Reynolds Price and Me: The Tale of Two Rhodes Scholars

Reynolds Price and Me: The Tale of Two Rhodes Scholars January 4, 2013

Part Two
Guest Post

By Casey N. Cep

Continued from yesterday.

 Years passed and fewer and fewer folks compared me to Reynolds Price, but I found myself returning to his work in 2011, the year he died. Price passed in January and that summer I served as hospital chaplain.  Within a week of starting at the hospital, I went looking for one of Price’s books. After A Palpable God, Price had mostly left religion alone, writing novels, stories, plays, and even a little advertising copy.

While his characters experienced spirituality and interrogated belief, Price himself went years before wrestling with his own angels. He called the ordeal that returned his pen to matters of faith “a mid-life collision with cancer and paralysis.”

His memoir of the spinal cancer that left him paraplegic is titled A Whole New Life (1994). All the painful symptoms, surgeries, rounds of radiation, and cycles of rehabilitation are chronicled for readers who follow Price’s move from despair to hope.

That move is what interested me during my summer chaplaincy. I have been blessed with good health, but alongside my bright, beautiful patients who were struggling with terminal diagnoses, I wanted to remember how Price survived his ordeal.

What I found was the moment, one early morning in July of 1984, when Price says he met Jesus Christ. Neither dream nor vision, the encounter was, according to Price, a real meeting. Asleep with his disciples along the shores of the Sea of Galilee, Jesus wakes only to call Price towards him. “I felt no shock or fear,” Price remembers, and then describes how:

Jesus silently took up handfuls of water and poured them over my head and back till water ran down my puckered scar. Then he spoke once—“Your sins are forgiven”—and turned to shore again, done with me.

 I came on behind him, thinking in standard greedy fashion, It’s not my sins I’m worried about. So to Jesus’ receding back I had the gall to say “Am I also cured?”

 He turned to face me, no sign of a smile, and finally said two words—“That too.” Then he climbed from the water, not looking round, really done with me.

 I followed him and then, with no palpable seam in the texture of time or place, I was home again in my wide bed.

Price continued with medical treatment and ultimately lost the use of his legs. He lived the rest of his life in a wheelchair, but continually told the story of his healing by Christ.

That healing interested me as a chaplain and as a Christian. And I found myself admiring Price’s willingness to engage old texts and seek answers for ancient questions that seem, so often, to go unanswered.

After A Whole New Life, I read for the first time another one of Price’s spiritual works, which emerged from a letter he received from a young medical student forced to leave school.

Dying of cancer, the student had read Price’s memoir and wrote to ask more about God and suffering. Price responded first with private letters, but then with public lectures that were published as Letter to a Man in the Fire: Does God Exist and Does He Care? (1999). Price said he was willing to address “the bottomless mystery of suffering,” but only as a believer.

“My belief in a Creator,” he wrote, “derives largely from detailed and overpowering personal intuition, an unshakable hunch, and a set of demonstrations that go far back in my consciousness.”

Oh, how familiar that unshakable hunch.

I, too, had felt it as a child when lighting candles as an acolyte in my home church, as a teenager praying by the tombstone of grandparents I never met, as an adult reading the scriptures from the wings of a brass eagle lectern in the Magdalen College Chapel, and so many other places. Price’s demonstrations were many during my summer chaplaincy, when I listened to the last breaths of the dying and held the hands of the bereaved.

It pains me to know that Price considered himself “a literal outlaw” of Christian churches because of his homosexuality. In one of his final books, A Serious Way of Wondering: The Ethics of Jesus Imagined (2003), Price confessed “though I’m not a churchgoer, for more than sixty years I’ve read widely in the life and teachings of Jesus; and since at least the age of nine, I’ve thought of myself as a Christian.”

Like the mystic Simone Weil, who resigned herself to “the conclusion that my vocation is to be a Christian outside the Church,” Price found his community with Christ beyond the sanctuary.

I never met Reynolds Price, but I carry his meeting with Christ in my consciousness, hold the words of his translations in my heart. Here was a writer, who many assumed would appeal to me for all his imaginary worlds, but who I only ever understood as a brother in the faith.

Pained as I am that he felt himself an outlaw of Christianity, I cherish the knowledge that he and I meet forever in the communion of saints.

 Casey N. Cep is a writer from the Eastern Shore of Maryland. Follow her on Twitter @cncep.

Portrait of Reynolds Price above by Will Wilson. 

"I an confused by the use of "aural" here: "In The Gutenberg Galaxy, he explained ..."

The Gutenberg Imagination
"My friend is looking for a Pepper Smith he served in the army with, was ..."

The Love Song of Pepper Smith
"Jesus love you dear sneha abraham dear not he will with you forever amen"

Take, Eat

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!

What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment
  • Catherine Tangney

    Love this thoughtful piece! – and the icons in the beautiful photo of Price…

  • I regret the truth that until I read Andrew Sullivan’s post today on his blog, The Dish, I had never heard of Reynolds Price. In the last two hours since my initial reading of his post, then yours, a few other stories about Price and finally returning to yours, I feel an odd kinship with someone whose life ended before I ever knew he had lived. And now I want to know more and read more because, from what I’ve read in this short time, we are ‘kin’ in the similarity of our experiences.

    I have a deep and abiding faith in God and in His Son, Jesus. I, too, grew up in the Methodist Church, and although I no longer attend any organized congregation, I consider myself as devout as ever — perhaps moreso. Like, Price, I am a renegade — an outlaw. I am gay. My struggle to latch on to that truth about myself is inextricably bound to the lessons I learned from the pulpit during my most formative years. Even now, into my forty second year of life, it is something I am not completely comfortable with.

    Given what I’ve read and learned today I wish I’d come to know of Reynolds Price during those hardest days in my twenties and early thirties when my desire to disappear nearly consumed my will to live. Had I been acquainted with his work then, perhaps the nights would not have seemed so long and the shroud of guilt, shame and disappointment would have been lifted sooner. Maybe knowing him now, reading his words and becoming acquainted with his struggles, will help to remove the last remnants of that veil so that I can see more clearly who the Creator made me to be.

    Thank you for taking the time to write this beautiful piece. You should know that it has helped open a new door for me to walk through on this wonderful and tragically mixed-up journey I call my life! Many, many blessings to you in your work and in your life.