One day [pastoring] in middle America

One day [pastoring] in middle America May 16, 2018

This is not going to be short. But it will be as honest and clear as I know how to write it.

And I’m going to start with a question I fielded recently on self-love.

Does Jesus teach self-compassion? Or was Jesus only all about compassion for “The Other” and about self-sacrificing oneself to the point of severe abuse and death?

First, one thing you are raising here is basically the feminist Christian critique of historical Christianity, which emphasized pride as the cardinal sin.

A LOT of feminist theology points out that if pride is the main sin, then we elevate self-abnegation as a virtue. But that’s problematic, because so many women are self-abnegating to the point of losing themselves.

So, in the feminist theological tradition, they find resources in Christian theology and Scripture that point out that the loss of self is as much a danger as too prideful of a self, and they see in Jesus a model for the balance or centered life that is both self-loving and self-denying. Or something like that.

To me, there’s a LOT in the gospels about Jesus’ self-love. First of all, he seems so regularly at peace and comfortable with himself.

Second, he doesn’t try to do and be everything to everyone. For example, there were probably thousands of lepers around, but he healed only a few. Similarly, when he would get overwhelmed by crowds, he would go off to quieter places to pray. He regularly changes location or context in order to care for himself and the people around him.

It is true that he ultimately sets his face for Jerusalem, and knows the consequences of that, but he prays right up until the last minute for that cup to be taken away from him. He doesn’t want to die. And it seems he is able to be as bold as he is because he loves himself AND knows he is loved by God. Remember that at his baptism, there’s the voice, “This is my beloved Son.” Given that God is Trinity, this means that self-love and self-care is built into God in Godself, as it were.

Now to the one day [pastoring] in middle America

Monday was not an easy day. Just two days prior, our church was full of mourners commemorating the life of a young member of our congregation. Our sister in Christ was remembered by most of us for her smile and her strength as an activist. She did life together so regularly with so many of us, the grief of her loss was especially profound. We wanted and needed space (and still need space) to simply mourn. But because she was also transitioning gender, some of that was highlighted, especially in the media, where news articles about her death kept emphasizing her gender identity rather than her person.

This made my function as pastor complicated. I wanted to make sure and offer comfort and support to many in the LGBTQ+ community impacted by her death, while also not over-emphasizing this one facet of her life. She was a whole person just as she was. She was baptized into Christ, and also wonderfully open to other faiths.

As the pastor, it was my role to steward a memorial that would honor her, give thanks for her life, comfort her family (who I was just getting to know) and her friends (many of whom belong either to our church, or the wider networks of which many of us were a part). And in the meantime, navigate my own grief and anguish.

Then, having mourned, my job was to wake up Sunday, shift gears, and celebrate the confirmation of our junior high youth, pray for mothers on Mother’s Day, preach a sermon about the Ascension, and enjoy the Mother’s Day holiday. None of this was a burden, because it was all honestly so joyous, and with people I love. But it did require a massive shift in my emotional and cognitive landscape.

Finally, we come to Monday, the difficult day. Arriving at 8:15 a.m. for Morning Prayer, I prayed with our little group of retirees who then stay and do “Spit and Shine” duties around the church. Having prayed with them, I went to the office to work on (in conversation with our office manager and some volunteers) the content of our new church web site.

After an hour focused on the web site, I met my fellow carpoolers for a long round trip drive to Little Rock. Why Little Rock? Well, to gather with others for the launch of the Arkansas Poor Peoples’ Campaign. So off we went, crossing the Ozark mountains down into central Arkansas.

And here’s where things get complex. We stopped at a Wendy’s for lunch. Imagine the scene. I’m standing with Lowell Grisham, the retired Episcopal rector from Fayetteville. He’s wearing a white collar. I’m wearing the same kind of collar, but mine is wrapped in a rainbow, a piece of art lovingly designed by folks from church.

A woman approaches us and asks, “What does your collar mean?” My answer: “Well, it means the same thing as his.” Point to Lowell. Smile. Prepare to explain more. She says, “Yes, but does it… mean… what I think it means?” Me: “Yes, it does, it’s a pride thing.”

End of conversation. The woman harumphs, and storms out of the Wendys.

It was then I realized we weren’t in Fayetteville anymore. And it reminded me how hard it is to live in this America when you don’t conform to the “norms.”

We continued our drive down to Little Rock. We stood in the 90 degree heat together with our community, launching the campaign with speeches and banners and signs and chants and a march that concluded with civil disobedience.

If you don’t know anything about the Poor Peoples’ Campaign, I recommend a pause at this point. Go to their web site, and read a bit around in it. Then come back.

Are you back? Great! So let me tell you, I’m in complete 100% agreement with the focus of the PPC. We have deep unaddressed issues in our nation, especially focused around race, poverty, a war economy, and environmental degradation. I probably have my own list of concerns that expand out into immigration and class, but even those issues are encompassed in various ways by the PPC. So, I’m all in on their goals.

I’m less in on the strategy, especially the civil disobedience. I’m fine supporting others when they decide to engage in civil disobedience, but I’m not yet ready myself to engage in it, at least not until such disobedience is done in order to fight against an actual unjust law.

This is where joining with others in a common cause becomes so very fraught. I’d like to design my own campaign, do it “my way.” To struggle alongside others means compromise, accompaniment, care. As we walked the streets of Little Rock on the way to the location for the civil disobedience, I kept lifting half-articulate prayers… for the safety of those who would be arrested… in confusion over my own unwillingness to get arrested… in puzzlement over why I have trouble, from my privileged perspective, seeing with eyes wide open.

