David Barton Wants to Sue Me

David Barton Wants to Sue Me December 22, 2014

For the fourth time, the Worldnetdaily has mentioned me in an article (not counting once when Joseph Farah quoted me but didn’t use my name). It’s the least they could do for all the attention I bring them. This time it’s an article about David Barton winning a $1 million settlement in a defamation suit. And he sounds like he wants to sue me and several others as well.

David Barton critics beware: There’s now a price to pay if you want to defame the popular historian, author and speaker with false and outlandish charges.

Barton won a $1 million defamation judgment in August against two left-leaning candidates for the Texas State Board of Education. The pair, Rebecca Bell-Metereau and Judy Jennings, charged in a 2010 campaign video that Barton, a consultant to the Board, was “known for speaking at white-supremacist rallies.”

That highly charged claim stems from two 1991 speeches Barton gave to groups linked to the racist and anti-Semitic “Christian Identity” movement. Barton, recognized as a strong friend of Israel, acknowledges speaking to the groups but said in court filings he did not know in advance about the racist ideology of his hosts…

Chris Rodda, author of “Liars For Jesus: The Religious Right’s Alternate Version of American History,” invited Barton to sue her, too, after he went after Bell-Metereau, Jennings, and Smith.

“I’m feeling a bit left out here,” Rodda told her FreeThoughtBlogs.com readers in September 2011. “I’ve worked very hard to spread the word that Barton is a liar. … What else do I have to do to get him to sue ME?”

Rodda responded to news about Barton’s legal success with a lively statement for WND, proclaiming she found it “unfathomably ironic and completely outrageous” that “David Barton, a man who has made a career of lying about others,” has won a defamation lawsuit…

A favored target of the secular left for decades, Barton considered a lawsuit 20 years ago “on some very easy to disprove lies.” However, as a public figure, he needed to do more than show that truth was on his side. He also had to demonstrate economic harm to prevail in court. And that, he said, meant hiring an economist for $100,000 to document financial damage.

“We dropped pursuing anything at that time,” Barton recalled, “but over the last 20 years, it has continued to grow and snowball and one unrebutted, uncontested lie – because nothing happened – became bigger and greater, so people added more as they repeated themselves.”

Examples abound. Blogger Fred Clark labels Barton an “outrageous liar” in a 2013 Patheos post. A Crooks and Liars blogpost from 2012 calls Barton a “Liar and a Rat Fink.” Unnamed Barton critics launched their own Facebook page, “David Barton and WallBuilders Are Liars,” and atheist Ed Brayton vented on Nov. 28, “David Barton is simply one of the most shameless liars in this country.”

And that he is. I’ll gladly join Chris Rodda in double dog daring Barton to sue me. Please sue me. Please please please please please. It won’t end well for him. Unlike a couple others he has successfully sued, I’ve focused only on the fact — undeniable — that he shamelessly lies about the founding fathers and other subjects. And I would be more than happy to prove that in court. And to file an anti-SLAPP suit (Texas’ statute on this is particularly strong, by the way) and take some of that million dollars he just won. Bring it on, Mr. Barton. I’d love to see you in court.

"Anyone who would believe all of the lies from CNN and MSNBC are dummies."

Root: Hillary Should Be Hung for ..."
"So you actually believe that the people of this world has the power to change ..."

Trump’s Incoherent Gibberish on Global Warming
"How many cases of COVID-19 have there been in our prisons? How many deaths?I think ..."

Saying Goodbye for the Last Time
"You're pretty dumb if you think action films are the entirety of culture. Or even ..."

The Problem is Toxic Masculinity, Not ..."

Browse Our Archives