Robin Collins on the Fine-Tuning Argument

Sorry for another long absence. I've been working on a project, and a draft of part of it is below. I present part of Robin Collins' defense of the fine-tuning argument (FTA) and a brief response. Comments would be appreciated. Statement of Collins' Argument ...we will focus on his defense of the FTA against what Collins calls “the atheistic single universe hypothesis”: “According to the atheistic single-universe hypothesis, there is only one universe, and it is ultimately an inexplicable, ‘brut … [Read more...]

New Chick Tracts

Some Muslim stereotyping:And a generic salvation story. Africans play the lead roles, but there's nothing specially African about it. … [Read more...]

Perceiving Moral Truths? Part 2

Here is an example of moral reasoning that appears to illustrate the theistic theory of ethics and moral reasoning proposed by Dianelos Georgoudis:1. God is kind and loving. (directly perceived truth about God's moral character)2. An action is morally good if and only if it makes the moral character of the person performing the action more like God's character. (fundamental normative assumption)3. Giving generously to the poor and hungry people of the world would make my moral character more … [Read more...]

Anti-evolution political ad

For non-USAnians who might be reading this, I have to point out that all the US is not as crazy as this (Alabama). Or perhaps I should phrase that differently. We may well be all as crazy as Alabama Christian conservatives, but we're not always crazy in exactly the same ways. California-crazy is different from Alabama-crazy and so forth. … [Read more...]

High weirdness by H-Net

Academia can be a rich source of weirdness. Personally, I'm fascinated by paranormalist physics-abuse as it percolates through popular culture, and, let's face it, quite a few places outside of physics. Here's a lovely example: somebody presented a paper at a conference called "The Semiotics of Time." From the announcement on H-Net:Some scientists believe that viral DNA dispatched from an alien cosmic civilization has been transferred into the DNA of earth’s organisms. In relation to this idea o … [Read more...]

If religion were to fizzle out

Chris Hedges's column today, "After Religion Fizzles, We’re Stuck With Nietzsche" claims that mainstream Christian and Jewish religion is in decline, and that the kind of secular options that might replace religion are nothing to be enthusiastic about.I think he underestimates the resilience of religion—particularly the right wing, magical-thinking, enthusiastic forms of religion he does not have much use for. It looks like conservative Christianity and Islam will continue to go strong, e … [Read more...]

Modal logic

In every possible world, modal logic is a useless waste of time. … [Read more...]

Commonsense Atheism interview

The Conversations from the Pale Blue Dot podcast has seen it fit to air my rant about intelligent design, physics, God, and so forth. It's 45 minutes, if you want to listen. … [Read more...]