Republican Myths About Robert Bork

Republican Myths About Robert Bork May 29, 2009

Tom Korologos, a Reagan administration aide who helped Robert Bork in his confirmation fight, peddles some well worn myths about the Bork nomination in this op-ed in the Washington Post. Like this one:

The Reagan White House, as well as Judge Bork himself, asked me to assist with his confirmation. Bork had literally written the textbook on antitrust law while a professor at Yale Law School; he was a former Solicitor General as well as a federal circuit judge; and he had perhaps the most brilliant legal mind of his era. I thought we were in for a fairly routine confirmation.

Boy, was I wrong.

Bork’s problem? He was conservative.

No, that was not Bork’s problem. If it was just because he was a conservative, then how does Korologos explain the overwhelming confirmation of Justice Scalia just a year earlier? Scalia was confirmed 98-0 (and the two abstentions were both Republicans). Or that of John Roberts, also a conservative, who was confirmed 78-22?

Heck, even Clarence Thomas, who was every bit as conservative and far more controversial because of the nature of the hearings, still got confirmed by a 52-48 vote. Yet Bork couldn’t. And Korologos wants people to believe that the only reason was because he was a conservative? That’s quite ridiculous.

Bork was voted down not because he was a mere conservative but because he took some incredibly radical positions on the law, like claiming that the First Amendment only protects explicitly political speech and provided no protection for non-political speech like literature, poetry, scientific writing and so forth. That’s not just a conservative position, it’s an absolutely insane position.

"True, but Artor's said that he's pretty much an alcohol teetotaler."

Trump’s Latest Incoherent Rant
"We might need another underground railroad."

Trump Revoking California’s Right to Have ..."
"Based on his diet Trump wouldn't know a vitamin if it kicked him in the ..."

Trump’s Latest Incoherent Rant
"It's a common trope nowadays that Trump, unbelievably, makes us think of the days of ..."

Trump’s Latest Incoherent Rant

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment