Atheist professor explains the doctrine of the Immaculate Conception

Atheist professor explains the doctrine of the Immaculate Conception December 7, 2018

OK, now I’ve seen it all from twitter.

As Campus Reform (and other sources) reported, an atheist professor from Minnesota State University, Mankato, Eric Sprankle, thought he was going to own the Christians with respect to the Incarnation, when he tweeted the following:

In response to replies that Mary indeed gave her consent in the scriptural account, he followed up:

And in doing so, unwittingly explained the doctrine of the Immaculate Conception.

After all, let’s face it, most people, especially most non-Catholics, don’t really understand what it’s all about, and think it refers to the conception of Christ, rather than the idea that Mary was herself conceived (while in an ordinary human way) without original sin, and was preserved sinless.  Why on earth would it be necessary to add on another layer that Mary was sinless?  Protestants have a hard time with this, since it all just seems a bit weird and unbiblical.  And this doctrine isn’t necessarily explained particularly well; some explanations (see this one by Catholic Answers) describe it in a way that tends to sound more like “God did a nice thing for Mary.”

But if you look at Sprankle’s objection, it falls apart if Mary, being free from sin, was uniquely enabled to give her consent without fear of the Almighty.  And given that I’d always found this one of the less-compelling doctrines of the church, I’m pleased as punch that out of all of this Me Too-ism comes an amazing, if unintended, explanation.

 

Image:  Queen Of Heaven; https://www.maxpixel.net/Queen-Of-Heaven-Iconography-Virgin-Mary-Religion-2176697

"If it is empathy it is seriously disordered empathy. Far more likely just rank cynical ..."

Parsing Mayor Lightfoot’s Inaugural Address
"Urrgh, pure leftist. I live in New York City, so I have the same crap. ..."

Parsing Mayor Lightfoot’s Inaugural Address
"Why would a lesbian take any stand on abortion?"

Parsing Mayor Lightfoot’s Inaugural Address

Browse Our Archives

Follow Us!


TRENDING AT PATHEOS Catholic
What Are Your Thoughts?leave a comment