And I can see two different issues. We want to build a coalition, and building a coalition means meeting people where they are at. Many people are not ready for civil disobedience. On the other hand, my community, the people with whom I identify, tend to believe we aren’t disrupting things enough. They’d like to engage in even more civil disobedience, of the disruptive kind, and I don’t disagree with them.

This is where neoliberalism comes in, and the critique of it, so now I invite you to read a quick book review, and then return. It will help you understand why I think it is so complicated to be a pastor in the 21st century, probably anywhere, but especially in middle America.

Are you back?! Great! Just in case you didn’t read the whole review, let me offer a short snippet:

The challenge of caring for souls: 

is not the effort to fix discrete personal problems or even to redress specific injustices. It is, rather, to aid people, individually and collectively, in finding their footing—to articulate the deep meanings that ground their lives and to strengthen healthy collectives and social movements that hold some residue of transcendent values. 

Rogers-Vaughn believes that much of therapy and counseling (including pastoral care) colludes with neoliberalism. He identifies collusive care as that which emphasizes

adaptation to society (rather than resistance), functioning in accord with the values of production and consumption (rather than communion and wholeness in relation to others and the earth), symptoms relief (rather than meaning-making), and accepting personal responsibility (rather than interdependent re­liance within the web of human relationships).

Our ride back to Fayetteville was highly energized. We had a lot to discuss… about neoliberalism, the efficacy of direct action, the goals of the campaign. Then suddenly, we were back at the church, and I was walking right into the pastoring stuff, needing to shift gears once again.

Because Monday night was a BBQ put on by Shine Solar, the company currently installing our solar panels at the church. Hopping out of the car, I barely have time to say goodbye to my traveling companions, when I am caught up in conversation with the Americorps volunteers currently staying at our church (yes, in addition to worship and Sunday school and offices and such, our church is also currently housing an 11-member Americorps team), then a hello to the families coming out from the sanctuary after the high school choir concert held there, then more hellos to visiting families, and congregational members hosting the event, and some conversations about the solar with the sales team from Shine Solar, and some chasing of small children whose favorite game is “get the pastor to chase us.”

Somewhere in there, I ate a burger, and eventually tried to get home in time to see the family before bedtime.

This whole time, and throughout the day (and this is an essential part of this blog post, notice that this is all woven into the day, from sun-up to sun-down), I’ve also fielded e-mails and phone calls and texts on at least the following items:

  • A family struggling through divorce
  • People grieving the death of a musician in town (the officiant is Lowell)
  • Questions about whether I believe in the actual resurrection of Jesus Christ
  • Some back and forth about the new screen for the sanctuary
  • More grief conversations
  • Planning the Interfaith Camp we’re hosting
  • Scheduling an interview for a documentary about immigration to Northwest Arkansas
  • A conversation about self-love and Christianity (I’ll post content from that below)
  • Scheduling the opera group who will be doing a special pop-up performance Pentecost Sunday

Now, I’m not complaining about any of this, mind you. The breadth of it all is part of what I love about the job. But by the time you consider the grief, the campaign, the drive, the solar, the various pastoral ministry concerns, the relational demands, the news of the day, etc. you can see just how broad the scope is of this pastoral work in the 21st century.

It’s a miracle I handle any of it correctly at all. Only by the grace of God. And I constantly fail. Like all the time.

I also happen to think that this unique combination of ministry roles all in a short few days illustrates the extent to which our congregation is figuring out how to do all of this “ministry” stuff faithfully in a dramatically shifting cultural context. Because these days, the whole preaching and praying in public thing is more fraught than ever before.

Tuesday was my day to at least kind of try to process everything. I got up right away and had coffee with Emily Linn, the director of Canopy NWA. It’s always good to sit down with her to talk. We’ve had a lot of refugees arrive in the past few weeks. We’re blessed by their presence. We’re also quite worried about the future of refugee resettlement in the United States, as the folks who currently have the power to make decisions on refugee admissions don’t seem to have the moral will to commit to significant admissions (watch for a speech from Mike Pence some time soon).

And we talked about the uptick in hate related actions against our Muslim neighbors in the past few weeks. Given that Ramadan starts this week, I spent that coffee conversation brainstorming the many ways I might be able to be a good neighbor to my Muslim friends.

Then I went to the office, worked on logistics for our trip to the national youth gathering, edited a litany for Pentecost Sunday, prayed for Palestinians, for Israel, and for all the things. Worked on the curriculum for the interfaith camp.

And then I went bowling. With our sound tech at church and some guys from church, all of whom work in the music scene in Fayetteville. We’d been trying to get together socially for a couple of months, and a lunch bowling date turned out to be the ticket. We spent the time reminiscing about their friend they’d lost (the one whose funeral Lowell was officiating). We threw heavy balls down a wooden lane and ate BLTs.

Then I came home, and went on a run, and drafted the outline of this blog post, and tried to rake leaves on a remaining section of the yard that has been neglected because life and ministry has left little time for simple, mundane work. Further illustration that I’m still trying to figure this whole thing out.

"I am "Christian" by association (and osmosis), in the choir at 6 churches over 75 ..."

Three Reasons I’m Neither Spiritual Nor ..."
"I grew up in a secular household. My family never attended church, nor did we ..."

Three Reasons I’m Neither Spiritual Nor ..."
"My perspective, fwiw, could be useful to some.Common to humanity is having meaning, purpose, and ..."

Three Reasons I’m Neither Spiritual Nor ..."
"I am close to your perspective or position--from a Catholic angle. Not sure that Jesus ..."

Three Reasons I’m Neither Spiritual Nor ..."

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!