Is it possible for a community under a couple thousand people to abuse 416 children?  Contemplate this for a second.  A community less than a quarter of the size of where I grew up, and they are presently being investigated for abusing a number of children they bore equal to 75% of the number of students that attended my high school.  There are many fundamental questions surrounding this issue.  Before we get too far into the process, the Fundamentalist Latter Day Saints are not in union with the Latter Day Saints.  The Latter Day Saints as a matter policy disunion any members who are found to engage in polygamy.

Polygamy involves a lot more nuance than one would initially anticipate.  The presence of polygamy in the Old Testament certainly wasn’t a creation of Joseph Smith preserved by the FLDS.  For a comprehensive treatment on polygamy, see Pope Leo XIII’s Arcanum.  Polygamy is still an issue the Church is addressing.  A search of the Vatican will find many exhortations in various African countries.  Often the issue is included with such issues as divorce, irregular marriage, and having children out of wedlock.  A cursory examination doesn’t see it being paired with same sex marriage.  As many polygamists will note, sex has very little to do with polygamy; it is more of a societal level economic arrangement.

Another facet of outrage in this situation is marriage to adolescents.  This was aided by a sensationalistic aspect of the story claiming that there was a bed in the temple where the marriages were forced to be consumated.  For me this part of the story had too much of a what-happens-in-the-basements-of-convents quality to it.  The FLDS are presently speculating that this investigation was most likely originated by a disgruntled former member; I think this detail lends credence to that claim.  As to the marriage of adolescents, Canon Law actually addresses the situation today.

Can.  1071 §1. Except in a case of necessity, a person is not to assist without the permission of the local ordinary at: 6/ a marriage of a minor child when the parents are unaware or reasonably opposed;  [Several conditions not related to youth marriage omitted.]

Can.  1072 Pastors of souls are to take care to dissuade youth from the celebration of marriage before the age at which a person usually enters marriage according to the accepted practices of the region.

Can.  1096 §1. For matrimonial consent to exist, the contracting parties must be at least not ignorant that marriage is a permanent partnership between a man and a woman ordered to the procreation of offspring by means of some sexual cooperation.

§2. This ignorance is not presumed after puberty.

At the State level, adolescent marriage generally has been treated differently than sexual abuse of adolescents.  A barrier to adolescent marriage would be the need to get consent of the parents in some places.  Being pregnant in some places will allow you to recieve a marriage license as an adolescent.  The law seems to contemplate there being good, bad, and worse situations, and so as to avoid worse situations, it allows marital consent by adolescents.  By the same token the law attempts to protect minors from unscrupulous people by making sexual relations absent marriage to adolescents criminal.

Obviously, polygamy and adolescent marriage are seen as opposed to societal values today.  There are and will be issues addressing both of these matters with minority sects and cultures.  In addressing these issues, I think we need to be cognizant of the externalities placed upon the State.  For example, there was a case in Utah where several of the wives of a man were receiving welfare benefits.  While not particular to any community, another externality would be heavy demands placed upon law enforcement.  In each situation you aren’t dealing with a closed society, you are dealing with a society leeching off another.  In the particular case in Texas, I think it is a cruel joke to place into protective custody over 400 children because of an anonymous phone call.  By this standard are we going to start closing schools across the country?  There is plenty of risk of sexual abuse in our schools.  Perhaps we could just let them live in peace and work to integrate them into the broader society.

Update:  Perhaps due to malice, there are some who have implied that I support polygamy.  This is nonsense.  A particular person who has bemoaned his persecution on his blog for endorsing the State sanctioning homosexual unions ironically can’t bring himself to countenance the practice of polygamy, a practice that has been far more ubiquitous in the world and through out time than homosexual unions.  Since I provided a link to Pope Leo’s definitive treatment on polygamy, I figured I wouldn’t have to restate his entire argument verbatim.

"Maybe thinking about it in individual terms is exactly the problem, since we're talking about ..."

Prelude to a Conversion
"Regarding pathological altruism, remove race from the equation and think about it in individual terms. ..."

Prelude to a Conversion
"That's the thing: I don't want to get into a display of endless hand-wringing in ..."

Prelude to a Conversion
"Radical altruism, even pathological altruism, is such a bizarre phenomenon. As far as race is ..."

Prelude to a Conversion

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • ben

    Obviously the authorites in Texas have decided that it is unlawful for people to practice fundamentalist mormonism. I wish they would just be honest about that.

  • http://discalcedyooper.wordpress.com M.Z. Forrest

    Good bye Nina.

  • http://discalcedyooper.wordpress.com M.Z. Forrest

    This was basically how the Mormons originally ended up in Utah rather than New York or Illinois. An official suppression might be justified. As you say, just make it official.

  • T. Shaw

    This incident reflects material (as opposed to immaterial) progress in human rights. Last time such as this happened co-president Hillary ordered federal secret police to murder 83 women and children in Waco, TX.

  • http://roadgoeseveron.wordpress.com Henry Karlson

    T. Shaw

    I see you believe in conspiracy theories….

  • T. Shaw

    HK: Do you believe the feds there killed all those people on their personal, official authority or own volition? Just stating the obvious. Eighty three dead bodies killed by federal police . . .

    No due process, either.

    I thought you were opposed to the death penalty and a pacifist, too. Does that only apply to Bush?

  • http://roadgoeseveron.wordpress.com Henry Karlson

    T. Shaw

    I only said you believe in a conspiracy theory.

    From that you make all kinds of judgment about what I think or do not thing of what happened. Interesting, no?

  • Adam Greenwood

    I think it would be an over-reaction to temporarily take all the teenage girls into custody, but it would be defensible. As is, Texas is just oppressing religious minorities pure and simple.

    Now there’s no real depth that human wickedness won’t plumb, so its not impossible that the bed story is true, but its also not impossible and even likely that its a lie someone made up for their own purposes.

  • digbydolben

    For once I agree with one of the more hot-headed right-wingers at this blog:

    It’s much, much worse, however than “co-President Hillary” ordering the annihilation of women and children because they were accounted to be some kind of “threat”:

    The tear gas cannisters that were thrown at the resisters, and which caused their deaths in the fires that were ignited, were thrown because the FBI and the Bureau of whatever-the-hell-it-is, were tossed in there because the Feds valued the DOLLARS they were spending on each day of the siege, and the additional DOLLARS they’d have to spend to erect a better fence and starve the adults out, MORE than they valued the lives of the children who died. It was NOT just the parents’ fault that their children were incinearated. It was ALSO the fault of Janet Reno and her henchmen.

    This was supposedly the atrocity that drove Timothy McVeigh mad, and, although there is no justification for what he did, it is obvious that it was the working of a certain terrible karma.

  • Pingback: Times & Seasons » 419 Children Taken from Cohab Parents()

  • Pingback: Times & Seasons » 419 Children Taken from Cohab Parents()

  • Pingback: Times & Seasons » 419 Children Taken from Cohab Parents()