Harnessing the Internet to undermine Islam

Harnessing the Internet to undermine Islam January 27, 2009

A GROWING number of atheists in the world’s largest Muslim-majority country are using the internet to express their scepticism.
An encouraging report at the weekend by Aubrey Belford revealed that:

Scores of young Indonesian atheists have found refuge on the Internet, harnessing web tools such as social networking sites, mailing lists, blogs and wikis to communicate with like-minded people in a country where declaring there is no God can turn someone into an outcast.

Today's innocents, tomorrow's jihadis: young Indonesian Muslims doing what Muslims do best - wave placards and throw tantrums
Today's innocents, tomorrow's jihadis: young Indonesian Muslims practicing doing what Muslims do best - waving placards and throwing tantrums
The report introduced Indonesian atheists Didi and Dewi, two young women who have little patience with the beliefs of most of their countrymen.
Said Didi, a 29-year-old architect:

For me personally (going online) is just to share my thoughts and to meet people who think the same way I do, because I don’t see many in my real life. It’s easier to say that you’re gay than an atheist.

Dewi, a 21-year-old student fond of sardonic put-downs of religion and superstition, agreed. In her life in the West Java city of Bandung, she keeps her absence of piety secret from all but her closest friends.
Both women, who refused to give their real names, go online daily to debate religion with fellow atheists – and the few believers hardy enough to brave their barbs – from safely behind their computer screens.
Asked what she would be without the Internet, Didi laughed:

I would be a full-closet atheist.

It is impossible to know how many atheists there are in Indonesia, a country of 234 million people that is nearly 90 percent Muslim, and where non-believers officially don’t exist.
Every Indonesian must carry an identity card stating his or her adherence to one of six official religions  -  Protestantism, Catholicism, Islam, Buddhism, Hinduism or Confucianism
In 2004, a 35-year-old teacher from West Sumatra, known online as “XYZMan” started an email mailing list to allow atheists to discuss their beliefs. The list now has more than 350 members.
Despite the success of the mailing list, XYZMan said he is forced to keep his own atheism secret in the real world, and has already suffered the breakdown of a marriage with a Muslim woman due to his non-belief.

If everyone knew that I’m an atheist, I could lose my job, my family would hate me and also some friends. It’s also more likely that I could be physically attacked or killed because I’m a kafir (unbeliever) and my blood is halal (allowed to be spilled) according to Islam.

Although small in number, Indonesia’s online atheists have been quick to adapt to the so-called “Web 2.0” innovations of blogs, wikis and social networking sites.
Karl Karnadi, a 25-year-old Indonesian student studying in Germany who is behind many of the web projects, said:

We use every means possible (Facebook, Friendster, Multiply etc) to show our existence, and gather people.

Apart from connecting atheists, the web presence also serves to break the language barrier that leaves Indonesians unaware of prominent English-language atheist authors such as Richard Dawkins and Christopher Hitchens, Karnadi said.
The web presence also acts as a kind of support service. The Facebook group also has discussions on how to broach the subject of religion with friends and family, with most members confessing they think it wisest to keep “wearing a mask”.

Karnadi, a former church pianist who recently turned his back on Christianity, said the eventual goal was to create a central website to coordinate atheists and reach out to Indonesians who have doubts about their religion.
It is a task that he conceded is much easier to do from abroad.

I have my freedom here … and I can do anything – create an atheist website, groups, criticise religion etc – openly, without being afraid of any jail sentence or any fundies that would kill me.

"Really? I always thought of karma as a 1:1 cause/effect thing.(Nothing supernatural about it, either: ..."

Exorcist plans counter-attack against witches cursing ..."
"John, if your god exists and actually created such a place as hell, no one ..."

Exorcist plans counter-attack against witches cursing ..."
"I lived in Quebec for awhile, so I know about its Catholic heritage, and how ..."

Crucifix is not a religious symbol, ..."
"You are the very definition of doublethink. You are a white SJW twit showcasing a ..."

Exorcist plans counter-attack against witches cursing ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


TRENDING AT PATHEOS Nonreligious
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • David L

    It should make athiests in the West realise just how good we have it and encourage us to offer as much support as we can.

  • valdemar

    Hear, hear, David L. Atheists in a country like Indonesia must be in the same position as freethinkers were in this country centuries ago. You simply couldn’t be honest and open for fear of reprisals. This gives the lie to the claim that Britain ‘used to be a Christian country’, when what people mean is a country where you couldn’t be anything else – unless you were prepared to suffer for it. We should support freethinkers in the Muslim world and offer all the encouragement we can.

  • Anti Relon

    Indonesians generally think for themselves instead of acting like sheep. Bravo to these breave people.

  • newspaniard

    This is a prime example of why our political representatives should protect our hard fought for rights instead of which, they allow them to be eroded at the behest of a vocal, foreign minority. (And I’m not just talking about the bunch of corrupt clowns working in Brussels).

  • Thanks a lot for putting the articles here, and for all the comments and supports.

  • Callisto

    quote: ‘If everyone knew that I’m an atheist, I could lose my job, my family would hate me and also some friends. It’s also more likely that I could be physically attacked or killed because I’m a kafir (unbeliever) and my blood is halal (allowed to be spilled) according to Islam.’
    Oh dear, how silly of me, I thought it was the religious who were the ones being persecuted by evil ‘militant’ atheists and rampant secularist! What a fool I’ve been, as Bob keeps saying, you know, how Xians are always being persecuted for their Xianity. you know, the really bad persecution stuff like a Xian homophobic bigot having to hand out leaflets at a gay parade, or a Xian bus driver being persecuted into driving a bus with an atheist message on it. Terrible, terrible persecution THEY have to suffer…
    yeah, pull the other one…

  • interesting how they come out of the woodwork. it can only be a good thing for free speech to come to indonesia.

  • René

    As a Dutchman who was 'married' to a Jakarta doctor and who has lived in Jakarta for some 5 years, I know all to well how pervasive Islam and its social contol are in Indonesia. I couldn't even discuss my atheism with her closest family members — who also held university degrees.
    So, kudos to these brave 'internet atheists' in Indonesia!