Daily Twitter: worshiping doctors

My office-mate, Sarah Moglia, tweets.  She tweets a lot.  I follow her during the day because it’s hilarious and because, occasionally, she gets something like this from @BarefootPeace.

@Mowgli3 nothing worse than atheists who worship doctors instead of priests #irony

He was, of course, chastising Sarah for placing too much trust in the opinions of doctors on the subject of medicine. 

The accusation of worship is strange.  I don’t have to think doctors are infallible to reach the fairly elementary conclusion that they’re less fallible than me on the subject of medicine, what with a dozen years of training/research and all that.  And personally, I’d rather not worship myself to such a degree that I, with zero medical training, think I know better than the experts.

No, I “worship” doctors the same way I worship airplane pilots and physicists when I’m on a plane.  Yes, the pilots and the physicists and the engineers might be wrong, but who will be the one to catch their errors, other experts or me armed with wikipedia?

To imply or to claim that I have a better grasp on medicine or aeronautics than the experts without first taking my evidence to the experts would be the apogee of arrogance.  Frankly, I have a pretty powerful imagination, but even I can’t imagine I’ve stumbled onto some argument all the world’s experts somehow never encountered while spending the equivalent of half my lifetime studying their particular subject.

If @BarefootPeace knows better, one can only wonder why he’s not the one wearing the labcoat and saving lives rather than sniping at others from the sidelines.  Other non-doctors, that is.

""Christians" aren't pushing" anything...atheists are. BTW....why do all our Founding documents end with..."in the Year ..."

Frank Turek fears me. Also he ..."
"Craig has two Ph.Ds, and the "tired arguments" are TRUTH..a tree is a tree...is that ..."

Frank Turek fears me. Also he ..."
"Well, to be fair, Craig IS a liar. Not because he believes, but because he ..."

Frank Turek fears me. Also he ..."
"Actually, I can see why Frank didn't have the time to debate you - everyone ..."

Frank Turek fears me. Also he ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment