Nazi Soldiers Indoctrinated with Darwin? Yeah, Right.

Nazi Soldiers Indoctrinated with Darwin? Yeah, Right. September 7, 2012

Koukl apologetics evolutionWhy were the Nazis so unpleasant? Because they were force-fed evolution, of course! Christian podcaster Greg Koukl thinks that he’s uncovered the missing link.

In a 2011 Stand to Reason podcast (starting at 5:00), Koukl spoke of being informed that all German soldiers during World War II were issued two books, Goethe’s Faust and a German translation of The Origin of Species. And it was Hitler himself who insisted that they get them.

About the logic behind Hitler’s assigning these books, Koukl says:

It’s because the ideas in The Origin of Species served [Hitler’s] purposes well, and if a person actually believed what Darwin taught, then they would make good Nazis.

My first complaint is that Koukl accepted the story uncritically. This story nicely supports his worldview that evolution is both harmful and wrong, so he passes it on with no fact checking. I do my best to take the opposite approach: when I find a delicious story that skewers an opponent (either a person or idea), I want to make sure that I have strong evidence so that I don’t look ridiculous after passing on flawed hearsay.

In doing my own research on books issued to German soldiers, the only page I came across was a post in another atheist blog who’d heard the podcast and asked the very same question. That blogger raised a great point: Why issue those two books but not Hitler’s own Mein Kampf?

And remember that Nazis liked to ban books. Or burn them. The official Nazi library journal in 1935 listed twelve categories of banned books. One category was:

Writings of a philosophical and social nature whose content deals with the false scientific enlightenment of primitive Darwinism and Monism.

That Origin of Species supported Nazi thinking seems unlikely.

Let’s move on to Koukl’s ill-informed ramblings on evolution. One of Koukl’s favorite ploys is to try to tie eugenics with evolution.

First off, Darwin himself rejected eugenics. In The Descent of Man, he said, “No one who has attended to the breeding of domestic animals will doubt that [not culling the inferiors] must be highly injurious to the race of man.” Creationists enjoy quoting just the paragraph that contains this sentence and ignoring the very … next … paragraph where he overturns this argument. (I’ve written more on Creationists taking Darwin out of context here.)

Darwin rejected eugenics, Greg. Of course, you’ll quickly backpedal and argue that Darwin’s own personal opinions say nothing about the validity of evolution. Agreed! Which is why whether or not Hitler kept his copy of Origin under his pillow or had an autographed photo of Darwin on his night table says nothing about the central issue here: Is evolution the best explanation of why life is the way it is?

Which is why this entire topic is simply mudslinging.

“Hitler was bad, and Hitler and Darwin were BFFs! And Darwin was ugly! And … and he probably ate babies! And didn’t recycle!” Whether true or not, this is irrelevant.

This is what one does when one doesn’t actually have a real argument.

Science is not policy. Evolution is science (the domain of scientists), and eugenics is policy (the domain of politicians). Any scientist who advocates eugenics has left the domain of science and jumped into policy. Eugenics isn’t science, and criticism of eugenics is no criticism of science.

Which brings up the last point: Did Hitler base his eugenics policies on evolution? Koukl seems to imagine a sweet and gentle Adolf Hitler, picking up litter and helping little old ladies cross the street, being turned to the scientific Dark Side after reading Darwin. But we don’t need to imagine any such nudging. Germany had plenty of anti-Semitism around already. In fact, Martin Luther himself wrote the violently anti-Semitic On the Jews and Their Lies.

This bypasses the issue: Is evolution correct? Bringing up eugenics is not only flawed but irrelevant.

It’s the white flag of surrender.

[Jews are a] base, whoring people,
that is, no people of God,
and their boast of lineage, circumcision, and law
must be accounted as filth.
— Martin Luther, On the Jews and their Lies, ch. 4

(This is a modified version of a post originally published 9/24/11.)

Photo credit: Wikipedia

"What really makes you think he wants to connect with you specifically? Faith is a ..."

The Design Argument (Fiction)
"I use the phrase "lying scribes" colloquially, in this instance, because I like to speak ..."

The Design Argument (Fiction)
"Your first link argues expert opinion is only of value if it is up to ..."

The Design Argument (Fiction)
"... but you had to add a lot of epicycles to make it fit.not as ..."

How Compelling is Christianity’s Cumulative Case?

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Pofarmer

    I think the idea is to point out people most folks wouldn’t consider evil also associated with Eugenics.

  • Pofarmer

    Let me give an example of where Eugenics would be a good thing. My wife and I are both recessive for Hurlers syndrome. We have one Son with the disease. Our two older boys are both carriers for the gene. i would highly suggest that my Sons have whoever they are seriously considering marrying also tested for the gene. Any positive hits should be avoided. Eliminating these sorts of Genetic diseases with the least amount of human suffering would be a great benefit.

    • lorasinger

      You say you have one son with the disease. This occurs in only 1 in 100,000 people on average. Does he have the typical physical appearance of a Hurler’s syndrome patient? What treatment is he receiving? What are his limitations? This is very interesting because of its rarity. In the 40 years I spent in the medical field, I never encountered even one case.

      • Pofarmer

        Yes, he has some of the typical physical appearance. It varies by patient. He wound up receiving 2 bone marrow transplants a year apart starting when he was 1 year old. He now recieves treatment for specific symptoms. He has joint pain, and limited mobility. He can’t walk long distances and has trouble with fine motor skills, and some learning disability. He does the best he can to be a “normal” kid, and we do the nest we can to facilitate that.

  • 90Lew90

    It’s been said the Nazis were all given copies of Nietzsche too. Just as falsely.