now): An Old Exchange between Keith Parsons and myself over theistic explanations This is one that appears in my paper on Hume on Miracles, Frequencies and Prior Probabilities. [Parsons] Science is unavoidably naturalistic, or atheistic if you prefer. Science operates in terms of scrutable, independently testable entities that operate in accordance with knowable … [Read more...]


CLOSE | X

HIDE | X