John Hagee is that car crash you should turn away from but still find fascinating. We’re closing in on five years since the end of his four blood moons period (four lunar eclipses, six months apart).
Hagee said, without evidence, “God is literally screaming at the world, ‘I’m coming soon,’ ” and “The coming four blood moons points to a world-shaking event that will happen between April 2014 and October 2015.” And yet nothing happened, and the earth is spinning pretty much like it did before the dreaded blood moons. “Four blood moons” was an invented concept. It’s not biblical.
You want a world-shaking event? The world has experienced close to a million deaths from COVID-19, and we can only guess how much longer it will continue. God couldn’t deliver a pandemic when he was supposed to, and even this one isn’t that big a deal compared to World War II, the Black Death, or God’s global flood.
I’m not surprised that Hagee didn’t have the courage to admit his error. What did surprise me, though, is that he didn’t simply ignore reality and declare victory. That’s what the Seventh-day Adventist Church did when it formed out of the ashes of the Millerite movement and its embarrassing prediction of the end of the world in 1844. That’s what the Jehovah’s Witnesses did after the failure of their prediction that the world as we knew it would end in 1914.
Instead, Hagee proceeded as if nothing happened, as if milking this two-year prediction to its decrepit close and then moving on to some new invented opportunity for hysteria is simply what a televangelist does.
Pythia, the Oracle of Delphi
Let’s compare Hagee with another famous prophet. The Oracle of Delphi, just one of many oracles in Ancient Greece, was an institution for over a thousand years. The priestess holding the position “was among [the] most powerful women of the classical world” (Wikipedia).
When Athens saw the mighty Persian army advancing in 480 BCE, held only briefly at Thermopylae (a battle celebrated in the 2006 film 300), the Oracle famously told Athens that a “wooden wall” would save them. But what did that mean? A literal wooden wall? A forest? They decided instead that it meant their fleet of wooden triremes, and their naval action was indeed key to turning back the Persians.
About sixty years earlier, King Croesus of Lydia also sought advice from the Oracle. His question was about the wisdom of attacking Persia. The response: “If you cross the river, a great empire will be destroyed.” Thinking that the great empire to be destroyed was Persia, he attacked. Unfortunately, the great empire that was destroyed was his own.
The wisdom at the time declared that the Oracle might be ambiguous but was never wrong. If something bad happened, the fault was your own for misunderstanding.
Sound familiar? That’s what we see from Christians: the Bible and God are never wrong, and if something bad happens, the fault was yours. At worst, the prophet takes the blame and the Bible that he used as his source is unscathed. And yet when does a modern prophet ever take any blame?
Jim Bakker also rode the blood-moon gravy train. Ten weeks after the fourth moon fizzle, he said, “People, it’s all happening, but we’re not looking.” He needs to keep the flock in fear so that they keep buying his buckets of end times provisions.
Another prophet gobbling up scraps from the blood moons flop was Jonathan Cahn. His angle was that the last year in the seven-year Jewish cycle, the Shemitah year, ended near the fourth blood moon (more or less), and that this presaged a financial collapse. But Cahn can’t say those three little words that are difficult for so many men, “I was wrong,” and he doubled down on his claim in the aftermath. He declared victory by arguing that worldwide financial markets in 2015 had the worst performance . . . since 2008.
That’s it? That’s the world-ending event that God was eager to tell us about?
What’s up with Hagee? At his web site, just after the final blood moon, there was nothing about reading the entrails to see what God was trying to tell us. There was neither a declaration of victory nor an admission that he was wrong. What was especially surprising (kidding) was the lack of any offer to compensate people who bought his book, sat through his movie, or made any financial donation due to the blood moons hysteria. Immediately after the final blood moon, he tried to change the subject by flogging a new book.
We can all breathe easy—John Hagee, Inc. is back to normal, and all we find at the site are upcoming conferences, rallies, and tours; invitations to prayer requests; pleas for money; and encouragement to shop at the online store.
Hagee has lost all credibility with any thoughtful person. You don’t get more than one chance. Even the Bible agrees:
The prophet who speaks a word presumptuously in My name which I have not commanded him to speak, or which he speaks in the name of other gods, that prophet shall die. (Deuteronomy 18:20)
But Hagee is simply un-embarrassable. The tragedy is that the rubes in his flock let him get away with it.
One silver lining of the prophecy insanity is watching the various end times prophets go at each other. Jennifer LeClaire, senior editor of Charisma magazine, sees the lack of accountability in Hagee’s case with about as much disdain as I do. Though she might then turn around and play up some other groundless prophecy herself, on this point she’s on target.
I’ll celebrate this rare moment of concord by giving her the last word. Remember, this is from the Christian editor of a magazine devoted to Christian prophecy:
Why do we make excuses for these prophets? Why is there no repentance? No apology? No accountability? . . . .
Where is the repentance in the prophetic ministry? Why is it OK to get up on a megaplatform and prophesy things with specific [dates] with no way of escape and move on to the next megaplatform (or Internet platform) without ever looking back at the mess you left behind? Why is it OK to charge for personal prophesy at the altar? Why is it OK to scare people half to death in the name of Jesus?
but most of them pick themselves up and hurry off
as if nothing had happened.
— Winston Churchill
(This is an update of a post that originally appeared 4/14/16.)