Something Better than “In God We Trust”

Something Better than “In God We Trust” March 9, 2015

About a month ago, I attended a public meeting in Vancouver, Washington. The Clark County Board of Councilors had decided that, among their many pressing matters of business, priority should be given to the question of whether “In God We Trust” should go up on the wall in their public hearing room. Public testimony took half a day.

The motion didn’t pass that day, but it was raised again and passed later that month (at a meeting with fewer citizens and less press, I’m guessing). One local paper said that hundreds of staff hours were also consumed by this project.

You might say that it’s not my business to criticize the wishes of the good people of Clark County, but that’s not who was behind this. This proposal wasn’t in response to a groundswell of public demand. Rather, one council member thought that it made sense to push this motion—whether for the good of the county or as his own personal posturing I can’t say.

I won’t go into details of this process since it has been nicely handled by the Ask an Atheist podcast and the Friendly Atheist blog (1, 2, 3). Instead, I’d like to summarize a few problems with this popular initiative and suggest a better way out.

Why “In God We Trust” in public buildings is a stupid idea

The public meetings made clear why this was a bad idea. Emotions ran high, with citizen speakers on both sides drawing applause from their partisans. This is a divisive issue.

In God We Trust-America, the California organization that is pushing for “In God We Trust” displays in local government buildings nationwide, says that this is “To promote patriotism.” What then are they saying about people who dislike “In God We Trust” glaring down at them from the wall behind their elected representatives? Apparently, those citizens aren’t patriotic. In Clark County, only Christians and perhaps Jews can be patriotic. And does “In God We Trust” behind the Board of Councilors mean that the Christian god is the final arbiter for all their decisions?

More than just atheists are left out. The baggage behind this slogan makes clear that this “God” is the Christian god—so too bad for believers of other faiths—and many Christians are outraged at this kind of hijacking of their religion by politicians.

I would’ve thought that the Board would want every citizen to feel included. Not a high priority, I guess.

You just gotta put something patriotic up on the wall? Here’s a better idea.

If you’re going to do anything in this department, put up the previous motto, E Pluribus Unum. “In God We Trust” is a shapeless religious platitude that could fit 50 countries, but E Pluribus Unum—that is, “Out of Many, One”—captures the essence of the people of the United States coming from all parts of the globe to forge a single great country.

E Pluribus Unum is precisely the opposite of an exclusionary slogan, and the Seattle Chapter of the Satanic Temple has a nice way to showcase the plurality and the unity. Click their proposed image below to read more on their Facebook page.

pluribus

You have confused a War on Religion
with not getting everything you want.
— Jon Stewart

Image credit: Wikipedia

"The small churches are no different to the mega churches when it comes to fake ..."

Silver-Bullet Argument #26: Jesus Was Wrong ..."
"I really don’t know much about Joshua and Gibeon.Figures.Anyway, sure, I believe it.And Mo rode ..."

Gospels vs. the Perfect Miracle Claim
"Really?The Miracle of the Sun?Talk about being gullible.That a loada ballix is easily explained.So what ..."

Gospels vs. the Perfect Miracle Claim

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


TRENDING AT PATHEOS Nonreligious
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • MNb

    “this is “To promote patriotism.””
    So God is only with American christians, I suppose.
    Suriname is an equally religious and equally religious country. Official mott:: Justice – Duty -Loyalty. Unofficial motto: Unity in Diversity.
    It’s not hard to express inclusive patriotism.

    • So God is only with American christians, I suppose.

      Well, yeah. No need to suppose–God is obviously on the side of ‘Merica.

      • Marv B.

        America, one nation under SCIENCE!

      • MNb

        So much for the claim of “Universal Religion”. Really, I don’t get it.

  • Sophia Sadek

    Ever since those Stephanie Meyers vampires moved into Washington, the state has gone to the dark side.

  • Rare Bat

    “In God we trust” was first really adopted as a motto in 1956, at the height of the Cold War and Red Scare (for similar reasons as “under God” was added to the Pledge). It made its way onto coins much earlier though, in the Civil War (as a way of implying that God was on the Union side). It originated, though, way back in the Star Spangled Banner (“And this be our motto, In God is our trust.”).

    In Zod we trust!

    • wtfwjtd

      “…Kneel before Zod!”

  • RichardSRussell

    I think this idea might be OK if accompanied by the proper imagery:

    In Gods We Trust
    (They won’t love us if we don’t.)

  • wtfwjtd

    I want one of those door mats like that Sheriff’s office in Florida had made up that had “In Dog We Trust” written on it. That seems like a good compromise, and would also declare our respect admiration for our canine friends at the same time! Although, I’ve got to admit, Richard may be onto something, cats are pretty cool too, and are also worthy of our worship and respect.

  • Greg G.

    In God’s Name We Climax

  • And another reason “in God we trust” is stupid as a national motto is that it’s demonstrably false.

    • I was hoping we could replace the Dept. of Defense with a prayer team. It’d save a few bucks.

      • MNb

        What’s more, if all religious countries would do that the world would become a much better place! Let the War of Prayer begin!

      • Greg G.

        Why drop bombs when you could drop mountains or she-bears?

  • Ingeborg Nordén

    The Cold War is over, and America’s biggest political enemies are extreme theists now. I’m behind “E pluribus unum” 100 per cent!