Insider Scoop on the Church of Scientology

If you haven’t already, check out New Yorker journalist Lawrence Wright’s story on ex-Scientologist writer-director Paul Haggis: The Apostate: Paul Haggis vs. the Church of Scientology At 26 pages, it’s long and rambling in the way of New Yorker articles, but its core is solid.

Paul Haggis is known for writing the screenplay of Million Dollar Baby, and writing and directing Crash (and being the executive producer of The Facts of Life and co-creator of Walker, Texas Ranger, kind of a mixed resume). He dropped out of the Church of Scientology in 2009. The final straw was the church’s refusal to retract its support of Proposition 8.

But there were a lot of straws before that, and the article contains 26 pages worth of them. It’s a very compelling story, because Wright does a good job of sketching Haggis. He comes across as a rootless and energetic young atheist who suddenly discovered a system that explained everything and seemed to make life easier to live.

Later on, after it had lost its sheen, he continued in Scientology despite reservations. He mentions that he felt no smarter or more “enlightened” after repeated auditings:

He noted that a Scientologist hearing this would feel, with some justification, that he had misled his auditors about his progress. But, after hundreds of hours of auditing sessions, he said, “I remember feeling I just wanted it over. I felt it wasn’t working, and figured that could be my fault, but did not want the hours of ‘repair auditing’ that they would tell me I needed to fix it. So I just went along, to my shame. I did what was easy . . . without asking them, or myself, any hard questions.”

We could play a game comparing Scientology to Fundamentalism. It seems to promote a similar mindset. There are some ironies as well:

Haggis and a friend from this circle eventually got a job writing for cartoons, including “Scooby-Doo” and “Richie Rich.”

That makes me want to see an episode of Scooby-Doo where they take the mask off of Xenu, and find that it was L. Ron Hubbard all along.

The article gets darker in the last third, when Wright starts talking about Gold Base, a Scientologist “monastery” and headquarters in California, and the abuse inflicted by higher-ups in the Scientologist chain of command. Apparently that abuse has been enough to attract the attention of the F.B.I., who are investigating the church for – get this – slave trafficking:

The laws regarding trafficking were built largely around forced prostitution, but they also pertain to slave labor. Under federal law, slavery is defined, in part, by the use of coercion, torture, starvation, imprisonment, threats, and psychological abuse. The California penal code lists several indicators that someone may be a victim of human trafficking: signs of trauma or fatigue; being afraid or unable to talk, because of censorship by others or security measures that prevent communication with others; working in one place without the freedom to move about; owing a debt to one’s employer; and not having control over identification documents. Those conditions echo the testimony of many former Sea Org members who lived at the Gold Base.

Trouble with Trolls
The Atlantic Jumps the Shark
Leaving the Phelps Clan
This Isn't Going to End Well
  • swmr1

    I took a semester of the sociology of cults and mind control at Berkeley and we dealt with Scientology for weeks. We had to read Dianetics (truly a crazy and disturbing book) and we had a guy who had just won the first successful lawsuit against Scientology speak in our class. Our professor was on his legal team. I always thought it was especially damning to be called a cult by anyone at Berkeley!

    • mrs s

      I would like the name of the professor please. Thank you.

      • Ty


        • Custador

          But she wants to sue him! SHE’LL SUE HIM IN LONDON!

      • Jabster

        Sure thing, it was Professor Yaffle, Augustus Barclay. Why do you want to know?

  • drax

    Scientology is particularly bad because it disguises itself as self-help, which is perfectly rational to a lot of people. Definitely a cult, and in my opinion, the most obviously made up religion that is followed by a substantial number of people.

  • claidheamh mor

    a rootless and energetic young atheist who suddenly discovered a system that explained everything and seemed to make life easier to live.

    I think this is the motivation behind most christians. And they (without a modicum of self-awareness) simply ASSume that everyone else wants that too, and needs the mythology of christianity inflicted on them, to soothe their angst at life’s uncertainties.

    I remember, the idea that here was the answer, that life was solved, was so appealing. I was all of 17. So yes, I do think christians are fostering immaturity, remaining babies, trying to avoid that awkward “burden” of uncertainty and responsibility.

    the abuse inflicted by higher-ups in the Scientologist chain of command.

    I have a copy of the delightful book “Life 102: What to Do When Your Guru Sues You”. There were defections and abuses in the Insight denomination of LGATS. (Large Group Awareness Trainings.)

  • Agentsmith

    To paraphrase my fundie friend: if you doubt then you are not a good Christain, Scientologist, Muslim, etc. to begin with. You faith was never that strong. It was your fault to be weak in your faith and had to leave the fold. It is not God’s, Zenu’s or the Bible’s fault that you can’t wrap your head around the illogicality ( I just made this word up) of the teaching/texts. That’s why you will need a very strong faith to be a good Christian, Scientologist, Muslim, etc, in the first place to ever hope to be a good Christian, Scientologist, Muslim, etc.

    I tried to mention to him his circular logic, then he just went on accusing me of attacking his faith and being a Satan worshipper and how by 2012 I will be left on earth to suffer the Great Torment.

    • Eric Mac

      “The Great Torment”. That sounds just irritating like endless purple nurples and pink bellies.

      I just tell people that call me a Satan worshipper that Satan is cool. He has cool colors, fire is his damn logo and everyone knows that fire is the sh*t. God…, he’s a nerd and he’s a creepy old man. Always trying to peep at my junk.